In this paper I review the problematic relationship between science and philosophy; in particular, I will address the question of whether science needs philosophy, and I will offer some positive perspectives that should be helpful in developing a synergetic relationship between the two. I will review three lines of reasoning often employed in arguing that philosophy is useless for science: (a) philosophy’s death diagnosis (‘philosophy is dead’); (b) the historic-agnostic argument/challenge “show me examples where philosophy has been useful for science, for I don’t know of any”; (c) the division of property argument (or: philosophy and science have different subject matters, therefore philosophy is useless for science). These arguments will be countered with three contentions to the effect that the natural sciences need philosophy. I will: (a) point to the fallacy of anti-philosophicalism (or: ‘in order to deny the need for philosophy, one must do philosophy’) and examine the role of paradigms and presuppositions (or: why science can’t live without philosophy); (b) point out why the historical argument fails (in an example from quantum mechanics, alive and kicking); (c) briefly sketch some domains of intersection of science and philosophy and how the two can have mutual synergy. I will conclude with some implications of this synergetic relationship between science and philosophy for the liberal arts and sciences.
...More
Article
Christiane S. Reiners;
Markus Bliersbach;
Karl Marniok;
(2017)
The Cultural Argument for Understanding Nature of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB523782243/)
Article
Ofran, Yanay;
(2008)
The Two Cultures and Systems Biology: How Philosophy Starts Where Science Ends
(/isis/citation/CBB001030486/)
Article
Harman, Oren;
Galison, Peter;
(2008)
Epistemic Virtues and Leibnizian Dreams: On the Shifting Boundaries between Science, Humanities, and Faith
(/isis/citation/CBB001030484/)
Book
Willard McCarty;
Geoffrey E. R. Lloyd;
Aparecida Vilaça;
(2022)
Science in the Forest, Science in the Past: Further Interdisciplinary Explorations
(/isis/citation/CBB549358382/)
Book
García Albea, Esteban;
(2001)
Historia y Humanidades en Neurología
(/isis/citation/CBB000530373/)
Book
Kagan, Jerome;
(2009)
The Three Cultures: Natural Sciences, Social Sciences, and the Humanities in the Twenty-First Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001021287/)
Book
Kellert, Stephen H.;
(2008)
Borrowed Knowledge: Chaos Theory and the Challenge of Learning Across Disciplines
(/isis/citation/CBB000820168/)
Article
Karafyllis, Nicole C.;
(2018)
Philosophie braucht Wissenschaftsgeschichte braucht Philosophiegeschichte. (Philosophy needs History of Science needs History of Philosophy.)
(/isis/citation/CBB044845023/)
Book
Therese Jones;
Delese Wear;
Lester D. Friedman;
Kathleen Pachuki;
(2014)
Health humanities reader
(/isis/citation/CBB223603500/)
Book
Gita Chadha;
Renny Thomas;
(2022)
Mapping Scientific Method: Disciplinary Narrations
(/isis/citation/CBB198387875/)
Article
Hiebert, Erwin N.;
(2000)
Common frontiers of the exact sciences and the humanities
(/isis/citation/CBB000110485/)
Article
Daston, Lorraine J.;
Most, Glenn W.;
(2015)
History of Science and History of Philologies
(/isis/citation/CBB001551437/)
Article
Henrik Thorén;
Line Breian;
(2016)
Stepping stone or stumbling block? Mode 2 knowledge production in sustainability science
(/isis/citation/CBB657683298/)
Article
Bod, Rens;
Kursell, Julia;
(2015)
Introduction: The Humanities and the Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB001551431/)
Review
Kai Horsthemke;
(2018)
Review of "Perspectives on Science and Culture"
(/isis/citation/CBB801319448/)
Book
Kris Rutten;
Stefaan Blancke;
Ronald Soetaert;
(2018)
Perspectives on Science and Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB362738776/)
Book
François Quiviger;
(2019)
Leonardo da Vinci: Self, Art and Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB598010678/)
Article
Veronica Boix Mansilla;
Michèle Lamont;
Kyoko Sato;
(July 2016)
Shared Cognitive–Emotional–Interactional Platforms: Markers and Conditions for Successful Interdisciplinary Collaborations
(/isis/citation/CBB848487776/)
Book
Machamer, Peter K.;
Wolters, Gereon;
(2010)
Interpretation: Ways Of Thinking about the Sciences and the Arts
(/isis/citation/CBB001033332/)
Article
Franzel, Sean;
(2014)
A “Popular,” “Private” Lecturer? Kant's Theory and Practice of University Instruction
(/isis/citation/CBB001201785/)
Be the first to comment!