Winegar, Reed (Author)
British Journal for the History of Philosophy
Volume: 23
Issue: 5
Pages: 888-910
According to recent commentators like Paul Guyer, Kant agrees with Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1) that physico-theology can never provide knowledge of God and (2) that the concept of God, nevertheless, provides a useful heuristic principle for scientific enquiry. This paper argues that Kant, far from agreeing with Hume, criticizes Hume's Dialogues for failing to prove that physico-theology can never yield knowledge of God and that Kant correctly views Hume's Dialogues as a threat to, rather than an anticipation of, his own view that the concept of God provides a useful heuristic principle for science. The paper concludes that Kant's critique of physico-theology reflects Kant's deep dissatisfaction with Hume's manner of argumentation and suggests that Kant's attempt to provide a more successful critique of physico-theology merits continued philosophical attention.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Russell, Paul;
(2003)
The Material World and Natural Religion in Hume's Treatise
(/isis/citation/CBB000670511/)
Article
Blank, Andreas;
(2012)
Julius Caesar Scaliger on Plants, Species, and the Ordained Power of God
(/isis/citation/CBB001251572/)
Article
Federico Boccaccini;
Anna Marmodoro;
(2017)
Powers, Abilities and Skills in Early Modern Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB647362818/)
Book
Emilia Giancotti;
(2024)
Baruch Spinoza. La ragione, la libertà, l'idea di Dio e del mondo nell'epoca della borghesia e delle nuove scienze
(/isis/citation/CBB215642666/)
Book
Rodney Holder;
(2020)
Ramified Natural Theology in Science and Religion: Moving Forward from Natural Theology
(/isis/citation/CBB969637055/)
Article
Falk Wunderlich;
(2020)
Priestley on Materialism and the Essence of God
(/isis/citation/CBB064750676/)
Article
Paola Rumore;
(2020)
Priestley in Germany
(/isis/citation/CBB683415681/)
Chapter
Virvidakis, Stelios;
(2011)
On Kant's Critique of Thought Experiments in Early Modern Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001321022/)
Article
Massimi, Michela;
(2013)
Philosophy of Natural Science from Newton to Kant
(/isis/citation/CBB001320263/)
Article
Vlahakis, George N.;
(2010)
Philosophy Is the Knowledge of Things Divine and Human. Exploring the Divine Logos in the Milieu of Greek Science during the 17th--19th Centuries
(/isis/citation/CBB001220615/)
Book
Rohrbasser, Jean-Marc;
(2001)
Dieu, L'ordre et le Nombre: Théologie Physique et Dénombrement au XVIIIe Siècle
(/isis/citation/CBB000500065/)
Book
Alexandrescu, Vlad;
Theis, Robert;
(2010)
Nature et surnaturel: Philosophies de la nature et métaphysique aux XVIe--XVIIIe siècles
(/isis/citation/CBB001023213/)
Book
Taylor, Craig;
Buckle, Stephen;
(2011)
Hume and the Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB001251064/)
Article
Flaherty, Niall O';
(2010)
The Rhetorical Strategy of William Paley's Natural Theology (1802): Part 2, William Paley's Natural Theology and the Challenge of Atheism
(/isis/citation/CBB001021664/)
Article
Richard Mark Fincham;
(2015)
Reconciling Leibnizian Monadology and Kantian Criticism
(/isis/citation/CBB087483741/)
Article
Tim Black;
Robert Gressis;
(2017)
True Religion in Hume’s Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion
(/isis/citation/CBB887668569/)
Book
James A. Harris;
(2019)
Hume: An Intellectual Biography
(/isis/citation/CBB460332792/)
Book
Laura Berchielli;
(2020)
Empiricist Theories of Space: Space and Experience in Early Modern Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB669076606/)
Chapter
Theis, Robert;
(2010)
La physico-théologie du jeune Kant
(/isis/citation/CBB001023227/)
Article
Alexander Wragge-Morley;
(2018)
Robert Boyle and the Representation of Imperceptible Entities
(/isis/citation/CBB175771553/)
Be the first to comment!