Article ID: CBB334696047

Assumptions of Authority: The Story of Sue the T-Rex and Controversy Over Access to Fossils (2019)

unapi

Although the buying, selling, and trading of fossils has been a principle part of paleontological practice over the centuries, the commercial collection of fossils today has re-emerged into a pervasive and lucrative industry. In the United States, the number of commercial companies driving the legal, and sometimes illegal, selling of fossils is estimated to have doubled since the 1980s, and worries from academic paleontologists over this issue has increased accordingly. Indeed, some view the commercialization of fossils as one of the greatest threats to paleontology today. In this article, I address the story of “Sue”—the largest, most complete, and most expensive Tyrannosaurus rex ever excavated—whose discovery incited a series of high-profile legal battles throughout the 1990s over the question of “Who owns Sue?” Over the course of a decade, various stakeholders from academic paleontologists and fossil dealers to Native Americans, private citizens, and government officials all laid claim to Sue. In exploring this case, I argue that assumptions of authority are responsible for initiating and sustaining debates over fossil access. Here, assumptions of authority are understood as assumptions of ownership, or expertise, or in some cases both. Viewing the story from this perspective illuminates the significance of fossils as boundary objects. It also highlights the process of boundary-work by which individuals and groups constructed or deconstructed borders around Sue (specifically) and fossil access (more generally) to establish their own authority. I draw on science studies scholarship as well as literature in the professionalization, commercialization, and valuation of science to examine how assumptions of authority facilitated one of the most divisive episodes in recent paleontological history and the broader debate on the commercial collection of vertebrate fossil material in the United Sates.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB334696047/

Similar Citations

Thesis Marlena Briane Cameron; (2017)
Fossil Excavation, Museums, and Wyoming: American Paleontology, 1870-1915 (/isis/citation/CBB144188127/)

Thesis Rieppel, Lukas Benjamin; (2012)
Dinosaurs: Assembling an Icon of Science (/isis/citation/CBB001567402/)

Book Dingus, Lowell; Norell, Mark A.; (2010)
Barnum Brown: The Man Who Discovered Tyrannosaurus Rex (/isis/citation/CBB001023269/)

Article Smith, Kerri; (2012)
China's Dinosaur Hunter: The Ground Breaker (/isis/citation/CBB001320439/)

Book Lukas Rieppel; (2019)
Assembling the Dinosaur: Fossil Hunters, Tycoons, and the Making of a Spectacle (/isis/citation/CBB932931396/)

Book Ina Heumann; Holger Stoecker; Marco Tamborini; Mareike Vennen; (2018)
Dinosaurierfragmente: Zur Geschichte der Tendaguru-Expedition und ihrer Objekte, 1906-2018 (/isis/citation/CBB168836588/)

Book Ilja Nieuwland; (2019)
American Dinosaur Abroad: A Cultural History of Carnegie’s Plaster Diplodocus (/isis/citation/CBB424808631/)

Book Weishampel, David B.; White, Nadine M.; (2003)
Dinosaur Papers: 1676-1906 (/isis/citation/CBB000400872/)

Book Rich, Thomas H. V.; Rich, Pat Vickers; (2000)
Dinosaurs of darkness (/isis/citation/CBB000101955/)

Book Mayor, Adrienne; (2011)
The First Fossil Hunters: Dinosaurs, Mammoths, and Myth in Greek and Roman Times (/isis/citation/CBB001550088/)

Book Rich, Thomas H.; Vickers-Rich, Patricia; (2003)
A Century of Australian Dinosaurs (/isis/citation/CBB000950018/)

Article Lukas Rieppel; (October 2020)
How Dinosaurs Became Tyrants of the Prehistoric (/isis/citation/CBB930265407/)

Book Sliggers, Bert; (2006)
Dino's en Draken: Fossielen in Mythen en Volksgeloof (/isis/citation/CBB001031845/)

Article R. Bruce McMillan; (2016)
C. W. Beehler's Collection of Vertebrate Fossils: A Lost Legacy (/isis/citation/CBB008066555/)

Chapter T. Pointon; D. M. Martill; (2013)
Dr. Arthur Conan Doyle's Contribution to the Popularity of Pterodactyls (/isis/citation/CBB880697902/)

Authors & Contributors
Rieppel, Lukas
Rich, Thomas H. V.
T. Pointon
Cameron, Marlena Briane
Fallon, Richard
D. M. Martill
Concepts
Dinosaurs
Fossils
Paleontology
Natural history
Museums
Science and literature
Time Periods
19th century
20th century
20th century, early
Gilded Age (1870s-1900)
21st century
Ancient
Places
United States
Australia
Wyoming (U.S.)
Mediterranean region
Tanzania (Tanganyika, Zanzibar)
Americas
Institutions
University of Wyoming
Museum für Naturkunde (Berlin)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment