Severini, Eleonora (Author)
Sterpetti, Fabio (Author)
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Volume: 39
Issue: 3
Pages: 27
The aim of this article is to explore the impact of Darwinism in metaethics and dispel some of the confusion surrounding it. While the prospects for a Darwinian metaethics appear to be improving, some underlying epistemological issues remain unclear. We will focus on the so-called Evolutionary Debunking Arguments (EDAs) which, when applied in metaethics, are defined as arguments that appeal to the evolutionary origins of moral beliefs so as to undermine their epistemic justification. The point is that an epistemic disanalogy can be identified in the debate on EDAs between moral beliefs and other kinds of beliefs, insofar as only the former are regarded as vulnerable to EDAs. First, we will analyze some significant debunking positions in metaethics in order to show that they do not provide adequate justification for such an epistemic disanalogy. Then, we will assess whether they can avoid the accusation of being epistemically incoherent by adopting the same evolutionary account for all kinds of beliefs. In other words, once it is argued that Darwinism has a corrosive impact on metaethics, what if its universal acid cannot be contained?
...MoreSimilar Citations
Essay Review
Lemos, John;
(2000)
Darwinian Natural Right and the Naturalistic Fallacy
(/isis/citation/CBB000110328/)
Article
Cartwright, John;
(2010)
Naturalising Ethics: The Implications of Darwinism for the Study of Moral Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001032815/)
Essay Review
Burges, Lucrecia;
(2002)
Evolutionary Epistemology: A Clue to Understand Moral Origins
(/isis/citation/CBB001566461/)
Book
Cohen, Robert S.;
Levine, Hillel;
(2000)
Maimonides and the Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB000110249/)
Book
William Boos;
Florence S. Boos;
(2018)
Metamathematics and the Philosophical Tradition
(/isis/citation/CBB060593902/)
Article
Wolfsdorf, David;
(2011-12)
Plato's Conception of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB001231746/)
Book
Evaldas Nekrašas;
(2016)
The Positive Mind: Its Development and Impact on Modernity and Postmodernity
(/isis/citation/CBB308281450/)
Book
C. C. W. Taylor;
(1999)
The Atomists: Leucippus and Democritus: Fragments
(/isis/citation/CBB857701853/)
Book
Susan James;
(2021)
Life and Death in Early Modern Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB596785213/)
Book
Matilal, Bimal Krishna;
Ganeri, Jonardon;
(2002)
Ethics and Epics: The Collected Essays of Bimal Krishna Matilal
(/isis/citation/CBB000201639/)
Essay Review
Narveson, Jan;
(2000)
Evolutionary Biology, Altruism, and Moral Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB000110348/)
Thesis
Sripada, Chandra Sekhar;
(2005)
Conceptual Foundations for the Psychology and Evolution of Morality
(/isis/citation/CBB001561694/)
Book
Rob Boddice;
(2016)
The Science of Sympathy: Morality, Evolution, and Victorian Civilization
(/isis/citation/CBB826467140/)
Book
Michael Ruse;
Robert J. Richards;
(2017)
The Cambridge Handbook of Evolutionary Ethics
(/isis/citation/CBB838749899/)
Book
Prochiantz, Alain;
(2010)
Darwin, 200 ans
(/isis/citation/CBB001024540/)
Chapter
Lefèvre, Wolfgang;
(2003)
Darwin, Marx, and Warranted Progress: Materialism and Views of Development in Nineteenth-Century Germany
(/isis/citation/CBB000430211/)
Book
Alexander, Denis R.;
Numbers, Ronald L.;
(2010)
Biology and Ideology from Descartes to Dawkins
(/isis/citation/CBB001020054/)
Chapter
Richard Weikart;
(2014)
The Role of Evolutionary Ethics in Nazi Propaganda and Worldview Training
(/isis/citation/CBB722029474/)
Book
Richards, Robert J.;
(2013)
Was Hitler a Darwinian? Disputed Questions in the History of Evolutionary Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB001213152/)
Article
Lillehammer, Hallvard;
(2003)
Debunking Morality: Evolutionary Naturalism and Moral Error Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB000340590/)
Be the first to comment!