Weidman, Nadine M. (Author)
A historian of science examines key public debates about the fundamental nature of humans to ask why a polarized discourse about nature versus nurture became so entrenched in the popular sciences of animal and human behavior.Are humans innately aggressive or innately cooperative? In the 1960s, bestselling books enthralled American readers with the startling claim that humans possessed an instinct for violence inherited from primate ancestors. Critics responded that humans were inherently loving and altruistic. The resulting debate―fiercely contested and highly public―left a lasting impression on the popular science discourse surrounding what it means to be human.Killer Instinct traces how Konrad Lorenz, Robert Ardrey, and their followers drew on the sciences of animal behavior and paleoanthropology to argue that the aggression instinct drove human evolutionary progress. Their message, spread throughout popular media, brought pointed ripostes. Led by the anthropologist Ashley Montagu, opponents presented a rival vision of human nature, equally based in biological evidence, that humans possessed inborn drives toward love and cooperation. Over the course of the debate, however, each side accused the other of holding an extremist position: that behavior was either determined entirely by genes or shaped solely by environment. Nadine Weidman shows that what started as a dispute over the innate tendencies of animals and humans transformed into an opposition between nature and nurture.This polarized formulation proved powerful. When E. O. Wilson introduced his sociobiology in 1975, he tried to rise above the oppositional terms of the aggression debate. But the controversy over Wilson’s work―led by critics like the feminist biologist Ruth Hubbard―was ultimately absorbed back into the nature-versus-nurture formulation. Killer Instinct explores what happens and what gets lost when polemics dominate discussions of the science of human nature.
...MoreReview Ben Harris (2022) Review of "Killer Instinct: The Popular Science of Human Nature in Twentieth-Century America". Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences (pp. 480-482).
Book
Miller, Ian Jared;
(2013)
The Nature of the Beasts: Empire and Exhibition at the Tokyo Imperial Zoo
(/isis/citation/CBB001420333/)
Book
Segal, Nancy L.;
(2012)
Born Together--Reared Apart: The Landmark Minnesota Twin Study
(/isis/citation/CBB001320238/)
Article
Ashanti Shih;
(2019)
The Most Perfect Natural Laboratory in the World: Making and Knowing Hawaii National Park
(/isis/citation/CBB149416703/)
Book
Thurs, Daniel Patrick;
(2007)
Science Talk: Changing Notions of Science in American Popular Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB000773753/)
Thesis
Newell, Catherine Lea;
(2012)
The Wheels of Titan: Faith, the Future, and the American Frontier
(/isis/citation/CBB001560757/)
Thesis
White, N. William;
(2011)
Stories from the Elders: Chronicles and Narratives of the Early Years of Wilderness Therapy
(/isis/citation/CBB001567332/)
Thesis
Milam, Erika Lorraine;
(2006)
Looking for a Few Good Males: Female Choice in Evolutionary Biology, 1915--1975
(/isis/citation/CBB001560598/)
Book
Peter S. Alagona;
(2022)
The Accidental Ecosystem: People and Wildlife in American Cities
(/isis/citation/CBB499746657/)
Article
R. J. W. Mills;
(2018)
William Falconer’s Remarks on the Influence of Climate (1781) and the Study of Religion in Enlightenment England
(/isis/citation/CBB895379293/)
Book
Lutkehaus, Nancy C.;
(2008)
Margaret Mead: The Making of an American Icon
(/isis/citation/CBB000950304/)
Article
Rapchan, Eliane Sebeika;
(2012)
Cultura e inteligência: reflexões antropológicas sobre aspectos não físicos da evolução em chimpanzés e humanos
(/isis/citation/CBB001420597/)
Article
Weidman, Nadine;
(2011)
Popularizing the Ancestry of Man: Robert Ardrey and the Killer Instinct
(/isis/citation/CBB001034550/)
Thesis
Kowalski, Philip J.;
(2007)
Cultural Genetics: Theories of Inheritance and Nineteenth-Century AmericanLiterature
(/isis/citation/CBB001561333/)
Article
Jean-Luc Chappey;
(2021)
Questions sur les usages de l’enfant sauvage dans l’écriture des sciences humaines (xviiie-xxie siècles)
(/isis/citation/CBB847754252/)
Book
Keller, Evelyn Fox;
(2010)
The Mirage of a Space between Nature and Nurture
(/isis/citation/CBB001022401/)
Book
Alessandra Cerea;
(2021)
Natura, psiche e cultura. Dal “ragazzo selvaggio” all’etnopsicoanalisi
(/isis/citation/CBB136760743/)
Article
Staum, Martin S.;
(2004)
Nature and Nurture in French Ethnography and Anthropology, 1859-1914
(/isis/citation/CBB000500190/)
Book
Paul Weirich;
(2015)
Models of Decision-Making: Simplifying Choices
(/isis/citation/CBB665668336/)
Thesis
Santoro, Lily A.;
(2011)
The Science of God's Creation: Popular Science and Christianity in the Early Republic
(/isis/citation/CBB001567279/)
Article
Nicholas Campion;
(2018)
Astronomy, Ethics and the Planets
(/isis/citation/CBB071336809/)
Be the first to comment!