Kwiecinski, Jakub (Author)
Merit Ptah is widely described as “the first woman physician and scientist” on the Internet and in popular history books. This essay explores the origins of this figure, showing that Merit Ptah came into being in the 1930s when Kate Campbell Hurd-Mead misinterpreted a report about an authentic ancient Egyptian healer. Merit Ptah gradually became a prominent figure in popular historical accounts during second-wave of feminism, and, in the twenty-first century she appeared in Wikipedia and subsequently spread throughout the Internet as a female (sometimes black African) founding figure. The history of Merit Ptah reveals powerful mechanisms of knowledge creation in the network of amateur historians, independently from the scholarly community. The case of Merit Ptah also pinpoints factors enabling the spread of erroneous historical accounts: the absence of professional audience, the development of echo chambers due to an obscured chain of knowledge transmission, the wide reach of the Internet, the coherence with existing preconceptions, the emotional charge of heritage, and even – in the case of ancient Egypt – the tendency to perceive certain pasts through a legendary lens. At the same time, the story of Merit Ptah reveals how important role models have been for women entering science and medicine.
...More
Article
Appel, Toby A.;
(2014)
Writing Women into Medical History in the 1930s: Kate Campbell Hurd-Mead and “Medical Women” of the Past and Present
(/isis/citation/CBB001202334/)
Article
Sazzad, Rehnuma;
(2012)
Nawal el Saadawi as a Saidian “Amateur”
(/isis/citation/CBB001200944/)
Article
Meyer, Paulette;
(2006)
Physiatrie and German Maternal Feminism: Dr. Anna Fischer-Dückelmann Critiques Academic Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB000930221/)
Thesis
Martin, Paula Joan;
(2007)
Suzanne Noel: Beauty, Feminism, and Cosmetic Surgery in Early Twentieth-Century France
(/isis/citation/CBB001561285/)
Article
Sweet, Helen;
(2007)
Establishing Connections, Restoring Relationships: Exploring the Historiography of Nursing in Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB001030688/)
Article
Geddes, Jennian F.;
(2007)
Deeds and Words in the Suffrage Military Hospital in Endell Street
(/isis/citation/CBB000773971/)
Book
Bluhm, Agnes;
Bleker, Johanna;
Ludwig, Svenja;
(2007)
Emanzipation und Eugenik: Die Briefe der Frauenrechtlerin, Rassenhygienikerin und Genetikerin Agnes Bluhm an den Studienfreund Alfred Ploetz aus den Jahren 1901--1938
(/isis/citation/CBB001022122/)
Article
Guy, Jean M.;
(2013)
Edith (1869--1938) and Florence (1870--1932) Stoney, Two Irish Sisters and Their Contribution to Radiology during the World War I
(/isis/citation/CBB001421951/)
Article
Andre Dechert;
Susanne Kinnebrock;
(2022)
The Quest for Equal Rights: The Women’s Movement in Germany and its Care-based Argumentation
(/isis/citation/CBB082624737/)
Book
Leung, Angela Ki Che;
(2006)
Medicine for Women in Imperial China
(/isis/citation/CBB001023421/)
Article
Mammola, Simone;
(2014)
Does the History of Medicine Begin where the History of Philosophy Ends? An Example of Interdisciplinarity in the Early Modern Era
(/isis/citation/CBB001201196/)
Article
Ivahn Smadja;
(2016)
On Two Conjectures That Shaped the Historiography of Indeterminate Analysis: Strachey and Chasles on Sanskrit Sources
(/isis/citation/CBB972048490/)
Chapter
Imhausen, Annette;
(2010)
From the Cave into Reality: Mathematics and Cultures
(/isis/citation/CBB001210454/)
Article
Alexandra Rutherford;
Katharine Milar;
(2017)
“The difference being a woman made” Untold Lives in personal and intellectual context
(/isis/citation/CBB103559604/)
Article
Christopher D. Hollings;
R. B. Parkinson;
(2020)
Two Letters from Otto Neugebauer to Thomas Eric Peet on Ancient Egyptian Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB613078944/)
Article
Florent Serina;
(2020)
Janet-Schwartz-Ellenberger: The history of a triangular relationship through their unpublished correspondence (1926-48)
(/isis/citation/CBB377008132/)
Article
Catherine Carstairs;
(2021)
More than Cleaning and Caring: The Profession of Dental Hygiene in Canada, 1951–2010
(/isis/citation/CBB736871313/)
Chapter
Rogers, Naomi;
(2009)
Feminists Fight the Culture of Exclusion in Medical Education, 1970--1990
(/isis/citation/CBB001031394/)
Article
Christy Ford Chapin;
(2020)
What Historians of Medicine Can Learn from Historians of Capitalism
(/isis/citation/CBB162448791/)
Article
Garrett, Emily;
(2014)
Josephine Letitia Denny Fairfield (1885--1978): Pushing the Boundaries of Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB001422001/)
Be the first to comment!