‘The Goddess Technology is a polyglot’: a critical review of Eric Schatzberg, Technology: critical history of a concept (2022)
Bray, Francesca (Author)
Hahn, Barbara (Author)
History and Technology
Volume: 38
Issue: 4
Pages: 275-316
Edition Details: Historiographic Essay
Language: English
The modern concept of technology, we argue, is not the product of an exclusively Western and intellectual genealogy, as proposed by Eric Schatzberg in Technology: Critical History of a Concept. Instead its emergence must be understood as the product of a worldwide ferment, polyglot dialogue and heterogenous conceptual traditions, a global assemblage whose local manifestations took shape concurrently in multiple centers. The forms taken by this new philosophy of the nature of material action cannot be understood separately from the geopolitics of industrialization, imperialism and modern nation-building. As a concept or worldview, technology is a way of thinking inseparable from praxis. An intellectual history of the idea divorced from the politics and potency of technological action on the ground conveys a false innocence about who and what counts in history of technology, and lends itself to misleadingly simple models of knowledge transfer. Here we analyze the cases of technocracy in imperial and post-war Japan, and the evolution of technology concepts in China from late imperial to Maoist times, to suggest more inclusive approaches to tracing the history of this modern keyword.
...MoreBook Eric Schatzberg (October 2018) Technology: Critical History of a Concept.
Article Eric Schatzberg (2023) Missing the mark: a response to Bray and Hahn. History and Technology (pp. 304-315).
Similar Citations
Article
Tilley;
(April 2019)
A Great (Scientific) Divergence: Synergies and Fault Lines in Global Histories of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB084948556/)
Article
Valeria Giacomin;
(2018)
The transformation of the global palm oil cluster: dynamics of cluster competition between Africa and Southeast Asia (c.1900–1970)
(/isis/citation/CBB285852664/)
Book
Mike Mason;
(2018)
Turbulent Empires: A History of Global Capitalism since 1945
(/isis/citation/CBB840357468/)
Article
Jorge Cañizares-Esguerra;
(2017)
On Ignored Global “Scientific Revolutions”
(/isis/citation/CBB557863061/)
Article
Jaehwan Hyun;
(2019)
Blood Purity and Scientific Independence: Blood Science and Postcolonial Struggles in Korea, 1926–1975
(/isis/citation/CBB792869780/)
Article
Shin, Y. J.;
Kim, J.;
(2014)
The Life of Choe Ung-Sok: With a Focus on His Design for and Role in the Health Care System Immediately after the Liberation
(/isis/citation/CBB001422428/)
Article
Fu, Daiwie;
(2007)
How Far Can East Asian STS Go?
(/isis/citation/CBB000760582/)
Article
Hong, Sungook;
(2007)
East Asian STS: Some Critical Issues
(/isis/citation/CBB000760598/)
Book
Saberi, Helen;
(2010)
Tea: A Global History
(/isis/citation/CBB001500553/)
Chapter
Anderson, Warwick;
(2010)
Biomedicine in Chinese East Asia: From Semicolonial to Postcolonial?
(/isis/citation/CBB001252508/)
Article
Ewout Frankema;
Marlous van Waijenburg;
(2023)
What about the race between education and technology in the Global South? Comparing skill premiums in colonial Africa and Asia
(/isis/citation/CBB579182681/)
Article
Oosterhout, Dianne Van;
(2008)
From Colonial to Postcolonial Irrigation Technology: Technological Romanticism and the Revival of Colonial Water Tanks in Java, Indonesia
(/isis/citation/CBB000950519/)
Book
Barbara Hahn;
(2020)
Technology in the Industrial Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB086776543/)
Book
Schlitz, Michael;
(2012)
The Money Doctors from Japan: Finance, Imperialism, and the Building of the Yen Bloc, 1895--1937
(/isis/citation/CBB001320919/)
Article
Lynteris, Christos;
(2011)
From Prussia to China: Japanese Colonial Medicine and Goto Shinpei's Combination of Medical Police and Local Self-Administration
(/isis/citation/CBB001230168/)
Article
Satofuka, Fumihiko;
(2006)
Science, War, and Colonization in East Asia: An Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB000670115/)
Article
Baichun Zhang;
(2018)
The Early Modernisation of Technology in China (1860s–1930s)
(/isis/citation/CBB912588366/)
Book
Fan, Yanqiu;
(2011)
Duo yuan xiang qian yu chuang zao zhuan hua: Taiwan gong gong wei sheng bai nian shi
(/isis/citation/CBB001213617/)
Thesis
Sakura Marcelle Christmas;
(2016)
The Cartographic Steppe: Mapping Environment and Ethnicity in Japan's Imperial Borderlands
(/isis/citation/CBB827878446/)
Article
Kuhn, Dieter;
(2006)
Reflections on the Current State and Significance of the History of East Asian Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB001021325/)
Be the first to comment!