Accounting for Complexity: Gene–environment Interaction Research and the Moral Economy of Quantification (March 2016)
Ackerman, Sara L (Author)
Darling, Katherine Weatherford (Author)
Lee, Sandra Soo-Jin (Author)
Science, Technology and Human Values
Volume: 41
Issue: 2
Pages: 194-218
Scientists now agree that common diseases arise through interactions of genetic and environmental factors, but there is less agreement about how scientific research should account for these interactions. This paper examines the politics of quantification in gene–environment interaction (GEI) research. Drawing on interviews and observations with GEI researchers who study common, complex diseases, we describe quantification as an unfolding moral economy of science, in which researchers collectively enact competing “virtues.” Dominant virtues include molecular precision, in which behavioral and social risk factors are moved into the body, and “harmonization,” in which scientists create large data sets and common interests in multisited consortia. We describe the negotiations and trade-offs scientists enact in order to produce credible knowledge and the forms of (self-)discipline that shape researchers, their practices, and objects of study. We describe how prevailing techniques of quantification are premised on the shrinking of the environment in the interest of producing harmonized data and harmonious scientists, leading some scientists to argue that social, economic, and political influences on disease patterns are sidelined in postgenomic research. We consider how a variety of GEI researchers navigate quantification’s productive and limiting effects on the science of etiological complexity.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Owen Marshall;
(2022)
Un-silencing an Experimental Technique: Listening to the Electrical Penetration Graph
(/isis/citation/CBB827332902/)
Article
Catherine Heeney;
(January 2017)
An “Ethical Moment” in Data Sharing
(/isis/citation/CBB939267013/)
Article
Alissa Cordner;
(November 2015)
Strategic Science Translation and Environmental Controversies
(/isis/citation/CBB568462630/)
Article
Shi Lin Loh;
Sulfikar Amir;
(June 2019)
Healing Fukushima: Radiation hazards and disaster medicine in post-3.11 Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB754363980/)
Article
Kellie Owens;
(September 2017)
Too Much of a Good Thing? American Childbirth, Intentional Ignorance, and the Boundaries of Responsible Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB160615752/)
Book
Huneman, Philippe;
Lambert, Gérard;
Silberstein, Marc;
(2015)
Classification, Disease, and Evidence: New Essays in the Philosophy of Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB001510440/)
Article
Hochman, Gilberto;
Palmer, Steven;
(2010)
Smallpox Eradication and Brazil: An Interview with Donald A. Henderson
(/isis/citation/CBB001420471/)
Article
Subrina Xirong Shen;
(July 2016)
Negotiating Authorship in Chinese Universities: How Organizations Shape Cycles of Credit in Science
(/isis/citation/CBB070859957/)
Article
Alina Geampana;
(2019)
Risky Technologies: Systemic Uncertainty in Contraceptive Risk Assessment and Management
(/isis/citation/CBB376759289/)
Article
Reichmann, Werner;
(December 2013)
Epistemic participation: How to produce knowledge about the economic future
(/isis/citation/CBB580792249/)
Article
Sora Park;
(December 2018)
FOMO, Ephemerality, and Online Social Interactions among Young People
(/isis/citation/CBB858909460/)
Article
Jaya Keaney;
(2022)
The Racializing Womb: Surrogacy and Epigenetic Kinship
(/isis/citation/CBB389875479/)
Article
Ernst van der Wal;
(December 2020)
LGBT Refugees and the Visual Representation of Transnational Mobility
(/isis/citation/CBB121039241/)
Article
Devasmita Chakraverty;
Sarah N. Newcomer;
Kelly Puzio;
Robert H. Tai;
(2018)
It Runs in the Family: The Role of Family and Extended Social Networks in Developing Early Science Interest
(/isis/citation/CBB531316217/)
Article
Fatima K. Espinoza Vasquez;
(2023)
Working at the Seams of Colonial Structures: Alternative Sociotechnical Infrastructures Revealed by Hurricane Maria
(/isis/citation/CBB231267644/)
Article
Tom Rook;
Harry Yi-Jui Wu;
(2022)
Defending Lives among Concrete Walls: An Interview with Flâneur Artist, Tom Rook
(/isis/citation/CBB414188247/)
Article
Nadine Levin;
Sabina Leonelli;
(March 2017)
How Does One “Open” Science? Questions of Value in Biological Research
(/isis/citation/CBB290502459/)
Article
Leandro Rodriguez Medina;
Hyungsub Choi;
(2022)
The Life and Death of Machines and Imaginaries: Conversations on Trains on EASTS Covers
(/isis/citation/CBB665341357/)
Article
Benjamin K. Sovacool;
David J. Hess;
(October 2017)
Ordering theories: Typologies and conceptual frameworks for sociotechnical change
(/isis/citation/CBB756258184/)
Article
S. Jainab Zareena;
(2020)
AMCAT Utility to Engineering and Computer Science Students
(/isis/citation/CBB179950850/)
Be the first to comment!