Claire Laurier Decoteau (Author)
Kelly Underman (Author)
Social Studies of Science
Volume: 45
Issue: 4
Pages: 471-500
After 5600 families of children diagnosed with autism filed claims with the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program in the United States, the court selected ‘test’ cases consolidated into the Omnibus Autism Proceedings, held from 2007 to 2008, to examine claims that vaccines caused the development of autism. The court found all of the causation theories presented to be untenable and did not award damages to any parents. We analyze the Omnibus Autism Proceedings as a struggle within the scientific field between the scientific orthodoxy of the respondents and the heterodox position taken by the plaintiffs, suggesting that the ruling in these cases helped to shore up hegemony on autism causation. Drawing on the literature on non-knowledge, we suggest that only the respondents had enough scientific capital to strategically direct non-knowledge toward genetic research, thereby foreclosing the possibility of environmental causation of autism. The plaintiffs, who promote a non-standard ontology of autism, suggest that the science on autism remains undone and should not be circumscribed. In analyzing the Omnibus Autism Proceedings with field theory, we highlight the way in which scientific consensus-building and the setting of research agendas are the result of struggle, and we show that the strategic deployment of non-knowledge becomes a major stake in battles for scientific legitimacy and the settling of scientific controversies.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Bragesjö, Fredrik;
Hallberg, Margareta;
(2011)
Dilemmas of a Vitalizing Vaccine Market: Lessons from the MMR Vaccine/Autism Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB001034622/)
Book
Brian Deer;
(2020)
The Doctor Who Fooled the World: Andrew Wakefield’s War on Vaccines
(/isis/citation/CBB311227433/)
Book
Eugenia Tognotti;
(2020)
Vaccinare i bambini tra obbligo e persuasione: Tre secoli di controversie. Il caso dell'Italia
(/isis/citation/CBB142911314/)
Article
McKeever, Brooke Weberling;
(2013)
News Framing of Autism: Understanding Media Advocacy and the Combating Autism Act
(/isis/citation/CBB001320108/)
Article
Hollin, Gregory;
(2014)
Constructing a Social Subject: Autism and Human Sociality in the 1980s
(/isis/citation/CBB001451516/)
Article
Alessandro Demichelis;
(2018)
Understanding vaccine hesitancy: Cognitive biases and the role of trust
(/isis/citation/CBB568141355/)
Article
Derek Cameron;
(2021)
“Imagine the Perfect Vaccine”: Homeopathic Vaccine Alternatives and Vaccine Discourse in English Canada
(/isis/citation/CBB605278051/)
Book
Jonathan M. Berman;
(2020)
Anti-vaxxers: How to Challenge a Misinformed Movement
(/isis/citation/CBB269088658/)
Article
Ren, Jie;
Peters, Hans Peter;
Allgaier, Joachim;
Lo, Yin-Yueh;
(2014)
Similar Challenges but Different Responses: Media Coverage of Measles Vaccination in the UK and China
(/isis/citation/CBB001420070/)
Article
Vaught, Jeannette;
(2013)
Materia Medica: Technology, Vaccination, and Antivivisection in Jazz Age Philadelphia
(/isis/citation/CBB001201818/)
Book
Largent, Mark A.;
(2012)
Vaccine: The Debate in Modern America
(/isis/citation/CBB001213531/)
Article
Conis, Elena;
(2013)
A Mother's Responsibility: Women, Medicine, and the Rise of Contemporary Vaccine Skepticism in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB001213524/)
Chapter
Marta Tomasi;
(2018)
L’equilibrio normativo. Uno sguardo giuridico sulle vaccinazioni fra doveri collettivi e volontà individuali
(/isis/citation/CBB093564798/)
Book
Douglas W. Maynard;
Jason Turowetz;
(2022)
Autistic Intelligence: Interaction, Individuality, and the Challenges of Diagnosis
(/isis/citation/CBB247458713/)
Book
Cristina Munno;
Elena Iorio;
(2018)
Vaccini e paure. Salute pubblica, resistenze popolari
(/isis/citation/CBB068311554/)
Article
Wood, Janice Ruth;
(2008)
Prescription for a Periodical: Medicine, Sex, and Obscenity in the Nineteenth Century, as Told in Dr. Foote's Health Monthly
(/isis/citation/CBB001032398/)
Thesis
Colgrove, James Keith;
(2004)
Vaccination Policy, Politics and Law in the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001562080/)
Article
McCray, W. Patrick;
(2005)
Will Small Be Beautiful? Making Policies for our Nanotech Future
(/isis/citation/CBB000551046/)
Book
Stern, Alexandra;
(2012)
Telling Genes: The Story of Genetic Counseling in America
(/isis/citation/CBB001213529/)
Book
Nattrass, Nicoli;
(2012)
The AIDS Conspiracy: Science Fights Back
(/isis/citation/CBB001252724/)
Be the first to comment!