Article ID: CBB311069000

Postgenomics function monism (2020)

unapi

The ENCODE project has made important new estimates of human genome functionality, now revising the percentage considered functional to more than 80%, which is in stark contrast to the received view, which estimated that less than 10% of the conserved parts of the human genome are functional. ENCODE's unorthodox use of the notion of biological function has stirred the so-called ENCODE controversy, involving conflicting views about the correct notion of function in postgenomics. The debate hinges on the traditional philosophical contrast between the causal role (CR) and selected effects (SE) approaches. In this paper, we examine the ENCODE controversy in terms of the distinction between function monism and pluralism. We propose to apply a weak etiological account to genomic function ascriptions. In this approach, we can ascribe a function to a genomic structure of an organism if and only if performing the function persists in causally contributing to the organism's and its ancestors' fitness. In comparison to the strong etiological (i.e., the selected effects) approach, the present account does not require there to be selection for the structure in question. This is a monistic approach that enables us to avoid the main difficulties of CR, as well as SE's overdependence on natural selection, while still preserving an evolutionary-constrained notion of biological functions. Our proposal is much more moderate in accommodating the estimates of the functionality of the human genome than both ENCODE's proposal itself and the views of the critics relying on a version of the SE account of functions.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB311069000/

Similar Citations

Book Ben Martynoga; (2018)
Molecular Tinkering: The Edinburgh Scientists Who Changed the Face of Modern Biology (/isis/citation/CBB777108676/)

Article Miguel García-Sancho; Rhodri Leng; Gil Viry; Mark Wong; Niki Vermeulen; James Lowe; (2022)
The Human Genome Project as a Singular Episode in the History of Genomics (/isis/citation/CBB309822518/)

Book Finkel, Elizabeth; (2012)
The Genome Generation (/isis/citation/CBB001211157/)

Article Frank, Reanne; (2015)
Back to the Future? The Emergence of a Geneticized Conceptualization of Race in Sociology (/isis/citation/CBB001510181/)

Book McElheny, Victor K.; (2010)
Drawing the Map of Life: Inside the Human Genome Project (/isis/citation/CBB001023276/)

Book Wailoo, Keith; Nelson, Alondra; Lee, Catherine Y.; (2012)
Genetics and the Unsettled Past: The Collision of DNA, Race, and History (/isis/citation/CBB001251696/)

Article Guido Barbujani; (2017)
What Genetics Has to Say about Racial Categorization of Humans (/isis/citation/CBB088477154/)

Thesis Horton, Dawn Marie; (2011)
Genetic Epistemology of Science and Scientist in the Human Genome Field (/isis/citation/CBB001567277/)

Article Oliver M. Lean; (2019)
Chemical arbitrariness and the causal role of molecular adapters (/isis/citation/CBB162430966/)

Article Tyler D. P. Brunet; W. Ford Doolittle; Joseph P. Bielawski; (2021)
The role of purifying selection in the origin and maintenance of complex function (/isis/citation/CBB268148463/)

Article Kathryn Maxson Jones; Rachel A. Ankeny; Robert Cook-Deegan; (2018)
The Bermuda Triangle: The Pragmatics, Policies, and Principles for Data Sharing in the History of the Human Genome Project (/isis/citation/CBB445174130/)

Article Soraya de Chadarevian; (2018)
Whose Turn? Chromosome Research and the Study of the Human Genome (/isis/citation/CBB174267343/)

Book Everson, Ted; (2007)
The Gene: A Historical Perspective (/isis/citation/CBB000700846/)

Article Eric D. Green; Christopher R. Donohue; (2018)
Special Issue Editors' Introduction: "Genomics and the Human Genome Project" (/isis/citation/CBB061547384/)

Essay Review Wolfe, Audra J.; (2001)
ELSI's Revenge (/isis/citation/CBB000100499/)

Book George G. Brownlee; (2014)
Fred Sanger - Double Nobel Laureate: A Biography (/isis/citation/CBB498106946/)

Authors & Contributors
Gil Viry
W. Ford Doolittle
Tyler D. P. Brunet
Brownlee, George G.
Green, Eric D.
Martynoga, Ben
Concepts
Genomics
DNA; RNA
Human genetics
Molecular biology
Genetics
Chromosomes
Time Periods
20th century, late
21st century
20th century
Places
Edinburgh
United States
Belgium
Institutions
Human Genome Project
Wellcome Trust
National Institutes of Health
Ghent University
Cambridge. University. Laboratory of Molecular Biology
National Institute of Health (U.S.)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment