IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB334075144

The Smell of the Insane: Disciplining the Olfactory Domain in the Nineteenth-Century Asylum (2022)

Madeline Kearin Ryan (Author)

Historical Archaeology
Volume: 56
Issue: 4
Pages: 722-739

URI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41636-022-00378-9

DOI: 10.1007/s41636-022-00378-9

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Historical archaeology Mental health and illness Archaeology Mental Health asylums Smell; olfactory perception 19th century United States New England (U.S.)

Nineteenth-century psychiatrists targeted the olfactory domain as an avenue for intervention into the pathologies of the mind. The insane asylum aimed at literally and metaphorically sanitizing the offensive aspects of its patients as a method of “cure.” By virtue of their unpleasant and characteristic odors, which marked them as a deviation from the “fragrant” and “inodorate” elite (Classen 1997), the insane were linked to other categories of difference, such as race, ethnicity, and class. Accordingly, the asylum was nested within parallel and overlapping projects to control deviant populations through their subjection to its “sensorial regime” (Hamilakis 2014). The administrators of the Worcester State Hospital in Massachusetts faced an uphill battle in mastering the olfactory domain of their institution, having failed to anticipate the hygienic challenges posed by the concentration of a large population under a single roof. Throughout the 19th century and into the 20th, the distinctive smell of confinement was identified by patients and staff as one of the most noticeable and memorable features of their experiences at the asylum. While 19th-century psychiatrists tended to attribute this odor to difference—i.e., to the deviant and defective physiology of the insane—I argue in this article that it was the olfactory signature of institutionalization, a tangible representation of the failure to achieve an orderly sensorial regime, which was brought about largely by psychiatrists’ misdirected efforts to localize and target the disease in the individual, rather than in the system.

...More

Associated with

Article Jennifer A. Lupu; Madeline Ryan (2022) Introduction: Health and Medicine in Historical Social Contexts. Historical Archaeology (pp. 642-647). unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB334075144/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Book Katherine Fennelly; (2019)
An archaeology of lunacy : Managing madness in early nineteenth-century asylums (/isis/citation/CBB504711389/)

Article Theodore M. Porter; (2018)
Observations, Narrative, and Data in Nineteenth-Century Asylum Medicine (/isis/citation/CBB706412394/)

Article Sarah E. Beaulieu; (2022)
The Materiality of Mental Health at the Morrissey World War I Internment Camp (/isis/citation/CBB769339539/)

Article Alex D. Velez; (2022)
“The Wind Cries Mary”: The Effect of Soundscape on the Prairie-Madness Phenomenon (/isis/citation/CBB237583986/)

Article Maria Smith; (March 2023)
The Paths They Wore: Shoes on Feet at the Syracuse State School (/isis/citation/CBB475423850/)

Article Aja M. Lans; (2022)
Investigating Black Women’s Mental Health in Progressive Era New York City: A Bioarchaeological Study of Slow Violence and Landscapes of Impunity (/isis/citation/CBB692003944/)

Book Alexandra Celia Kelly; (2021)
Consuming ivory : Mercantile legacies of East Africa and New England (/isis/citation/CBB596793782/)

Article Titta Kallio-Seppä; Annemari Tranberg; (2021)
The Materiality of Odors: Experiencing Church Burials and the Urban Environment in Early Modern Northern Sweden (/isis/citation/CBB891805891/)

Article Linnea Kuglitsch; (2023)
All the Aids that Nature Can Afford: Horticulture, Healing, and Moral Reform in a Gilded Age Hospital (/isis/citation/CBB777307170/)

Book Carolyn L. White; (2020)
The archaeology of Burning Man : The rise and fall of Black Rock City (/isis/citation/CBB199619942/)

Article Ross K. Harper; (2021)
The ca. 1638 Waterman Site, Marshfield, Massachusetts: The Anatomy of a Pilgrim House (/isis/citation/CBB397201863/)

Article Karen Bescherer Metheny; (2022)
Sensory Perspectives on Maize and Identity Formation in Colonial New England (/isis/citation/CBB003179062/)

Article Meghan C.L. Howey; Christine M. DeLucia; (2022)
Spectacles of Settler Colonial Memory: Archaeological Findings from an Early Twentieth-Century “First” Settlement Pageant and Other Commemorative Terrain in New England (/isis/citation/CBB327462840/)

Article Robert M. Thorson; (2023)
Taxonomy and Nomenclature for the Stone Domain in New England (/isis/citation/CBB081931211/)

Article Meredith B. Linn; (2022)
Neither Snake Oils nor Miracle Cures: Interpreting Nineteenth-Century Patent Medicines (/isis/citation/CBB855105432/)

Article Kishān Chaleendra Amarasinghe; Rashmila Vidulani Bandara; (2022)
Death and Grief in Ceylon in the Nineteenth Century: A Case Study on the British Garrison Cemetery in Kandy (/isis/citation/CBB794271356/)

Article Gwendolyn Martin-Apostolatos; (2022)
The High Cost of Living: Death and Social Identity of Missouri’s Historic Columbia Cemetery (/isis/citation/CBB920065260/)

Article V. Camille Westmont; (2022)
Social Engineering at the Company Home Hearth: Coal Company Use of Architecture to Control Domestic Spaces in the Pennsylvania Anthracite Region, 1866–1889 (/isis/citation/CBB160614733/)

Article Jade W. Luiz; (2022)
Wares of Venus: The Sensoriality of Sex for Purchase at a Nineteenth-Century Brothel in Boston, Massachusetts (/isis/citation/CBB029513140/)

Book Melanie A. Kiechle; Paul S. Sutter; (2017)
Smell Detectives: An Olfactory History of Nineteenth-Century Urban America (/isis/citation/CBB388564580/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}