The tension between academic and professional aims of engineering education is a remarkably consistent challenge facing engineering educators. Here, some historical roots of this issue are traced through the life and work of Carl Richard Söderberg (1895–1979), who emigrated from Sweden to the US for an illustrious industrial and academic career. While Söderberg was a proponent for a more science-based curriculum, his rationale was related to solving real professional problems, and he would come to criticise the distancing of engineering education from engineering practice. Söderberg's views are compared to a present-day reform concept for engineering education, the CDIO approach, founded by MIT and three Swedish universities. The similarities show the persistence of the issue, as many of Söderberg's ideals, arguments, and proposed strategies are fully recognisable in the current discussion. Further, Söderberg and CDIO share the ideal of mutually supporting professional and disciplinary preparation, implying that the tension should not be a zero-sum game. The paths to this ideal were different, however, as Söderberg wanted to integrate theoretical aspects to improve an overly practical education, while CDIO is about improving an overly theoretical education by integrating also other necessary professional aspects.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Spencer, David B.;
Mehler, George;
(Summer 2013)
Opportunities in Engineering Education: Pathways to Better-Prepared Students
(/isis/citation/CBB917435053/)
Article
Ambrose, Susan A.;
(Summer 2013)
Undergraduate Engineering Curriculum: The Ultimate Design Challenge
(/isis/citation/CBB242192510/)
Article
Jacqueline Rohde;
Derrick J. Satterfield;
Miguel Rodriguez;
Allison Godwin;
Geoff Potvin;
Lisa Benson;
Adam Kirn;
(2020)
Anyone, but not Everyone: Undergraduate Engineering Students’ Claims of Who Can Do Engineering
(/isis/citation/CBB610221987/)
Article
Thursby, Marie C.;
(Fall 2014)
The Importance of Engineering: Education, Employment, and Innovation
(/isis/citation/CBB383968239/)
Article
Kennedy, Theodore C.;
(Summer 2006)
The “Value-Added” Approach to Engineering Education: An Industry Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB599642950/)
Article
Wulff, William A;
(Spring 1998)
The Urgency of Engineering Education Reform
(/isis/citation/CBB239852196/)
Article
Vest, Charles M.;
(Summer 2006)
Educating Engineers for 2020 and Beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB876317815/)
Article
Miller, Glen;
(2014)
Exploring Engineering and Sustainability: Concepts, Practices, Politics, and Consequences
(/isis/citation/CBB113118773/)
Book
Bix, Amy Sue;
(2014)
Girls Coming to Tech!: A History of American Engineering Education for Women
(/isis/citation/CBB001550627/)
Book
Ross Knox Bassett;
(2016)
The Technological Indian
(/isis/citation/CBB204652109/)
Article
Scholz, Tom;
(Spring 2016)
An Interview with . . . Tom Scholz
(/isis/citation/CBB500872908/)
Article
Gillette, David D.;
Lowham, Elizabeth;
Haungs, Michael;
(2014)
When the Hurly-Burly's Done, of Battles Lost and Won: How a Hybrid Program of Study Emerged from the Toil and Trouble of Stirring Liberal Arts into an Engineering Cauldron at a Public Polytechnic
(/isis/citation/CBB300484459/)
Article
Bordogna, Joseph;
(Spring 1997)
Making Connections: The Role of Engineers and Engineering Education
(/isis/citation/CBB916821535/)
Book
Robert McCaughey;
(2014)
A Lever Long Enough: A History of Columbia's School of Engineering and Applied Science Since 1864
(/isis/citation/CBB428233837/)
Chapter
C. M. Cunningham;
Muller, Carol B.;
P. Boyle Single;
(1999)
MentorNet: lessons learned from electronic communities for women engineers
(/isis/citation/CBB970862132/)
Book
Henry C. Dethloff;
Stephen W. Searcy;
(2015)
Engineering Agriculture at Texas A&M: The First Hundred Years
(/isis/citation/CBB231611060/)
Chapter
Bix, Amy Sue;
(1999)
'Engineeresses' 'invade' campus: four decades of debate over technical coeducation
(/isis/citation/CBB630267426/)
Chapter
Gillmore, G.;
Brainard, Suzanne G.;
S. S. Metz;
(1999)
National WEPAN Pilot Climate Survey exploring the environment for undergraduate engineering students
(/isis/citation/CBB332681086/)
Article
Peeters, Eric;
Richards-Kortum, Rebecca;
Levoy, Marc;
(Summer 1997)
Frontiers of Engineering: Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB437651040/)
Article
Willcox, Karen E.;
Klopfer, Eric;
Miller, Haynes R.;
(Fall 2016)
Open Educational Resources: Past, Present, and Future
(/isis/citation/CBB568788184/)
Be the first to comment!