According to most Evolutionary Psychologists, human moral attitudes are rooted in cognitive modules that evolved in the Stone Age to solve problems of social interaction. A crucial component of their view is that such cognitive modules remain unchanged since the Stone Age, and I question that here. I appeal to evolutionary rollback, the phenomenon where an organ becomes non-functional and eventually atrophies or disappears—e.g. cave-dwelling fish losing their eyes. I argue that even if cognitive modules evolved in the Stone Age to solve problems of social interaction, conditions since then have favoured rollback of those modules. This is because there are institutions that solve those problems—e.g. legal systems. Moreover, evidence suggests that where external resources are available to perform cognitive tasks, humans often use them instead of internal ones. In arguing that Stone Age cognitive modules are unchanged, Evolutionary Psychologists say that evolutionary change is necessarily slow, and that there is high genetic similarity between human populations worldwide. I counter-argue that what is necessarily slow is the building-up of complex mechanisms. Undoing this can be much quicker. Moreover, rollback of cognitive mechanisms need not require any genetic change. Finally, I argue that cross-cultural similarity in some trait need not be rooted in genetic similarity. This is not intended as decisive evidence that rollback has occurred. To finish, I suggest ways we might decide whether moral attitudes are likely to be rooted in unchanged Stone Age modules, given that I have argued that cross-cultural similarity is not enough.
...More
Book
Allen Buchanan;
Russell Powell;
(2018)
The Evolution of Moral Progress: A Biocultural Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB465416379/)
Book
Rob Boddice;
(2016)
The Science of Sympathy: Morality, Evolution, and Victorian Civilization
(/isis/citation/CBB826467140/)
Book
Klaus Hoeyer;
(2013)
Exchanging Human Bodily Material: Rethinking Bodies and Markets
(/isis/citation/CBB569868995/)
Book
Ong, Aihwa;
Chen, Nancy N.;
(2011)
Asian Biotech: Ethics and Communities of Fate
(/isis/citation/CBB001023125/)
Book
Daniel C. Dennett;
(2013)
Intuition Pumps And Other Tools for Thinking
(/isis/citation/CBB963525099/)
Article
Churchill, Frederick B.;
(2002)
The Evolutionary Ethics of Alfred C. Kinsey
(/isis/citation/CBB000501158/)
Thesis
Sripada, Chandra Sekhar;
(2005)
Conceptual Foundations for the Psychology and Evolution of Morality
(/isis/citation/CBB001561694/)
Chapter
Richards, Robert J.;
(2003)
Darwin on mind, morals and emotions
(/isis/citation/CBB000359558/)
Book
Lone Frank;
(2018)
The Pleasure Shock: The Rise of Deep Brain Stimulation and Its Forgotten Inventor
(/isis/citation/CBB884931356/)
Article
Natan Elgabsi;
(April 2022)
The ‘ethic of knowledge’ and responsible science: Responses to genetically motivated racism
(/isis/citation/CBB230115895/)
Book
Mark Coeckelbergh;
(2013)
Human Being @ Risk: Enhancement, Technology, and the Evaluation of Vulnerability Transformations
(/isis/citation/CBB944837263/)
Book
Enrico Furlan;
(2020)
Il principialismo di Beauchamp e Childress: una ricostruzione storico-filosofica
(/isis/citation/CBB988833100/)
Article
Brown, Bryson;
(2011)
Ethics in Darwin's Melancholy Vision
(/isis/citation/CBB001023983/)
Book
Giovanni Fornero;
Maurizio Mori;
(2012)
Laici e cattolici in bioetica: storia e teoria di un confronto
(/isis/citation/CBB846992376/)
Book
Noortje Jacobs;
(2022)
Ethics by Committee: A History of Reasoning Together about Medicine, Science, Society, and the State
(/isis/citation/CBB108849167/)
Article
Silvia Siano;
(2020)
Albert R. Jonsen: one of the most important pioneers of Bioethics and Clinical Ethics. An historical portrait
(/isis/citation/CBB595476468/)
Article
Shelley Ochs;
(2015)
Medicine and Morality in the Ho Family in Lijiang
(/isis/citation/CBB600427403/)
Article
Jenna M. Grant;
(April 2016)
From subjects to relations: Bioethics and the articulation of postcolonial politics in the Cambodia Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis trial
(/isis/citation/CBB531101853/)
Article
Daniel J. Hicks;
(2017)
Genetically Modified Crops, Inclusion, and Democracy
(/isis/citation/CBB212227086/)
Article
Federico Nicoli;
Giuseppe Armocida;
Mario Picozzi;
(2017)
Louis Pasteur and the Six Russian Peasants: a Significant French Episode of XIX Century
(/isis/citation/CBB294233125/)
Be the first to comment!