During the second quarter of the nineteenth century, an argument raged about the identity of a small freshwater fish: was the parr a distinct species, or merely the young of the salmon? This “Parr Controversy” concerned both fishermen and ichthyologists. A central protagonist in the controversy was a man of ambiguous social and scientific status: a gamekeeper from Scotland named John Shaw. This paper examines Shaw’s heterogeneous practices and the reception of his claims by naturalists as he struggled to find a footing on the “gradient of attributed competence” (Rudwick 1985). The case demonstrates the context-specific nature of expert-lay boundaries and identities and explores a range of material and linguistic resources available for negotiating them. Arguing for a view of Shaw’s trajectory as simultaneously one of being a “practical man” and of becoming a naturalist, the paper explores both the permeability of social hierarchies in knowledge production and their effective role in the regulation of competency.
...More
Book
Thomas Sterba;
(2018)
Die Süßwasserfische des Karl von Meidinger: Mit naturhistorischen Illustrationen aus vier Jahrhunderten
(/isis/citation/CBB037489435/)
Article
Anderson, William D., Jr.;
(2012)
John Edwards Holbrook's Illustrations of Fishes in the Bibliothèque Centrale, Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, Paris
(/isis/citation/CBB001220851/)
Article
Matthew Hayes;
Noah Morritt;
(2020)
Michael W. Burke-Gaffney and the UFO Debate in Atlantic Canada, 1947-1969
(/isis/citation/CBB417665220/)
Article
Forbes, Curtis;
(2011)
Science and Public Controversy: Editor's Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB001220690/)
Chapter
Yuko Takigawa;
(2016)
Japanese Ichthyological Objects and Knowledge Gained in Contact Zones by the Krusenstern Expedition
(/isis/citation/CBB894149222/)
Article
Lightman, Bernard;
(2011)
Periodicals and Controversy
(/isis/citation/CBB001220691/)
Article
Kusukawa, Sachiko;
(2000)
The Historia Piscium (1686)
(/isis/citation/CBB000111544/)
Article
Joris Mercelis;
(2020)
The scientist and the advertisement: Reklamegutachten in imperial Germany
(/isis/citation/CBB621920403/)
Book
Johnson, Kristin;
(2012)
Ordering Life: Karl Jordan and the Naturalist Tradition
(/isis/citation/CBB001210068/)
Book
Saunders, Brian;
(2012)
Discovery of Australia's Fishes: A History of Australian Ichthyology to 1930
(/isis/citation/CBB001211155/)
Article
Orr, Mary;
(2014)
Fish with a Different Angle: The Fresh-Water Fishes of Great Britain by Mrs Sarah Bowdich (1791--1856)
(/isis/citation/CBB001321005/)
Article
Qian, Xue-mei;
Li, Bin;
(2002)
Relevant Record of the Blind Fish in Yi Ban Lu
(/isis/citation/CBB000340071/)
Book
Carin Berkowitz;
Bernard Lightman;
(2017)
Science Museums in Transition: Cultures of Display in Nineteenth-Century Britain and America
(/isis/citation/CBB922082803/)
Book
Sherra Murphy;
(2021)
"The First National Museum": Dublin's Natural History Museum in the Mid-nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB399178111/)
Article
Regal, Brian;
(2012)
Richard Owen and the Sea-Serpent
(/isis/citation/CBB001210166/)
Article
Daszkiewicz, Piotr;
Keith, Philippe;
(2001)
The correspondence between Louis Agassiz and the French naturalists Georges Cuvier, Lucien Bonaparte and Alexandre Brongniart in the manuscript collections of the Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle and Institut de France
(/isis/citation/CBB000100706/)
Article
Varughese, Shiju Sam;
(2011)
Media and Science in Disaster Contexts: Deliberations on Earthquakes in the Regional Press in Kerala, India
(/isis/citation/CBB001220695/)
Book
Liz Sevcenko;
(2022)
Public History for a Post-Truth Era: Fighting Denial through Memory Movements
(/isis/citation/CBB650942848/)
Book
Fletcher, Ronald;
(1991)
Science, Ideology, and the Media: The Cyril Burt Scandal
(/isis/citation/CBB001422097/)
Article
Keller, Evelyn Fox;
(2011)
What Are Climate Scientists to Do?
(/isis/citation/CBB001220693/)
Be the first to comment!