Exploring Education Cyborg Space: Bibliographic and Metaphor Analysis of Educational Psychology and Artificial Intelligence Studies (2021)
Byoung-gyu Gong (Author)
McGurty, Iveta (Advisor)
Arizona State University
McGurty, Iveta
Physical Details: 160
Language: English
The emergence of machine intelligence, which is superior to the best human talent in some problem-solving tasks, has rendered conventional educational goals obsolete, especially in terms of enhancing human capacity in specific skills and knowledge domains. Hence, artificial intelligence (AI) has become a buzzword, espousing both crisis rhetoric and ambition to enact policy reforms in the educational policy arena. However, these policy measures are mostly based on an assumption of binary human-machine relations, focusing on exploitation, resistance, negation, or competition between humans and AI due to the limited knowledge and imagination about human-machine relationality. Setting new relations with AI and negotiating human agency with the advanced intelligent machines is a non-trivial issue; it is urgent and necessary for human survival and co-existence in the machine era. This is a new educational mandate. In this context, this research examined how the notion of human and machine intelligence has been defined in relation to one another in the intellectual history of educational psychology and AI studies, representing human and machine intelligence studies respectively. This study explored a common paradigmatic space, so-called ‘cyborg space,’ connecting the two disciplines through cross-referencing in the citation network and cross-modeling in the metaphorical semantic space. The citation network analysis confirmed the existence of cross-referencing between human and machine intelligence studies, and interdisciplinary journals conceiving human-machine interchangeability. The metaphor analysis found that the notion of human and machine intelligence has been seamlessly interwoven to be part of a theoretical continuum in the most commonly cited references. This research concluded that the educational research and policy paradigm needs to be reframed based on the fact that the underlying knowledge of human and machine intelligence is not strictly differentiated, and human intelligence is relatively provincialized within the human-machine integrated system.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Mark Coeckelbergh;
(2020)
AI Ethics
(/isis/citation/CBB990965100/)
Book
Marta Bertolaso;
Alfredo Marcos;
(2023)
Umanesimo tecnologico. Una riflessione filosofica sull'intelligenza artificiale
(/isis/citation/CBB918982351/)
Book
John Zerilli;
(2021)
A Citizen's Guide to Artificial Intelligence
(/isis/citation/CBB926539601/)
Article
Tiina Männistö-Funk;
(2022)
“One Fine Day Your Car Will Also Start to Speak”: Automotive Voices as Promises of Machine Intelligence
(/isis/citation/CBB351055297/)
Article
Rino Falcone;
(2022)
Cognizione e Sistemi Intelligenti: il ruolo della Fiducia
(/isis/citation/CBB696585814/)
Article
Daniel White;
(2019)
The Mechanics of Fear. Re-envisioning Anxiety through Emerging Technologies of Affect (Funktionsweisen der Furcht. Neue Konzepte von Angst im Kontext der emotionalen Robotik)
(/isis/citation/CBB473929187/)
Article
James Evans;
Tyler Reigeluth;
Adrian Johns;
(2023)
The Craft and Code Binary: Before, During, and After
(/isis/citation/CBB170446293/)
Article
Luisa Simonutti;
(2022)
Credere e delegare? Filosofia e religione interrogano l'intelligenza artificiale. Alcuni appunti
(/isis/citation/CBB507214301/)
Book
Roberto Pieraccini;
(2021)
AI Assistants
(/isis/citation/CBB406160431/)
Article
Laura Leondina Campanozzi;
Eugenio Guglielmelli;
Eleonora Cella;
Giampaolo Ghilardi;
Mirta Michilli;
Alfonso Molina;
Massimo Ciccozzi;
Vittoadolfo Tambone;
(December 2019)
Building Trust in Social Robotics: A Pilot Survey
(/isis/citation/CBB220307519/)
Article
Cristiano Castelfranchi;
(2022)
For a Science-oriented, Socially Responsible, and Self-aware AI: beyond Ethical Issues
(/isis/citation/CBB779365747/)
Article
Marco Maggesi;
(2022)
Una introduzione visiva al Machine Learning e al Deep Learning
(/isis/citation/CBB152236580/)
Article
Rachel Adams;
(2021)
Can artificial intelligence be decolonized?
(/isis/citation/CBB237800539/)
Article
Katina Michael;
Diana Bowman;
Meg Leta Jones;
Ramona Pringle;
(March 2018)
Robots and Socio-Ethical Implications [Guest Editorial]
(/isis/citation/CBB056930455/)
Article
Monica Riccio;
(2022)
Espressione delle emozioni, intelligenza artificiale, vacanza delle scienze umane
(/isis/citation/CBB994061050/)
Book
Emanuela Piga Bruni;
(2023)
La macchina fragile. L'inconscio artificiale fra letteratura, cinema e televisione
(/isis/citation/CBB294063311/)
Article
Rebecca Eynon;
Erin Young;
(January 2021)
Methodology, Legend, and Rhetoric: The Constructions of AI by Academia, Industry, and Policy Groups for Lifelong Learning
(/isis/citation/CBB867495051/)
Article
Jascha Bareis;
Christian Katzenbach;
(2022)
Talking AI into Being: The Narratives and Imaginaries of National AI Strategies and Their Performative Politics
(/isis/citation/CBB921773543/)
Book
Saswat Sarangi;
Pankaj Sharma;
(2018)
Artificial Intelligence: Evolution, Ethics and Public Policy
(/isis/citation/CBB532987471/)
Article
Sullivan, Jacquelyn F.;
(Summer 2006)
A Call for K–16 Engineering Education
(/isis/citation/CBB710192370/)
Be the first to comment!