In this article Denis Diderot’s Fifth Memoir of 1748 on the problem of a pendulum damped by air resistance is discussed in its historical as well as mathematical aspects. Diderot wrote the Memoir in order to clarify an assumption Newton made without further justification in the first pages of the Principia in connection with an experiment to verify the Third Law of Motion using colliding pendulums. To explain the differences between experimental and theoretical values, Newton assumed the bob was traversed. By giving Newton’s arguments a mathematical scaffolding and recasting his geometrical reasoning in the language of differential calculus, Diderot provided a step-by-step solution guide to the problem. He also showed that Newton’s assumption was equivalent to having assumed FR proportional the bob’s velocity v, when in fact he believed it should be replaced by FR ∼ v2. His solution is presented in full detail and his results are compared to those obtained from a Lindstedt-Poincaré approximation for an oscillator with quadratic damping. It is shown that, up to a prefactor, both results coincide. Some results that follow from his approach are presented and discussed for the first time. Experimental evidence to support Diderot’s or Newton’s claims is discussed together with the limitations of their solutions. Some misprints in the original memoir are pointed out.
...More
Chapter
Pulte, Helmut;
(1993)
Die Newton-Rezeption in der rationalen Mechanik des 18. Jahrhunderts: Wissenschaftstheoretische, -historische und -historiographische Reflexionen zu einem kontroversen Thema
(/isis/citation/CBB000078199/)
Chapter
Marius Stan;
(2017)
Newton’s Concepts of Force among the Leibnizians
(/isis/citation/CBB491004939/)
Article
Chen, Yue;
(2006)
An inquiry into mechanical problems in the “single pendulum” section of Xin Zhi Ling Tai Yi Xiang Zhi
(/isis/citation/CBB000701119/)
Chapter
Tega, Walter;
(2008)
All Knowledge in a Circle: From the Republic of Letters to Cosmopolitanism
(/isis/citation/CBB001023483/)
Article
Allen, Timothy;
Cooney, Charles;
Douard, Stéphane;
Horton, Russell;
Morrissey, Robert;
Olsen, Mark;
Roe, Glenn;
Voyer, Robert;
(2010)
Plundering Philosophers: Identifying Sources of the Encyclopédie
(/isis/citation/CBB001201136/)
Article
Casini, Paolo;
(1992)
Newton, Diderot, et la vulgate de l'atomisme
(/isis/citation/CBB000039730/)
Article
Gallavotti, Giovanni;
(2013)
Aspects of Lagrange's Mechanics and their Legacy
(/isis/citation/CBB001320790/)
Article
Santos Puerto, José;
(1997)
El Padre Sarmiento y la introducción de Newton en España
(/isis/citation/CBB000077410/)
Article
Evans, James;
(1996)
Fraud and illusion in the anti-Newtonian rear guard: The Coultaud-Mercier affair and Bertier's experiments, 1767-1777
(/isis/citation/CBB000071018/)
Book
Isaac Newton;
Amrie Boas Hall;
Alfred Rupert Hall;
(1962)
Unpublished Scientific Papers of Isaac Newton: A Selection from the Portsmouth Collection in the University Library, Cambridge.
(/isis/citation/CBB695803286/)
Article
Lorenz, Martina;
(1986)
Der Beitrag Christian Wolffs zur Rezeption von Grundprinzipien der Mechanik Newtons in Deutschland zu Beginn des 18. Jahrhunderts
(/isis/citation/CBB000061576/)
Chapter
Weiss, Burghard;
(1989)
Newton à la Cartes: Das 18. Jahrhundert auf der Suche nach der “wahren” Ursache der Gravitation
(/isis/citation/CBB000057676/)
Article
Lorenz, Martina;
(1990)
Rezeption und Bewertung des Newtonschen Gravitationsgesetzes in Physiklehrbüchern im Zeitalter der Aufklärung in Deutschland
(/isis/citation/CBB000035014/)
Article
Bertoloni Meli, Domenico;
(1990)
The relativization of centrifugal force
(/isis/citation/CBB000053148/)
Chapter
Domski, Mary;
(2012)
Locke's Qualified Embrace of Newton's Principia
(/isis/citation/CBB001500340/)
Book
Scott Mandelbrote;
Helmut Pulte;
(2019)
The Reception of Isaac Newton in Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB864191332/)
Book
Stedall, Jacqueline A.;
(2011)
From Cardano's Great Art to Lagrange's Reflections: Filing a Gap in the History of Algebra
(/isis/citation/CBB001321014/)
Chapter
Huggett, Nick;
(2012)
What Did Newton Mean by “Absolute Motion”?
(/isis/citation/CBB001500345/)
Thesis
Gerald Charles Lawrence;
(1968)
The Assimilation of Newtonian Mechanics, 1687-1736
(/isis/citation/CBB617132624/)
Article
Gandt, François de;
(1995)
La réception de Newton: Philosophes et géomètres
(/isis/citation/CBB000067256/)
Be the first to comment!