IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB269092739

Different Ways of Seeing ‘Savagery’: Two Nordic Travellers in 18th-Century North America (2019)

Fur, Gunlög (Author)

History of the Human Sciences
Volume: 32
Issue: 4
Pages: 43-62

DOI: 10.1177/0952695119846003

URI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0952695119846003

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Indigenous peoples; indigeneity Epistemology Ethnography Sociology 18th century North America

Andreas Hesselius and Pehr Kalm both spent time in eastern North America during the first half of the 18th century. Both came with an ardent desire to observe and learn about the natural environment and inhabitants of the region. Both produced writings, in the form of journals that have proved immensely useful to subsequent scholars. Yet their writings also display differences that illuminate the epistemological and sociological underpinnings of their observations, and which had consequences for their encounters with foreign environments. Hesselius, who served as pastor to the Swedish congregation in Philadelphia from 1712 to 1724, described his experiences and observations with what we might call a historical awareness, while Kalm, known as the first of Linnaeus’s students to travel to the New World, primarily offered dehistoricized and denarrativized taxonomic ethnographic descriptions. At first glance, Hesselius and Kalm appear to illustrate perfectly Michel Foucault’s description of the difference between Renaissance and classical epistemologies. Kalm’s disembodied and decontextualized representations fit well with Foucault’s description of natural history in the classical age as consisting ‘of undertaking a meticulous examination of things themselves…and then of transcribing what it has gathered in smooth, neutralized, and faithful words’. This article, however, points out that while Hesselius and Kalm arrive at similar descriptions of plants and other-than-human beings by employing different methodologies, when it comes to describing indigenous peoples their respective methodologies lead to radically different approaches, with Hesselius writing them into history, while Kalm relegates them to ethnology in the sense of savage ‘peoples without histories’.

...More

Included in

Article Bruce Buchan; Linda Andersson Burnett (2019) Knowing Savagery: Humanity in the Circuits of Colonial Knowledge. History of the Human Sciences (pp. 3-7). unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB269092739/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Scott Berthelette; (2020)
New France and the Hudson Bay Watershed: Transatlantic Networks, Backcountry Specialists, and French Imperial Projects in Post-Utrecht North America, 1713–29 (/isis/citation/CBB752642294/)

Book Giulia Iannuzzi; (2022)
Geografie del tempo: Viaggiatori europei tra i popoli nativi nel Nord America del Settecento (/isis/citation/CBB327958036/)

Article Attenbrow, Valerie J.; Cartwright, Caroline R.; (2014)
An Aboriginal Shield Collected in 1770 at Kamay Botany Bay: An Indicator of Pre-Colonial Exchange Systems in South-Eastern Australia (/isis/citation/CBB001422060/)

Article Giulia Bogliolo Bruna; (2021)
Une sauvage si sauvage: une esquimaude qui n’en était pas une… (/isis/citation/CBB560301160/)

Article Sarah Irving-Stonebraker; (2017)
“The Sagacity of the Indians”: William Dampier’s Surprising Respect for Indigenous Knowledge (/isis/citation/CBB079440616/)

Thesis Christopher Michael Blakley; (2019)
Inhuman Empire: Slavery and Nonhuman Animals in the British Atlantic World (/isis/citation/CBB485703529/)

Thesis E. Bennett Jones; (2021)
'The Indians Say': Settler Colonialism and the Scientific Study of North America, 1722 to 1848 (/isis/citation/CBB627267294/)

Article Johnson, Christopher; (2004)
“Periwigged Heralds”: Epistemology and Intertextuality in Early American Cometography (/isis/citation/CBB000500189/)

Book Krautwurst, Udo; (2014)
Culturing Bioscience: A Case Study in the Anthropology of Science (/isis/citation/CBB001420880/)

Article Nancy J Turner; (2018)
Learning New Medicines: Exchanging Medicinal Plant Knowledge amongst Northwestern North American Indigenous and Settler Communities (/isis/citation/CBB592368681/)

Book Householder, Michael; (2011)
Inventing Americans in the Age of Discovery: Narratives of Encounter (/isis/citation/CBB001201653/)

Thesis Susan Marie Wood; (2018)
Gathering the "Other": A Study in Salvage Ethnography and the Construction of Native Culture in Southern California, 1897-1908 (/isis/citation/CBB720338629/)

Article Julie Gibbings; (2020)
“Their debts follow them into the afterlife”: German Settlers, Ethnographic Knowledge, and the Forging of Coffee Capitalism in Nineteenth-Century Guatemala (/isis/citation/CBB272463503/)

Article Smithers, Gregory D.; (2015)
Beyond the “Ecological Indian”: Environmental Politics and Traditional Ecological Knowledge in Modern North America (/isis/citation/CBB001422283/)

Article Bradley, John; Adgemis, Philip; Haralampou, Luka; (2014)
“Why Can't They Put Their Names?”: Colonial Photography, Repatriation and Social Memory (/isis/citation/CBB001201577/)

Article Terry Kass; (2021)
False testimony: the surveying career of Robert Hamilton Mathews (/isis/citation/CBB617388972/)

Thesis Rosanna Jane Dent; (2017)
Studying Indigenous Brazil: The Xavante and the Human Sciences, 1958-2015 (/isis/citation/CBB170454215/)

Article Michaela Spencer; Endre Dányi; Yasunori Hayashi; (2019)
Asymmetries and Climate Futures: Working with Waters in an Indigenous Australian Settlement (/isis/citation/CBB277466911/)

Article Bruce Grant; (2020)
Missing Links. Indigenous Life and Evolutionary Thought in the History of Russian Ethnography (/isis/citation/CBB724939608/)

Article Hilary Howes; (2019)
Lothar Becker’s Contributions to Anthropology (/isis/citation/CBB428689866/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}