Article ID: CBB288024663

Template Theories, the Rule of Parsimony, and Disregard for Irreproducibility—The Example of Linus Pauling’s Research on Antibody Formation (2021)

unapi

In 1940, Linus Pauling proposed his template theory of antibody formation, one of many such theories that rejected Paul Ehrlich’s selective theory of preformed “receptors” (antibodies), assuming instead a direct molding of antibody shapes onto that of the antigen. Pauling believed that protein shapes—independently of amino acid sequences—determined antibody specificity and biological specificity in general. His theory was informed by his pioneering work on protein structure, and it was inspired by the intuitive “rule of parsimony” and simplicity. In 1942, Pauling published his alleged success in producing specific artificial antibodies through experiments based on his 1940 theory. However, his experiments could not be reproduced by prominent immunochemists at the time, and, later, it became generally accepted that antibody specificity was not generated according to Pauling’s and others’ “instruction” template theories. A citation analysis shows that Pauling’s papers on antibody generation continue to be cited as, among other things, pioneering studies of a chemical technology called “molecular imprinting.”The examples of Pauling and other protein chemists are used in this paper to demonstrate that scientific belief, philosophical concepts, and subjective theory preferences facilitated the occurrence of irreproducibility in immunochemistry and beyond. The article points to long-term consequences for the scientific community if irreproducible results are not acknowledged. It concludes by arguing that despite the risks, e.g., for the occurrence and perpetuation of irreproducible results that they entail, subjectivity and a commitment to scientific convictions have often been pre-requisites for the generation, and holding on to, scientific innovation in the face of doubt and rejection from the scientific community.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB288024663/

Similar Citations

Article Heumann, Ina; (2013)
Linus Pauling, Roger Hayward und der Wert von Sichtbarmachungen (/isis/citation/CBB001213501/)

Book Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg; (2001)
Experimentalsysteme und epistemische Dinge: Eine Geschichte der Proteinsynthese im Reagenzglas (/isis/citation/CBB000410066/)

Article Weber, Marcel; (2002)
Incommensurability and Theory Comparison in Experimental Biology (/isis/citation/CBB000200251/)

Article García, Pío; (2015)
Computer Simulations and Experiments: In Vivo-In Vitro Conditions in Biochemistry Source (/isis/citation/CBB001551376/)

Chapter Jeffrey Allan Johnson; (2016)
From Bio-organic Chemistry to Molecular and Synthetic Biology: Fulfilling Emil Fischer’s Dream (/isis/citation/CBB095124609/)

Article Strasser, Bruno J.; Chadarevian, Soraya de; (2011)
The Comparative and the Exemplary: Revisiting the Early History of Molecular Biology (/isis/citation/CBB001036159/)

Article Nickelsen, Kärin; Graßhoff, Gerd; (2011)
In Pursuit of Formaldehyde: Causally Explanatory Models and Falsification (/isis/citation/CBB001024015/)

Article William H. Brock; David E. Lewis; (2021)
A Different Kind of Nierenstein Reaction: The Chemical Society’s Mistreatment of Maximilian Nierenstein (/isis/citation/CBB005808365/)

Article William H. Brock; David E. Lewis; (2023)
A Dark Comedy of Errors and Polemics: Nierenstein, Freudenberg and the Structure of Catechin (/isis/citation/CBB452230638/)

Article Carreta, Jorge Augusto; (2011)
Oswaldo Cruz e a controvérsia da sorologia (/isis/citation/CBB001420533/)

Book George E. Smith; Raghav Seth; (2020)
Brownian Motion and Molecular Reality (/isis/citation/CBB800777900/)

Chapter Schickore, Jutta; (2012)
Scientists' Methods Accounts: S. Weir Mitchell's Research on the Venom of Poisonous Snakes (/isis/citation/CBB001500248/)

Article Patton, Lydia; (2011)
Reconsidering Experiments (/isis/citation/CBB001230105/)

Authors & Contributors
Lewis, David E.
Brock, William H.
Raghav Seth
Matlin, Karl S.
Weber, Marcel
Strasser, Bruno J.
Concepts
Biochemistry
Experiments and experimentation
Controversies and disputes
Molecular biology
Methodology of science; scientific method
Philosophy of science
Time Periods
20th century, early
19th century
20th century, late
20th century
Places
Edinburgh
France
Great Britain
Brazil
Institutions
Rockefeller Foundation
Chemical Society, London
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment