IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB330937147

Practical Knowledge and the Rhetoric of Experience: Three Italian Surgeons and Their Observations (2022)

Early Science and Medicine: A Journal for the Study of Science, Technology and Medicine in the Pre-modern Period
Volume: 27
Issue: 3
Pages: 235-256

URI: https://brill.com/view/journals/esm/27/3/article-p235_1.xml

DOI: 10.1163/15733823-20220045

Outside Links

PubMed

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Physicians; doctors Communication within scientific contexts Authority of medicine Experience; witness Medical literature Surgery 18th century 17th century Italy

This article deals with early modern surgical case literature, more specifically with printed collections of observations in surgery. It examines the work of late seventeenth- to late eighteenth-century Italian practitioners from different backgrounds and of different statuses, and highlights the complexity of cognitive and social purposes pervading the genre, besides that of sharing empirical knowledge. These can be apprehended through a second look at texts and contexts, by analysing the ways in which authors selected, penned, and arranged their narratives. As the anthologies under examination show, collected observations varied significantly in focus and scope, with some seemingly designed to sustain the authoritative legacy of learned surgery, others defying a professional ethos for non-academic practitioners, and others still surveying ailments in light of hospital statistics. In fact, as this article suggests, the genre was flexible enough – and the narratives malleable enough – to adjust to changes in surgical theory and practice. In spite of new intellectual expectations, however, it was not plastic enough to take on new epistemic functions, such as reframing surgical nosology.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB330937147/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Mason, Julia M.; (2013)
Surgical Intervention: Critiquing the Representation of Breast Cancer Surgery in US Women's Magazines (/isis/citation/CBB001202124/)

Article Marian Surdacki; (2023)
Physicians and Surgeons at the Hospital of the Holy Spirit in Rome in the 17th-18th Centuries (/isis/citation/CBB437109368/)

Article Stefano Crabu; Ilenia Picardi; Valentina Turrini; (2023)
Refused-knowledge during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Mobilising Experiential Expertise for Care and Well-being (/isis/citation/CBB291581369/)

Article Maria Conforti; (2017)
Tracce campanelliane nella medicina italiana del Seicento (/isis/citation/CBB880541792/)

Article Eamon, William; (2009)
Physicians and the Reform of Popular Culture in Early Modern Europe (/isis/citation/CBB001023375/)

Book Maria Carla Garbarino; (2019)
«Per il bene dell'umanità sofrente». La chirurgia di Giovanni Alessandro Brambilla (1728-1800) (/isis/citation/CBB085640491/)

Book Diana De Rosa; (2024)
Il chirurgo di carta. Manuali e istruzioni di igiene e medicina navale nell'ottocento e inizio novecento (/isis/citation/CBB087129442/)

Book McVaugh, Michael; (2006)
The Rational Surgery of the Middle Ages (/isis/citation/CBB001020078/)

Chapter Adelino Cardoso; (2021)
Tradição e inovação na obra de médicos portugueses dos séculos XVI e XVII (/isis/citation/CBB402459450/)

Chapter Laurinda Abreu; (2021)
A presença médica portuguesa no império (séculos XVI‑XVIII): acção dos agentes políticos (/isis/citation/CBB030218394/)

Article Jennifer J. Connor; (2021)
Introduction—Case by Case: Private and Public Representations of Patients in the Grenfell Mission in Newfoundland and Labrador in the Early 20th Century (/isis/citation/CBB460031763/)

Article Allan Ingram; (2023)
Medicating Georgia: Writing Doctors in the Old South (/isis/citation/CBB842011214/)

Book Kira Robison; (2020)
Healers in the Making: Students, Physicians, and Medical Education in Medieval Bologna (/isis/citation/CBB998112939/)

Article Angelo D'Ambrosio; (2019)
'Date a la mia man, moto e virtute'. Barbieri, salassi e trattamenti sanitari nella società d’antico regime (sec. XVI-XVIII) (/isis/citation/CBB308981260/)

Book Nelli-Elena Vanzan Marchini; (1993)
Dalla scienza medica alla pratica dei corpi: Fonti e manoscritti marciani per la storia della sanita (/isis/citation/CBB987889704/)

Chapter Riccardo Gattai; Stefania Lotti; Laura Faustini; (2023)
Adelfo Masotti. A Pioneer of Diathermy-surgery and the Private Hospital (/isis/citation/CBB310386856/)

Article Maria Conforti; (2016)
Luigi Amabile, chirurgo (/isis/citation/CBB247668573/)

Article Giovanni Magno; Fabio Zampieri; Alberto Zanatta; (2022)
From pathologist to surgeon: the surgical tools inventions and techniques of Lodovico Brunetti (/isis/citation/CBB471676104/)

Chapter Tommaso Duranti; (2019)
Un mondo in formazione: la medicina a Bologna nel XIII secolo (/isis/citation/CBB927084927/)

Chapter Michael McVaugh; (2019)
Teodorico Borgognoni: From Surgeon’s Son to Surgical Author (/isis/citation/CBB676707874/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}