Aparna Ravilochan (Author)
Apeiron: Journal for Ancient Philosophy and Science
Volume: 56
Issue: 1
Pages: 1-14
In this essay, I respond to a problem raised by Sarah Broadie in her 1987 article “Nature, Craft and Phronesis in Aristotle.” Broadie analyzes Aristotle’s famous craft analogy for natural causation in order to determine whether or not it requires importing a psychological dimension to natural teleology. She argues that it is possible to make sense of the analogy without psychology, but that the tradeoff is a conception of craft so thoroughly de-psychologized that it is rendered unrecognizable, perhaps even incoherent as a referent. I dispute this suggestion and argue, rather, that Aristotle’s insistence on removing psychology from the craft side of the analogy points to his prioritization of techne itself, rather than any particular craftsman, as primary efficient agent. The lack of psychology that characterizes a techne ensures stability and reliability in the causal process that could not be guaranteed by the idiosyncratic psychologies of various craftspeople. The same kind of stability and reliability belong to nature as an efficient cause, forming the basis of the comparison between craft and natural teleology. It is therefore the craft, not the craftsman, that must stand as analog to nature. I demonstrate the value of this revision by applying the analogy to the case of natural teleology: reproduction as depicted in Aristotle’s Generation of Animals. The result is a reading of Aristotle’s analogies that can assuage Broadie’s concerns and allow for a natural thing’s own nature to more fully inhabit its intended role as an inner source of change.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Francisco J. Gonzalez;
(2023)
From Dunamis as Active/Passive Capacity to Dunamis as Nature in Aristotle’s Metaphysics Theta
(/isis/citation/CBB494981363/)
Article
Andrade Martins, Roberto de;
(2013)
A doutrina das causas finais na Antiguidade. 2. A teleologia na natureza, segundo Aristóteles
(/isis/citation/CBB001214013/)
Article
Müller, Jörn;
(2006)
Aristoteles und der naturalistische Fehlschluß
(/isis/citation/CBB000933647/)
Article
de Andrade Martins, Roberto;
(2013)
A doutrina das causas finais na Antiguidade. 1. A teleologia na natureza, dos pré-socráticos a Platão
(/isis/citation/CBB001212573/)
Article
Bowin, John;
(2010)
Aristotle on the Unity of Change: Five Reductio Arguments in Physics viii 8
(/isis/citation/CBB001211462/)
Article
Roark, Tony;
(2004)
Why Aristotle Says There Is No Time Without Change
(/isis/citation/CBB000502258/)
Thesis
Anagnostopoulos, Andreas Harol;
(2007)
Aristotle on Change and Potentiality
(/isis/citation/CBB001561324/)
Article
Santiago Chame;
(2023)
The Non-kinetic Origins of Aristotle’s Concept of Ἐνέργεια
(/isis/citation/CBB454695173/)
Book
Gotthelf, Allan;
Leunissen, Mariska;
Beullens, Pieter;
(2012)
Teleology, First Principles and Scientific Method in Aristotle's Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB001250500/)
Book
Cooper, John Madison;
(2004)
Knowledge, Nature, and the Good: Essays on Ancient Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB000650408/)
Article
Gill, Mary Louise;
(2014)
The Limits of Teleology in Aristotle's Meteorology IV.12
(/isis/citation/CBB001421728/)
Article
Mirus, Christopher V.;
(2006)
The Homogeneous Bodies in Meteorology iv 12
(/isis/citation/CBB000670351/)
Chapter
Pellegrin, Pierre;
(2007)
Les études sur la biologie d'Aristote: un bilan provisoire
(/isis/citation/CBB001022497/)
Book
Johnson, Monte Ransome;
(2005)
Aristotle on Teleology
(/isis/citation/CBB000772093/)
Book
Leunissen, Mariska;
(2010)
Explanation and Teleology in Aristotle's Science of Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB001220104/)
Thesis
Rosen, Jacob;
(2008)
Necessity and Teleology in Aristotle's Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB001561237/)
Thesis
Bianchi, Emanuela;
(2005)
Teleology and Its Symptoms: Sexual Difference in the Aristotelian Cosmos
(/isis/citation/CBB001561906/)
Thesis
Scharle, Margaret Elizabeth;
(2005)
The Place of the Elements in Aristotle's Natural Teleology
(/isis/citation/CBB001561693/)
Article
Ignacio De Ribera-Martin;
(2019)
Movement (Kinêsis) as Efficient Cause in Aristotle’s Generation of Animals
(/isis/citation/CBB085326578/)
Article
Ebrey, David;
(2014)
Making Room for Matter: Material Causes in the Phaedo and the Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB001214197/)
Be the first to comment!