“My Reputation is at Stake.” Humboldt's Mountain Plant Geography in the Making (1803–1825) (2023)
Renner, Susanne S. (Author)
Ulrich Päßler (Author)
Moret, Pierre (Author)
Journal of the History of Biology
Volume: 56
Issue: 1
Pages: 97-124
Alexander von Humboldt’s depictions of mountain vegetation are among the most iconic nineteenth century illustrations in the biological sciences. Here we analyse the contemporary context and empirical data for all these depictions, namely the Tableau physique des Andes (1803, 1807), the Geographiae plantarum lineamenta (1815), the Tableau physique des Îles Canaries (1817), and the Esquisse de la Géographie des plantes dans les Andes de Quito (1824/1825). We show that the Tableau physique des Andes does not reflect Humboldt and Bonpland’s field data and presents a flawed depiction of plant occurrences and vertical succession of vegetation belts, arising from Humboldt’s misreading of La Condamine’s description (1751). Humboldt's 1815 depiction, by contrast, shows a distribution of high-vegetation belts that is consistent with La Condamine’s description, while the 1824 depiction drops innovations made in 1815 and returns to simply showing numerous species’ names, thus not applying Humboldt’s own earlier zonation framework. Our analysis of contemporary reactions to Humboldt’s TPA includes Francis Hall’s posthumously published 1834 illustration of Andean plant zonation near Quito and Humboldt’s reaction to Hall’s critique. Throughout his work on plant geography, Humboldt disregarded some of his own observations, or confused them. At stake was his reputation as an innovator in the field of plant geography and a discoverer of the sequence of high-elevation vegetation belts on the world’s mountains.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Lawson, Russell M.;
(2012)
Frontier Naturalist: Jean Louis Berlandier and the Exploration of Northern Mexico and Texas
(/isis/citation/CBB001202063/)
Article
Marianne Klemun;
(2020)
‘Humboldtian Science’ and beyond. The Humboldtian way of seeing and knowing in Vienna and in Franz Unger’s and Friedrich Simony’s earth sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB712710967/)
Chapter
Jon Mathieu;
(2021)
Divergent Perception: Deserts and Mountains in Transition to Modernity, Seen through Alexander von Humboldt’s Views of Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB984242932/)
Book
Humboldt, Alexander von;
Bonpland, Aimé;
Jackson, Stephen T.;
(2009)
Essay on the Geography of Plants
(/isis/citation/CBB001020064/)
Book
Hadot, Pierre;
(1982)
Zur Idee der Naturgeheimnisse: Beim Betrachten des Widmungsblattes in den Humboldtschen Ideen zu einer Geographie der Pflanzen
(/isis/citation/CBB000007882/)
Article
Patrick Anthony;
(2018)
Mining as the Working World of Alexander von Humboldt’s Plant Geography and Vertical Cartography
(/isis/citation/CBB344446536/)
Chapter
Nicolson, Malcolm;
(1990)
Alexander von Humboldt and the geography of vegetation
(/isis/citation/CBB000045574/)
Book
Ulrich Päßler;
(2020)
Alexander von Humboldt: Geographie der Pflanzen: Unveröffentlichte Schriften aus dem Nachlass
(/isis/citation/CBB673505639/)
Article
Castrillon, Alberto;
(1992)
Alexandre de Humboldt et la géographie des plantes
(/isis/citation/CBB000029521/)
Book
Beck, Hanno;
Hein, Wolfgang-Hagen;
(1989)
Humboldts Naturgemälde der Tropenländer und Goethes ideale Landschaft: Zur ersten Darstellung der Ideen zur einer Geographie der Pflanzen. Erläuterungen zu fünf Profil-Tafeln in natürlicher Grösse
(/isis/citation/CBB000031144/)
Article
Nicolson, Malcolm;
(1987)
Alexander von Humboldt, Humboldtian science, and the origins of the study of vegetation
(/isis/citation/CBB000047978/)
Article
Hein, Wolfgang-Hagen;
(1997)
Notizen zur Humboldt-Chronologie aus seiner Flora Fribergensis
(/isis/citation/CBB000071542/)
Article
Nicolson, Malcolm;
(1996)
Humboldtian plant geography after Humboldt: The link to ecology
(/isis/citation/CBB000074970/)
Article
Kwa, Chunglin;
(2005)
Alexander von Humboldt's Invention of the Natural Landscape
(/isis/citation/CBB000670547/)
Article
Teichmann, Jūrgen;
Stinner, Arthur;
(2014)
From William Hyde Wollaston to Alexander von Humboldt---Star Spectra and Celestial Landscape
(/isis/citation/CBB001320983/)
Article
Gunilla Törnvall;
(2017)
From Copperplate to Color Lithography: On the Modernization of an Illustrated Flora 1800–1900
(/isis/citation/CBB108690573/)
Article
Tevebring, Frederika;
(2012)
Unveiling the Goddess. Artemis of Ephesus as a Symbol of Nature at the Turn of the Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001320378/)
Book
Stepan, Nancy Leys;
(2001)
Picturing Tropical Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB000102239/)
Book
Lack, H. Walter;
(2009)
Alexander von Humboldt and the Botanical Exploration of the Americas
(/isis/citation/CBB000954778/)
Book
Nasim, Omar W.;
(2013)
Observing by Hand: Sketching the Nebulae in the Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001213160/)
Be the first to comment!