Estimates of English income in Broadberry et al.’s British economic growth, 1270–1870 are founded upon a fourfold growth of farm output, and output per farm worker, over this interval. This article shows, using four separate tests, that farm output growth must have been much more limited. The tests are, first, whether in 1300 there was enough work at harvest to employ all the labour force; second, whether the value of output per worker in agriculture was greater than the annual earnings of workers; third, whether the implied relative outputs per acre of arable versus pasture were reasonable; and fourth, whether a much shorter medieval work year was possible. An alternative index of farm output consistent with the labour supply, wages, and farm rents is derived. This shows much less growth during the period 1270–1800. Overall economic growth in England during these years must consequently have been far less than Broadberry et al. estimate.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Chapter
Andrea Bonoldi;
(2016)
La risorsa mutevole. L'Adige nell'economia della regione trentino-tirolese
(/isis/citation/CBB675032851/)
Book
Edwards, Peter;
(2007)
Horse and Man in Early Modern England
(/isis/citation/CBB001201097/)
Book
Hoyle, R W;
(2013)
The Farmer in England, 1650--1980
(/isis/citation/CBB001422268/)
Book
Bromyard & District Local History Society, ;
(2007)
A Pocketful of Hops: Hop Growing in the Bromyard Area
(/isis/citation/CBB001201103/)
Book
Eric H. Ash;
(2017)
The Draining of the Fens: Projectors, Popular Politics, and State Building in Early Modern England
(/isis/citation/CBB613554035/)
Book
Hillary Eklund;
(2017)
Ground-Work: English Renaissance Literature and Soil Science
(/isis/citation/CBB688646795/)
Book
Thick, Malcolm;
(2010)
Sir Hugh Plat: The Search for Useful Knowledge in Early Modern London
(/isis/citation/CBB001201969/)
Article
Slavin, Philip;
(2012)
The Great Bovine Pestilence and Its Economic and Environmental Consequences in England and Wales, 1318--50
(/isis/citation/CBB001320059/)
Book
Erasmo D'Angelis;
Massimo Gargano;
Elisabetta Novello;
(2021)
La grande storia d'Italia raccontata dall'acqua
(/isis/citation/CBB639703806/)
Book
John Theilmann;
(2022)
Disease and Society in Premodern England
(/isis/citation/CBB618361645/)
Article
Savy, Pierre;
(2012)
Les attributs chimériques de peuples réels. Queue des Anglais et queue des Juifs au Moyen Âge et à l'époque moderne
(/isis/citation/CBB001420813/)
Chapter
Lowry, S. Todd;
(2003)
The Agricultural Foundation of the Seventeenth-Century English Oeconomy
(/isis/citation/CBB000501262/)
Book
Debby Banham;
Rosamond Faith;
(2014)
Anglo-Saxon Farms and Farming
(/isis/citation/CBB481385622/)
Book
Michael D. J. Bintley;
Michael G. Shapland;
(2013)
Trees and Timber in the Anglo-Saxon World
(/isis/citation/CBB744651029/)
Chapter
Leonardo Rombai;
(2003)
Le acque interne in Toscana tra Medioevo ed età moderna
(/isis/citation/CBB941655266/)
Chapter
Gabriella Garzella;
(2003)
In silva Tumuli e in Stagno: paesaggio dell’incolto e risorse naturali lungo il litorale pisano del Medioevo
(/isis/citation/CBB907150178/)
Chapter
Paolo Emilio Tomei;
(2003)
Il paesaggio vegetale delle paludi toscane: una testimonianza di antiche naturalità
(/isis/citation/CBB558524028/)
Book
Alberto Malvolti;
Giuliano Pinto;
(2003)
Incolti, fiumi, paludi. Utilizzazione delle risorse naturali nella Toscana medievale e moderna
(/isis/citation/CBB499062363/)
Chapter
Christopher Cullen;
(2011)
Reflections on the Transmission and Transformation of Technologies: Agriculture, Printing and Gunpowder between East and West
(/isis/citation/CBB689327508/)
Article
Dino Güldner;
(2021)
Contested Grasslands: Commons and the Unequal Land-Costs to Sustain Soil Fertility in Preindustrial Agriculture
(/isis/citation/CBB597215326/)
Be the first to comment!