This paper concerns the development of a central tenet of modern biochemistry: that cellular metabolism coordinates biological energy supply through the cyclical making and breaking of “energy-rich” phosphate bonds. This interpretation of intermediary metabolism was comprehensively set forth in two review articles published nearly simultaneously (though independently) in early 1941 by German biochemist Fritz Lipmann and Danish biochemist Herman Kalckar. Lipmann and Kalckar first met in the early 1930s in Copenhagen, where they were in frequent contact until 1939, when both left Denmark. Despite the similar claims advanced in Lipmann’s and Kalckar’s reviews, the two men’s presentations differed substantially with respect to their descriptions of “energy-rich” phosphate bonds and their target audiences. In order to explore the circumstances behind these divergences, this paper utilizes a “parallel lives” approach. By analyzing Lipmann’s and Kalckar’s lives in parallel, particular institutional contexts emerge as having been especially significant in shaping their differing interpretations of the power of phosphate bonds. The period that Lipmann spent in muscle researcher Otto Meyerhof’s laboratory (1927–30) conditioned his physiological interpretation of the role of phosphate bonds in cellular energy metabolism. Kalckar’s time at California Institute of Technology (1939–40)—where he was in regular communication with chemists such as Linus Pauling—played the most significant role in his decision to present the power of phosphate bonds from a chemical perspective. Ultimately, an examination of the life stories behind Lipmann’s and Kalckar’s 1941 reviews illuminates how older physiological perspectives were combined with recent advances in theoretical chemistry to explain how energy flows through living organisms.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Braun, Robyn;
(2011)
Accessory Food Factors: Understanding the Catalytic Function
Article
Beintema, Jaap J.;
(2008)
The Last Month of Szent-Györgyi in Groningen
Article
Neswald, Elizabeth;
(2011)
Francis Gano Benedict's Reports of Visits to Foreign Laboratories and the Carnegie Nutrition Laboratory
Chapter
Kaasch, Michael;
(2000)
Sensation, Irrtum, Betrug? Emil Abderhalden und die Geschichte der Abwehrfermente
Article
Van der Kloot, William;
(2003)
Ernest Starling's Analysis of the Energy Balance of the German People During the Blockade, 1914--19
Article
Gerald Zon;
(2021)
Chemistry, Cyclophosphamide, Cancer Chemotherapy, and Serendipity: Sixty Years On
Article
Prebble, John N.;
(2010)
The Discovery of Oxidative Phosphorylation: A Conceptual Off-Shoot from the Study of Glycolysis
Book
Randi Hutter Epstein;
(2018)
Aroused: The History of Hormones and How They Control Just About Everything
Article
Aparna Singh;
Sonam Agrawal;
Kishor Patwardhan;
Sangeeta Gehlot;
(2023)
Overlooked contributions of Ayurveda literature to the history of physiology of digestion and metabolism
Article
Büttner, Johannes;
(2005)
Der “Chemische Lebensprozeß” gerät in den Blick der Chemiker: Die Anfänge der Physiologischen Chemie
Article
Deichmann, Ute;
Travis, Anthony S.;
(2004)
A German Influence on Science in Mandate Palestine and Israel: Chemistry and Biochemistry
Article
Mertens, Lothar;
(2003)
Nur “Zweite Wahl” oder Die Berufung Adolf Butenandts zum Direktor des KWI für Biochemie
Book
Kaufmann, Doris;
(2000)
Geschichte der Kaiser-Wilhelm-Gesellschaft im Nationalsozialismus: Bestandsaufnahme und Perspektiven der Forschung
Chapter
Kaasch, Michael;
(2002)
Von den Lehr- zu den Meisterjahren -- Emil Abderhalden in der Frühzeit der Biochemie in Berlin
Book
Deichmann, Ute;
(2001)
Flüchten, Mitmachen, Vergessen: Chemiker und Biochemiker in der NS-Zeit.
Article
Trunk, Achim;
(2006)
Biochemistry in Wartime: The Life and Lessons of Adolf Butenandt, 1936--1946
Article
Jong, Simcha;
(2006)
How Organizational Structures in Science Shape Spin-off Firms: The Biochemistry Departments of Berkeley, Stanford, and UCSF and the Birth of the Biotech Industry
Article
Douglas J. Lanska;
(2019)
The Development and Evolution of “Cerebral Thermometry”: The Physiology Underlying a Nineteenth-Century Approach to Cerebral Localization and Neurological Diagnosis
Article
Haffer, J.;
(2008)
The Origin of Modern Ornithology in Europe
Chapter
Stoff, Heiko;
(2008)
Verjüngungsrummel. Der Kampf um Wissenschaftlichkeit in den 1920er Jahren
Be the first to comment!