Is Technology Value-Neutral? (January 2021)
According to the Value-Neutrality Thesis (VNT), technology is morally and politically neutral, neither good nor bad. A knife may be put to bad use to murder an innocent person or to good use to peel an apple for a starving person, but the knife itself is a mere instrument, not a proper subject for moral or political evaluation. While contemporary philosophers of technology widely reject the VNT, it remains unclear whether claims about values in technology are just a figure of speech or nontrivial empirical claims with genuine factual content and real-world implications. This paper provides the missing argument. I argue that by virtue of their material properties, technological artifacts are part of the normative order rather than external to it. I illustrate how values can be empirically identified in technology. The reason why value-talk is not trivial or metaphorical is that due to the endurance and longevity of technological artifacts, values embedded in them have long-term implications that surpass their designers and builders. I further argue that taking sides in this debate has real-world implications in the form of moral constraints on the development of technology.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Nassim JafariNaimi;
(March 2018)
Our Bodies in the Trolley’s Path, or Why Self-driving Cars Must *Not* Be Programmed to Kill
(/isis/citation/CBB556129964/)
Article
Katie Shilton;
(March 2018)
Engaging Values Despite Neutrality: Challenges and Approaches to Values Reflection during the Design of Internet Infrastructure
(/isis/citation/CBB184768397/)
Article
Neelke Doorn;
Behnam Taebi;
(May 2018)
Rawls’s Wide Reflective Equilibrium as a Method for Engaged Interdisciplinary Collaboration: Potentials and Limitations for the Context of Technological Risks
(/isis/citation/CBB722391619/)
Article
Tanel Kerikmäe;
Peeter Müürsepp;
Henri Mart Pihl;
Ondrej Hamuľák;
Hovsep Kocharyan;
(2020)
Legal Person- or Agenthood of Artificial Intelligence Technologies
(/isis/citation/CBB758247890/)
Book
Hanks, Craig;
(2010)
Technology and Values: Essential Readings
(/isis/citation/CBB000951740/)
Book
Cécile Michel;
Michael Friedrich;
(2020)
Fakes and Forgeries of Written Artefacts from Ancient Mesopotamia to Modern China
(/isis/citation/CBB397878352/)
Article
Ilse Verdiesen;
Filippo Santoni de Sio;
Virginia Dignum;
(2019)
Moral Values Related to Autonomous Weapon Systems: An Empirical Survey that Reveals Common Ground for the Ethical Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB025394666/)
Article
Till Winkler;
Sarah Spiekermann;
(September 2019)
Human Values as the Basis for Sustainable Information System Design
(/isis/citation/CBB725022354/)
Article
Eike-Christian Heine;
(2016)
Jenseits von Kultur und Zivilisation - Vereinzelte moralische Ansprüche an Technik und Techniker im ersten Drittel des 20. Jahrhunderts
(/isis/citation/CBB896107104/)
Book
Jon A. Leydens;
Lucena, Juan C.;
(2018)
Engineering justice: Transforming engineering education and practice
(/isis/citation/CBB400900880/)
Thesis
Jotterand, Fabrice;
(2006)
Nanotechnology, Bioethics and the Techno-Scientific Revolution: Philosophical and Ethical Assessment of Nanotechnology and Its Applications in Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB001561686/)
Book
Sheila Jasanoff;
(2016)
The ethics of invention : Technology and the human future
(/isis/citation/CBB934940191/)
Book
Mitcham, Carl;
(2000)
Metaphysics, Epistemology, and Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB000100785/)
Book
Mark Coeckelbergh;
(2013)
Human Being @ Risk: Enhancement, Technology, and the Evaluation of Vulnerability Transformations
(/isis/citation/CBB944837263/)
Article
Baird, Davis;
Schummer, Joachim;
(2005)
Editorial
(/isis/citation/CBB000630293/)
Book
Kroes, Peter;
Meijers, Anthonie;
Mitcham, Carl;
(2000)
Empirical Turn in the Philosophy of Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB000101895/)
Book
Mark Coeckelbergh;
(2020)
AI Ethics
(/isis/citation/CBB990965100/)
Article
Magne Brekke Rabben;
Øyvind Thomassen;
(2019)
Humane treatment versus means of control: coercive measures in Norwegian high-security psychiatry, 1895–1978
(/isis/citation/CBB458667420/)
Article
Ibo van de Poel;
Behnam Taebi;
(May 2022)
Value Change in Energy Systems
(/isis/citation/CBB234591523/)
Article
David G. Havlick;
Christine Biermann;
(November 2021)
Wild, Native, or Pure: Trout as Genetic Bodies
(/isis/citation/CBB221988475/)
Be the first to comment!