Devanesan, Arjun (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Volume: 79
Pages: 101189
In a new and interesting book entitled Medical Nihilism (2018), Jacob Stegenga attempts to convince us that modern medical therapies are less effective than we think. Given the heterogeneity of hypotheses in medicine and the evidence for or against them, I argue that such a decontextualised critique cannot be made unless substantially weakened. Instead, I put forward an alternative, more nuanced and defensible epistemic view of medicine. According to this view, evaluating medical evidence requires analysis of both the methods of research e.g. randomised controlled trial (RCT), and context-specific information. This is because the way a trial (even an RCT) is conducted e.g. the population recruited and how it is intervened on, will vary and will have significant effects on the likelihood of a positive outcome. Moreover, the relationship between the positive outcome of a trial and the actual effectiveness of an intervention (the trial validity) will depend on these context specific factors. I argue for this position against nihilism by showing how each of Stegenga's individual claims about medical trials (trials are biased in favour of positive outcomes etc) can be questioned by taking the context into consideration.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Donald Gillies;
(2017)
Evidence of mechanism in the evaluation of streptomycin and thalidomide
(/isis/citation/CBB434797387/)
Article
Clay Davis;
(December 2020)
Homo adhaerens: Risk and adherence in biomedical HIV prevention research
(/isis/citation/CBB559629478/)
Article
Hawgood, Barbara J.;
(2013)
Rosemary Biggs MD FRCP (1912--2001) and Katharine Dormandy MD FRCP (1926--78): from Laboratory To Treatment and Care of People with Haemophilia
(/isis/citation/CBB001200766/)
Article
Knaapen. Loes;
(October 2013)
Being ‘evidence-based’ in the absence of evidence: The management of non-evidence in guideline development
(/isis/citation/CBB444983980/)
Article
Rigal, Christelle S.;
(2008)
Neo-clinicians, Clinical Trials, and the Reorganization of Medical Research in Paris Hospitals after the Second World War: The Trajectory of Jean Bernard
(/isis/citation/CBB000931179/)
Article
Achim Rosemann;
(2019)
Alter-Standardizing Clinical Trials: The Gold Standard in the Crossfire
(/isis/citation/CBB107905760/)
Article
Kohli-Laven, Nina;
Bourret, Pascale;
Keating, Peter;
Cambrosio, Alberto;
(2011)
Cancer Clinical Trials in the Era of Genomic Signatures: Biomedical Innovation, Clinical Utility, and Regulatory-Scientific Hybrids
(/isis/citation/CBB001034675/)
Book
Keating, Peter;
Cambrosio, Alberto;
(2012)
Cancer on Trial: Oncology as a New Style of Practice
(/isis/citation/CBB001250375/)
Article
Valier, Helen;
Timmermann, Carsten;
(2008)
Clinical Trials and the Reorganization of Medical Research in Post--Second World War Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB000931178/)
Article
Jacob Stegenga;
(2015)
Measuring effectiveness
(/isis/citation/CBB861466560/)
Article
Todd M Olszewski;
(2018)
Between Bench and Bedside: Building Clinical Consensus at the NIH, 1977–2013
(/isis/citation/CBB649225500/)
Book
Tomas Matza;
(2018)
Shock Therapy: Psychology, Precarity, and Well-Being in Postsocialist Russia
(/isis/citation/CBB052329453/)
Book
Hannah Dudley-Shotwell;
(2020)
Revolutionizing Women's Healthcare: The Feminist Self-Help Movement in America
(/isis/citation/CBB446855800/)
Book
Kenneth Maes;
(2016)
The Lives of Community Health Workers: Local Labor and Global Health in Urban Ethiopia
(/isis/citation/CBB528353819/)
Article
Nikos Giatrakos;
Nikos Katzouris;
Antonios Deligiannakis;
Alexander Artikis;
Minos Garofalakis;
George Paliouras;
Holger Arndt;
Raffaele Grasso;
Ralf Klinkenberg;
Miguel Ponce De Leon;
Gian Gaetano Tartaglia;
Alfonso Valencia;
Dimitrios Zissis;
(June 2019)
Interactive Extreme-Scale Analytics: Towards Battling Cancer
(/isis/citation/CBB319384817/)
Thesis
Carpenter, Elise Audrey;
(2008)
The Social Practice of HIV Drug Therapy in Botswana, 2002--2004: Experts, Bureaucrats, and Health Care Providers
(/isis/citation/CBB001561188/)
Article
Catelijne Coopmans;
Karen M. McNamara;
(March 2020)
Care in Translation: Care-ful Research in Medical Settings
(/isis/citation/CBB435307274/)
Thesis
Renee Rose Walsh;
(2021)
Think Like a Nurse: A Qualitative Case Study in Using Nursing’s Past to Enhance the Quality of Nursing’s Future
(/isis/citation/CBB165406509/)
Book
Halliwell, Martin;
(2013)
Therapeutic Revolutions: Medicine, Psychiatry, and American Culture, 1945--1970
(/isis/citation/CBB001201281/)
Chapter
Bhushan Patwardhan;
Gururaj Mutalik;
Girish Tillu;
(2015)
Evidence-Based Medicine and Ayurveda
(/isis/citation/CBB209876516/)
Be the first to comment!