The philosopher of chemistry Andrea Woody has recently published a wide-ranging article concerning the turn to practice in the philosophy of science. Her primary example consists of the use of different forms of representations by Lothar Meyer and Mendeleev when they presented their views on chemical periodicity. Woody believes that this distinction can cast light on various issues including why Mendeleev was able to make predictions while Meyer was not. Secondly, she claims that it can clarify the much-debated question concerning the relative values of prediction and accommodation of data in the way that the periodic system was accepted. Thirdly, Woody believes that such differences in the representation of periodicity can be used to argue for the explanatory nature of the periodic table in contrast with the more traditional view that the periodic table is not explanatory. This discussion examines each of these claims and argues that they need to be qualified and in some cases rejected.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Chapter
Ann E. Robinson;
Carmen J. Giunta;
Vera V. Mainz;
Gregory S. Girolami;
(2021)
Dmitri Mendeleev and the Periodic System: Philosophy, Periodicity, and Predictions
(/isis/citation/CBB516331374/)
Article
Chris Campbell;
Karoliina Pulkkinen;
(2020)
How Mendeleev issued his predictions: comment on Andrea Woody
(/isis/citation/CBB534312169/)
Article
Ann E. Robinson;
(2019)
Chemical Pedagogy and the Periodic System
(/isis/citation/CBB434604363/)
Chapter
Kaji, Masanori;
(2003)
Social Background of the Discovery and the Reception of the Periodic Law of the Elements: Recognizing the Contribution of Dmitri Ivanovich Mendeleev and Julius Lothar Meyer
(/isis/citation/CBB000600082/)
Article
Gisela Boeck;
(2021)
„Meinen kleinen Atomschwindel werden Sie erhalten haben.“ Julius Lothar (von) Meyer (1830 –1895) und das Periodensystem der Elemente ["You will have received my little atomic hoax". Julius Lothar (von) Meyer (1830 -1895) and the periodic table of the elements]
(/isis/citation/CBB341997558/)
Article
Alan J. Rocke;
(2019)
Lothar Meyer’s Pathway to Periodicity
(/isis/citation/CBB674524182/)
Chapter
Gisela Boeck;
Carmen J. Giunta;
Vera V. Mainz;
Gregory S. Girolami;
(2021)
The Periodic Table of the Elements and Lothar Meyer
(/isis/citation/CBB170429677/)
Article
Gregory S. Girolami;
(2019)
A Book Collector’s View of the Periodic Table: Before Mendeleev.
(/isis/citation/CBB300228576/)
Article
Chris Campbell;
(2019)
The Periodic Table as an Icon: A Perspective from the Philosophy of Charles Sanders Peirce
(/isis/citation/CBB857890487/)
Article
Griffith, W. P.;
(2010)
The Group VIII Platinum-Group Metals and the Periodic Table
(/isis/citation/CBB000933099/)
Article
Dmitry Pushcharovsky;
(2019)
Dmitry I. Mendeleev and his time
(/isis/citation/CBB490178604/)
Article
Gisela Boeck;
(2019)
Julius Lothar (von) Meyer (1830-1895) and the Periodic System
(/isis/citation/CBB601476539/)
Article
Mary Virginia Orna;
Marco Fontani;
(2019)
Mendeleev's "Family": The Actinides
(/isis/citation/CBB880862496/)
Article
Juergen Heinrich Maar;
Alexander Maar;
(2019)
The Periodic Table and its Iconicity: an Essay
(/isis/citation/CBB599518974/)
Chapter
Nathan M. Brooks;
(2020)
Dmitri Mendeleev’s Concept of the Chemical Elements Prior to the Periodic Law
(/isis/citation/CBB524647894/)
Article
Mary Virginia Orna;
(2019)
Mendeleev at Home
(/isis/citation/CBB700021045/)
Chapter
Bernardette Bensaude-Vincent;
(2020)
From Simple Substance to Chemical Element
(/isis/citation/CBB327497668/)
Chapter
Eric R. Scerri;
(2020)
The Many Questions Raised by the Dual Concept of “Element”
(/isis/citation/CBB802086327/)
Article
John Emsley;
(2019)
The Development of the Periodic Table and its Consequences
(/isis/citation/CBB224151752/)
Article
Ramírez-Solís, Alejandro;
Novaro, Octavio;
(2014)
The First Metals in Mendeleiev's Table: Further Arguments to Place He above Ne and Not above Be
(/isis/citation/CBB001420433/)
Be the first to comment!