This paper examines debates about the “planning of science” that took place in the 1930s and 1940s in the United States and Britain and argues for their enduring relevance to today's philosophical literature on scientific pursuitworthiness. In addition to proposing desiderata for scientific pursuit that retain philosophical interest, such as social utility, coordination between branches of science, and the comprehensive development of science as a whole, advocates of the planning of science shared a sense of the inextricable relationship between the philosophy of scientific pursuit and the political economy of science, including the structure of science funding and scientific institutions. Critics of the planning of science were alarmed by the movement's socialist political orientation and developed a rival account of scientific pursuit framed by the economic metaphor of the independent businessman or entrepreneur. Taking advantage of the red scare in the United States in the early years of the Cold War, advocates of scientific entrepreneurship seized the upper hand over advocates of science planning during the shaping of the postwar American science policy regime. According to the science-as-entrepreneurship view, the role of science policy was only to make judgments about which individuals seemed best equipped, due to their personal intellectual or moral virtues, to make decisions about pursuitworthiness. The ultimate triumph of this view over the planning of science opened up a gap between the philosophy of pursuit and the political economy of science that persists to the present day.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Grant Fisher;
(2023)
Practical pursuit in stem cell biology: Innovation, translation, and incomplete theorization
(/isis/citation/CBB484096816/)
Book
Nancy J. Turner;
(2020)
Plants, People, and Places: The Roles of Ethnobotany and Ethnoecology in Indigenous Peoples' Land Rights in Canada and Beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB548513205/)
Article
Milutin Stojanovic;
(2023)
Pursuitworthiness in urgent research: Lessons on well-ordered science from sustainability science
(/isis/citation/CBB831206486/)
Article
Eli I. Lichtenstein;
(2021)
(Mis)Understanding scientific disagreement: Success versus pursuit-worthiness in theory choice
(/isis/citation/CBB459964165/)
Article
Marina DiMarco;
Kareem Khalifa;
(2022)
Sins of inquiry: How to criticize scientific pursuits
(/isis/citation/CBB330185494/)
Article
Jamie Shaw;
(2022)
On the very idea of pursuitworthiness
(/isis/citation/CBB716870476/)
Article
Philipp Haueis;
Lena Kästner;
(2022)
Mechanistic inquiry and scientific pursuit: The case of visual processing
(/isis/citation/CBB714075790/)
Chapter
Morgan, Mary S.;
(2010)
Seeking Parts, Looking for Wholes
(/isis/citation/CBB001221458/)
Article
Stefano Furlan;
(2022)
Pursuitworthiness between daring conservatism and procrastination: Wheeler and the path towards black holes
(/isis/citation/CBB776435610/)
Article
Marcin Krasnodębski;
(2022)
Reinventing the wheel: A critical look at one-world and circular chemistries
(/isis/citation/CBB083705321/)
Article
Julie Hipperson;
(2018)
Roy Porter Student Prize Essay, Professional Entrepreneurs: Women Veterinary Surgeons as Small Business Owners in Interwar Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB539541626/)
Article
Fedorenko, N. V.;
(2010)
From Chemistry to Political Economy: Jane Marcet as Popularizer of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001211365/)
Article
Renwick, Chris;
(2011)
From Political Economy to Sociology: Francis Galton and the Social-Scientific Origins of Eugenics
(/isis/citation/CBB001024706/)
Book
Joris Mercelis;
(2020)
Beyond Bakelite: Leo Baekeland and the Business of Science and Invention
(/isis/citation/CBB912550580/)
Article
Hintz, Eric S.;
(2007)
Independent Inventors in an Era of Burgeoning Research and Development
(/isis/citation/CBB001211717/)
Article
Julia Sánchez-Dorado;
(2023)
Creativity, pursuit and epistemic tradition
(/isis/citation/CBB782498092/)
Article
Nora Hangel;
Christopher ChoGlueck;
(2023)
On the pursuitworthiness of qualitative methods in empirical philosophy of science
(/isis/citation/CBB960529736/)
Article
Rune Nyrup;
(2020)
Of Water Drops and Atomic Nuclei: Analogies and Pursuit Worthiness in Science
(/isis/citation/CBB558276725/)
Article
Pablo Ruiz de Olano;
(2023)
Confirmation, or pursuit-worthiness? Lessons from J. J. Sakurai's 1960 theory of the strong force for the debate on non-empirical physics
(/isis/citation/CBB430659500/)
Article
Torsten Wilholt;
(2022)
Epistemic interests and the objectivity of inquiry
(/isis/citation/CBB341914920/)
Be the first to comment!