Article ID: CBB217455719

On the Origins of the Quinarian System of Classification (2016)

unapi

William Sharp Macleay developed the quinarian system of classification in his Horæ Entomologicæ, published in two parts in 1819 and 1821. For two decades, the quinarian system was widely discussed in Britain and influenced such naturalists as Charles Darwin, Richard Owen, and Thomas Huxley. This paper offers the first detailed account of Macleay’s development of the quinarian system. Macleay developed his system under the shaping influence of two pressures: (1) the insistence by followers of Linnaeus on developing artificial systems at the expense of the natural system and (2) the apparent tension between the continuity of organic nature and the failure of linear classification schemes (which continuity seemed to require). Against what he perceived as dogmatic indolence on the part of the Linnaeans, Macleay developed a philosophy of science in which hypotheses that exceeded the available evidence should be proposed and subjected to severe tests. He also developed a novel comparative anatomical methodology, the method of variation, to aid in his search for the natural system. Using this method, he developed an intricate system that showed how organic nature could be continuous without being linear. A failure to appreciate these facets of Macleay’s thought has led to several misunderstandings of him and his work, most notably that he was an idealist. These misunderstandings are here rebutted.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB217455719/

Similar Citations

Article Aaron Novick; (2019)
A Reappraisal of Charles Darwin’s Engagement with the Work of William Sharp Macleay (/isis/citation/CBB878710980/)

Article Mary P. Winsor; (2021)
“I would sooner die than give up”: Huxley and Darwin's deep disagreement (/isis/citation/CBB437064231/)

Article Cosans, Christopher; (1994)
Anatomy, metaphysics, and values: The ape brain debate reconsidered (/isis/citation/CBB000030732/)

Article Gould, Stephen Jay; (1986)
The Archaeopteryx flap (/isis/citation/CBB000059278/)

Article Smith, C.U.M.; Smith, C. U. M.; (1998)
Owen and Huxley: Unfinished business (/isis/citation/CBB000076960/)

Book Cosans, Christopher E.; (2009)
Owen's Ape and Darwin's Bulldog: Beyond Darwinism and Creationism (/isis/citation/CBB000951052/)

Article Wilson, Leonard G.; (1996)
The gorilla and the question of human origins: The brain controversy (/isis/citation/CBB000070383/)

Article Smith, C.U.M.; Smith, C. U. M.; (1997)
Worlds in collision: Owen and Huxley on the brain (/isis/citation/CBB000077733/)

Article Di Gregorio, Mario A.; (1996)
The uniqueness of Charles Darwin: His reading of W.S. Macleay's Horae entomologicae (/isis/citation/CBB000072204/)

Book Purton, Valerie; (2013)
Darwin, Tennyson and Their Readers: Explorations in Victorian Literature and Science (/isis/citation/CBB001421851/)

Article Caudill, Edward; (1994)
The bishop-eaters: The publicity campaign for Darwin and On the origin of species (/isis/citation/CBB000033844/)

Article Preece, Rod; (2003)
Darwinism, Christianity, and the Great Vivisection Debate (/isis/citation/CBB000774479/)

Article Weikart, Richard; (1998)
Laissez-faire Social Darwinism and individualist competition in Darwin and Huxley (/isis/citation/CBB000077710/)

Article Curtis N. Johnson; (2019)
Charles Darwin, Richard Owen, and Natural Selection: A Question of Priority (/isis/citation/CBB684893999/)

Article Bown, Nicola; (2010)
What the Alligator Didn't Know: Natural Selection and Love in Our Mutual Friend (/isis/citation/CBB001022453/)

Article Cosans, Chris; (2005)
Was Darwin a Creationist? (/isis/citation/CBB000640653/)

Article Gardiner, B.G.; (1990)
Clift, Darwin, Owen, and the Dinosauria (/isis/citation/CBB000062453/)

Authors & Contributors
Smith, C. U. M.
Smith, Christopher Upham Murray
Novick, Aaron
Purton, Valerie
Winsor, Mary P.
Wilson, Leonard G.
Concepts
Evolution
Controversies and disputes
Biology
Anatomy
Classification in biology
Zoology
Time Periods
19th century
Places
British Isles
Great Britain
Europe
Institutions
Botanic Garden (Calcutta, India)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment