IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB327324379

‘Innate Nature’ and ‘Complete Nature’: The Catholic Natural Family Planning Program and the Competition of Natural Methods in Mid-1970s Korea (2020)

Seungmann Park (Author)

Korean Journal of Medical History
Volume: 29
Issue: 1
Pages: 81-120

DOI: 10.13081/kjmh.2020.29.81

URI: http://medhist.or.kr/journal/view.php?doi=10.13081/kjmh.2020.29.81

Outside Links

PubMed

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Nature Family planning Gynecology Roman Catholic Church 20th century, late Korea

This article reviews the competition of two natural family planning methods in the mid-1970s when the Catholic Natural Family Planning program was underway in Korea. The Catholic Church, emphasizing the natural law, has recommended Natural Family Planning (NFP), a method of regulating childbirth by abstinence during the fertile period, since the mid-twentieth century. However, a group of gynecologists working at St. Mary’s Hospital, a Catholic general hospital in Korea, questioned the utility of NFP. As an alternative, they proposed the method of Ovulation Regulation (OR), which regulates the menstrual cycle by inducing ovulation with steroids agents. This seemed to be no different than contraception with oral contraceptives disapproved of by the Catholic Church, but many doctors who advocated OR thought that this could be a new ‘natural’ family planning method to replace NFP. What is noteworthy here is the fact that not only NFP advocates, but also OR advocates attempted to justify their methods based on the authority of the ‘nature.’ In the debate over natural family planning methods, nature’s legitimacy was given premise, not the object of doubt. Rather, the issue was the definition of nature. First, ‘nature’ in NFP signifies ‘innate nature,’ which excludes human intervention. According to this point of view, OR with steroids agents could not be natural. On the contrary, a group of doctors who advocated OR considered nature ‘primal completeness.’ If the natural order of the menstrual cycle could be restored, the artificial intervention of the administration of steroids was not a problem. Thus, both groups defended their arguments by redefining nature, rather than raising an issue of nature itself. The competition between ‘innate nature’ and ‘complete nature,’ a proxy war between NFP and OR, resulted in the victory of the former as the meaning of nature became fixed. Advocates of NFP pointed out that OR inhibits other physiological functions in the process of inducing ovulation, suggesting that the idea of ‘complete nature’ could never be achieved. The meaning of nature could no longer be controversial. Since the intervention was unnatural, nature meant innateness, the absence of intervention. Accordingly, the Catholic Bishops of Korea approved the Billings Method, a kind of the NFP, as the official family planning method, and gynecologists at St. Mary’s Hospital of Korea also focused on the development and supplementation of the Billings Method. In short, the debate over the methods of natural family planning in mid1970s Korea was a clash of ‘innate nature’ and ‘complete nature.’ As a result, this confirmed the limitations of medical practice and reconfirmed the power of magisterium, the church’s authority over medical practice.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB327324379/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article DiMoia, John P.; (2008)
“Let's Have the Proper Number of Children and Raise Them Well!”: Family Planning and Nation-Building in South Korea, 1961--1968 (/isis/citation/CBB000930701/)

Article Hong, Yang Hee; (2013)
“Medical Knowledge” and “Tradition” of Colonial Korea: Focused on Kudo's “Gynecology”-based Knowledge (/isis/citation/CBB001213261/)

Article Kim, Sonja; (2008)
“Limiting Birth”: Birth Control in Colonial Korea (1910--1945) (/isis/citation/CBB000930700/)

Article Ehrlich, Shoshanna; (2013)
From Birth Control to Sex Control: Unruly Young Women and the Origins of the National Abstinence-Only Mandate (/isis/citation/CBB001213536/)

Article Agata Ignaciuk; (2020)
No Man’s Land? Gendering Contraception in Family Planning Advice Literature in State-Socialist Poland (1950s–1980s) (/isis/citation/CBB998240820/)

Article Jennifer Johnson; (2018)
The Origins of Family Planning in Tunisia: Reform, Public Health, and International Aid (/isis/citation/CBB662781842/)

Book Kluchin, Rebecca M.; (2009)
Fit to Be Tied: Sterilization and Reproductive Rights in America, 1950--1980 (/isis/citation/CBB000933019/)

Article Raynal, Cécile; (2009)
“La Contraception” en microsillon (/isis/citation/CBB000933413/)

Article John P. DiMoia; (2016)
“Counting One's Allies”: The Mobilization of Demography, Population, and Family Planning in East Asia, Late 1920s–Present (/isis/citation/CBB560855337/)

Article Sylwia Kuźma-Markowska; Agata Ignaciuk; (2020)
Family Planning Advice in State-Socialist Poland, 1950s–80s: Local and Transnational Exchanges (/isis/citation/CBB387865967/)

Article Nicole C. Bourbonnais; (2019)
Population Control, Family Planning, and Maternal Health Networks in the 1960s/70s: Diary of an International Consultant (/isis/citation/CBB957985292/)

Article Erika Dyck; Maureen Lux; (2021)
Population Control in the "Global North"?: Canada's Response to Indigenous Reproductive Rights and Neo-Eugenics (/isis/citation/CBB777030596/)

Article Alexandra Barmpouti; (2020)
Issues of biopolitics of reproduction in post-war Greece (/isis/citation/CBB602217086/)

Article DiMoia, John; (2013)
Blastocysts and Family Planning: IVF and Tracking a Developmental Context for Biomedical Research in Singapore (1966--1994) (/isis/citation/CBB001201762/)

Article Weisz, George; Olszynko-Gryn, Jesse; (2010)
The Theory of Epidemiologic Transition: The Origins of a Citation Classic (/isis/citation/CBB001034276/)

Article Yi-Tang Lin; (2020)
Local Actions, National Policies and International Knowledge: Family Planning and Statistical Practices in Taiwan (1949–1980s) (/isis/citation/CBB725136358/)

Book Erin Heidt-Forsythe; (2018)
Between Families and Frankenstein: The Politics of Egg Donation in the United States (/isis/citation/CBB151853995/)

Book Takeshita, Chikako; (2011)
The Global Biopolitics of the IUD: How Science Constructs Contraceptive Users and Women's Bodies (/isis/citation/CBB001250518/)

Article Malich, Lisa; (2012)
Vom Mittel der Familienplanung zum differenzierenden Lifestyle-Präparat (/isis/citation/CBB001420902/)

Book Erika Dyck; Maureen Lux; (2020)
Challenging Choices: Canada's Population Control in the 1970s (/isis/citation/CBB928803182/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}