Scott, Joan Wallach (Author)
Columbia University Press
Physical Details: 144
Language: English
In the face of conflict and despair, we often console ourselves by saying that history will be the judge. Today’s oppressors may escape being held responsible for their crimes, but the future will condemn them. Those who stand up for progressive values are on the right side of history. As ideas once condemned to the dustbin of history—white supremacy, hypernationalism, even fascism—return to the world, threatening democratic institutions and values, can we still hold out hope that history will render its verdict?Joan Wallach Scott critically examines the belief that history will redeem us, revealing the implicit politics of appeals to the judgment of history. She argues that the notion of a linear, ever-improving direction of history hides the persistence of power structures and hinders the pursuit of alternative futures. This vision of necessary progress perpetuates the assumption that the nation-state is the culmination of history and the ultimate source for rectifying injustice. Scott considers the Nuremberg Tribunal and South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which claimed to carry out history’s judgment on Nazism and apartheid, and contrasts them with the movement for reparations for slavery in the United States. Advocates for reparations call into question a national history that has long ignored enslavement and its racist legacies. Only by this kind of critical questioning of the place of the nation-state as the final source of history’s judgment, this book shows, can we open up room for radically different conceptions of justice.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Richard A. Cosgrove;
(2000)
Reflections On the Whig Interpretation of History
(/isis/citation/CBB012691253/)
Article
Florian Bettel;
(2018)
Ware Zukunft: Erzählung und Kommerzialisierung von Fortschrittsdenken im 19. Jahrhundert (Commodity Future: narrative and commercialization of progressive thinking in the 19th century)
(/isis/citation/CBB943804331/)
Thesis
Thomas Lalevee;
(2022)
From Perfectibility to Progress: The Search for a Science of Society in France, 1750-1850
(/isis/citation/CBB368433669/)
Article
Zoltán Boldizsár Simon;
(2019)
The Story of Humanity and the Challenge of Posthumanity
(/isis/citation/CBB050398770/)
Article
Alexander C.T. Geppert;
Tilmann Siebeneichner;
(2017)
Einleitung: ‚Lieux de l’Avenir‘. Zur Lokalgeschichte des Weltraumdenkens (Introduction: 'Lieux de l'Avenir'. On the local history of space thinking)
(/isis/citation/CBB043160935/)
Book
Michel Blay;
(2017)
Critique of the History of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB122907818/)
Book
Peter J. Bowler;
(2021)
Progress Unchained: Ideas of Evolution, Human History and the Future
(/isis/citation/CBB574268768/)
Article
O'Neill, Onora;
(2008)
Historical Trends and Human Futures
(/isis/citation/CBB000931158/)
Article
Subrata Dasgupta;
(2021)
Whiggism, creativity and the historiography of technoscience
(/isis/citation/CBB848900254/)
Article
Vyacheslav Artyukh;
(2017)
Elements of Positivism in the Ukrainian Philosophy and Culture of the Second Half of the 19th Century
(/isis/citation/CBB070290698/)
Article
Rosalind Williams;
(April 2021)
Essay: Crisis: The Emergence of Another Hazardous Concept
(/isis/citation/CBB021121481/)
Article
Katherina Kinzel;
(2017)
Wilhelm Windelband and the Problem of Relativism
(/isis/citation/CBB605899861/)
Chapter
Tonks, Paul;
(2011)
Leviathan's Defenders: Scottish Historical Discourse and the Political Economy of Progress
(/isis/citation/CBB001214724/)
Article
Allison Ksiazkiewicz;
(2020)
Bricks and Antiquarianism: Masonry and Historical Method in the Historical Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB911983578/)
Article
Adrian Currie;
Kim Sterelny;
(2017)
In Defence of Story-Telling
(/isis/citation/CBB462798357/)
Article
Paul Merchant;
(2019)
What Oral Historians and Historians of Science Can Learn from Each Other
(/isis/citation/CBB829034696/)
Book
Niccolò Guicciardini;
(2021)
Anachronisms in the History of Mathematics: Essays on the Historical Interpretation of Mathematical Texts
(/isis/citation/CBB653765922/)
Article
Cornelis, Gustaaf C.;
(2011)
Against Chronological and Impersonal Accounts of the History of Science. Towards Non-linear Didactics
(/isis/citation/CBB001220634/)
Article
Diacu, Florin;
(2013)
Mathematical Methods in the Study of Historical Chronology
(/isis/citation/CBB001211739/)
Book
Williams, Robert Chadwell;
(2013)
The Forensic Historian: Using Science to Reexamine the Past
(/isis/citation/CBB001201223/)
Be the first to comment!