Are psychiatric disorders natural kinds? This question has received a lot of attention within present-day philosophy of psychiatry, where many authors debate the ontology and nature of mental disorders. Similarly, historians of psychiatry, dating back to Foucault, have debated whether psychiatric researchers conceived of mental disorders as natural kinds or not. However, historians of psychiatry have paid little to no attention to the influence of (a) theories within logic, and (b) theories within metaphysics on psychiatric accounts of proper method, and on accounts of the nature and classification of mental disorders. Historically, however, logic and metaphysics have extensively shaped methods and interpretations of classifications in the natural sciences. This paper corrects this lacuna in the history of psychiatry, and demonstrates that theories within logic and metaphysics, articulated by Christian Wolff (1679–1754), have significantly shaped the conception of medical method and (psychiatric) nosology of the influential nosologist Boissier De Sauvages (1706–1767). After treating Sauvages, I discuss the method of the influential nosologist William Cullen (1710–1790), and demonstrate the continuity between the classificatory methods of Sauvages and Cullen. I show that both Sauvages and Cullen were essentialists concerning medical diseases in general and psychiatric disorders in particular, contributing to the history of conceptions of the ontology and nature of mental disorders.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Andresen, Christopher Schroeder;
German E Berrios;
(2020)
‘My insanity in the year 1783’, by C.S. Andresen (1801)
(/isis/citation/CBB296326403/)
Article
Hane Htut Maung;
(2016)
To what do psychiatric diagnoses refer? A two-dimensional semantic analysis of diagnostic terms
(/isis/citation/CBB007035563/)
Book
Edward Shorter;
Max Fink;
(2018)
The Madness of Fear: A History of Catatonia
(/isis/citation/CBB544899834/)
Article
Åsa Jansson;
(2022)
From Melancholia to Depression: Disordered Mood in Nineteenth-Century Psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB956265052/)
Article
Hane Htut Maung;
(2016)
Diagnosis and causal explanation in psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB953313116/)
Article
Aragona, Massimiliano;
(2013)
Neopositivism and the DSM Psychiatric Classification. An Epistemological History. Part 1: Theoretical Comparison
(/isis/citation/CBB001320328/)
Article
Mauricio V Daker;
(2019)
The theory of symptom complexes, mind and madness
(/isis/citation/CBB264539507/)
Article
Jonathan Y Tsou;
(2016)
Natural kinds, psychiatric classification and the history of the DSM
(/isis/citation/CBB258474975/)
Article
M. Cristina Amoretti;
Elisabetta Lalumera;
Davide Serpico;
(2021)
The DSM-5 introduction of the Social (Pragmatic) Communication Disorder as a new mental disorder: A philosophical review
(/isis/citation/CBB881537603/)
Article
Daniel Mason;
Honor Hsin;
(2018)
‘A more perfect arrangement of plants’: the botanical model in psychiatric nosology, 1676 to the present day
(/isis/citation/CBB222714448/)
Article
Annemarie Jutel;
(2021)
Uncertainty and the inconvenient facts of diagnosis
(/isis/citation/CBB249581784/)
Thesis
Steven Warech;
(2021)
The Serpentine Genesis of Hysteria: Psychoanalysis, Photography, Artificial Intelligence
(/isis/citation/CBB692045705/)
Article
Rachel Cooper;
(2015)
Why is the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders so hard to revise? Path-dependence and “lock-in” in classification
(/isis/citation/CBB648630739/)
Article
Rachel Cooper;
(2018)
Understanding the DSM-5: Stasis and Change
(/isis/citation/CBB641094844/)
Article
Nikos Karfakis;
(2018)
The biopolitics of CFS/ME
(/isis/citation/CBB349225966/)
Article
Yorgos Dimitriadis;
(2020)
History of the opposition between psychogenesis and organogenesis in classic psychiatry: Part 1
(/isis/citation/CBB157647685/)
Article
German E Berrios;
Johan Schioldann;
(2019)
‘Insanity in Classical Antiquity’, by JL Heiberg (1913)
(/isis/citation/CBB216036852/)
Article
Kyu-hwan Sihn;
(2022)
Distinguishing between neurosis and psychosis: discourses on neurosis in colonial Korea
(/isis/citation/CBB040102801/)
Article
Aragona, Massimiliano;
(2013)
Neopositivism and the DSM Psychiatric Classification. An Epistemological History. Part 2: Historical Pathways, Epistemological Developments and Present-Day Needs
(/isis/citation/CBB001214389/)
Chapter
Foncin, Jean-Francois;
(2008)
Réflexions à partir de l'importance de la notion de cause dans la classification des “maladies”
(/isis/citation/CBB001221149/)
Be the first to comment!