IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB217909079

The Cosmological Argument: A Newtonian Challenge to Hume (2016)

Michael Granado (Author)

Circumscribere: International Journal for the History of Science
Volume: 17
Issue: 0
Pages: 1-17

URI: https://revistas.pucsp.br/index.php/circumhc/article/view/24484

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Cosmology Natural philosophy Controversies and disputes Hume, David Newton, Isaac Clarke, Samuel

Hume’s arguments against the cosmological argument have, in the past century, often been highly praised by commentators such as H.D.Aiken and E.C. Mossner. While Hume’s argument often receives strong philosophical support, the four major objections raised against the cosmological argument in book IX of his Dialogues hinge upon a misunderstanding of Newtonian natural philosophy. Hence, when the proper historical context is considered, Hume’s objections are weak at best, for they assume an understanding of matter and physical necessity that are inconsistent with Newtonian natural philosophy. This paper will outline Hume’s objections, and explore how the formulation of the cosmological argument put forth by the English philosopher Samuel Clarke was reliant upon the best available scientific evidence, i.e. Newtonian philosophy. Consequently, any contemporary supporter of Hume who believes that his argument was successful in quenching the enlightenment era reiteration of the cosmological argument does so anachronistically.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB217909079/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Hayashi, Shin-ichiro; (2009)
Was Clarke Newton's Agent? Reexamination of Samuel Clarke in the Controversy with Leibniz (/isis/citation/CBB000931599/)

Article Baxfield, Christopher; (2013)
“Who Is the Almighty That We Should Serve Him?” Chaos, Providence and Natural Philosophy in Stephen Hales (/isis/citation/CBB001252607/)

Chapter Tamas Demeter; (2014)
Enlarging the Bounds of Moral Philosophy: Newton's Method and Hume's Science of Man (/isis/citation/CBB803014043/)

Chapter Pierris, Graciela de; (2012)
Newton, Locke, and Hume (/isis/citation/CBB001500347/)

Chapter Stephen Gaukroger; (2014)
Empiricism as a Development of Experimental Natural Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB971325669/)

Thesis Schliesser, Eric S.; (2002)
Indispensable Hume: From Isaac Newton's Natural Philosophy to Adam Smith's Science of Man (/isis/citation/CBB001562221/)

Book Martin, Craig; (2014)
Subverting Aristotle: Religion, History, and Philosophy in Early Modern Science (/isis/citation/CBB001422607/)

Chapter Catherine Abou-Nemeh; (2017)
Controversies over Comets: Isaac Newton, Nicolas Hartsoeker, and Early Modern World-making (/isis/citation/CBB982337013/)

Article Ovanes Akopyan; (2022)
Discussing Tides Before and After Newton: Roger Joseph Boscovich’s De aestu maris (/isis/citation/CBB435148776/)

Book Dante Alighieri; Giuseppe Boffito; (2021)
Quaestio de aqua et terra (/isis/citation/CBB788424367/)

Article Dmitri Levitin; (2021)
Newton on the Rules of Philosophizing and Hypotheses: New Evidence, New Conclusions (/isis/citation/CBB194940336/)

Article Vincenzo Schettino; (2017)
Isaac Newton and Alchemy (/isis/citation/CBB730185488/)

Article Ovidiu Babeş; (2022)
Playing with the Ancients: The Cosmology of Gilles Personne de Roberval (/isis/citation/CBB618042661/)

Book Harper, William L.; (2011)
Isaac Newton's Scientific Method: Turning Data into Evidence about Gravity and Cosmology (/isis/citation/CBB001221264/)

Book Niccolò Guicciardini; (2021)
Isaac Newton: Filosofo della Natura, interprete della Scrittura, cronologo degli Antichi Regni (/isis/citation/CBB698089545/)

Article Gregory Brown; (2016)
Did Samuel Clarke Really Disavow Action at a Distance in His Correspondence with Leibniz?: Newton, Clarke, and Bentley on Gravitation and Action at a Distance (/isis/citation/CBB410182076/)

Article Wigelsworth, Jeffrey R.; (2009)
Samuel Clarke's Newtonian Soul (/isis/citation/CBB001030599/)

Article Snobelen, Stephen; (1997)
Caution, conscience, and the Newtonian Reformation: The public and private heresies of Newton, Clarke, and Whiston (/isis/citation/CBB000079293/)

Book Lefèvre, Wolfgang; (2001)
Between Leibniz, Newton, and Kant: Philosophy and Science in the Eighteenth Century (/isis/citation/CBB000100782/)

Article Harrison, Peter; (1995)
Newtonian science, miracles, and the laws of nature (/isis/citation/CBB000069255/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}