Aetiologies of Blame: Fevers, Environment, and Accountability in a War Context (France and Italy, ca. 1800) (2023)
Paul-Arthur Tortosa (Author)
Centaurus: International Magazine of the History of Mathematics, Science, and Technology
Volume: 65
Issue: 1
Pages: 63-90
During the Italian campaigns of the French Revolutionary Wars (1796–1801), several epidemic outbreaks sparked acrimonious aetiological debates: were the fevers spread by soldiers and prisoners of war, or produced by environmental factors? This debate was not only a scientific issue, but also a political one, for causation was linked to accountability. Looking at a series of medical investigations written by French military practitioners, this paper argues that theories of contagion were used by civilians to accuse the army of spreading disease, in what I describe as an “aetiology of blame.” Likewise, military officials attempted to absolve themselves of responsibility for the spread of disease by focusing on unwholesome environments, depicting diseases as unavoidable fatalities. Military doctors thus supported French imperial endeavours by obscuring the army's responsibility for the spread of diseases, putting forward aetiologies of fate and blaming individual behaviour. Even when they did not radically dismiss contagionist perspectives, military practitioners insisted on a wide range of pathogenic causes. Their discourses were in line with medical theories of the time, but they downplayed the responsibility of the army for the spread of diseases, which they depicted as a factor among others. Military doctors were thus not always involved in the direct and deliberate production of ignorance, but they did sustain controversies and uncertainty.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Goulet Denis;
(2020)
Brève histoire des épidémies au Québec: Du choléra à la COVID-19
(/isis/citation/CBB318570787/)
Article
Lindsay Rae Privette;
(2019)
‘We Yet Survive’: Physician Patient Relationships and the Yellow Fever Epidemic of 1853
(/isis/citation/CBB083346880/)
Article
Jones, Margaret;
(2013)
A “Textbook Pattern”? Malaria Control and Eradication in Jamaica, 1910--65
(/isis/citation/CBB001320597/)
Article
Bruno Bonnemain;
(2020)
Le Formulaire des hôpitaux militaires de Coste, publié à Newport, pour l’Armée de Rochambeau, en 1780
(/isis/citation/CBB859676535/)
Article
Marco Emanuele Omes;
(2023)
“In aria sana”: Conceptualising Pathogenic Environments in the Popular Press: Northern Italy, 1820s–1840s
(/isis/citation/CBB348044601/)
Article
Randall M. Packard;
(2016)
The Fielding H. Garrison Lecture: "Break-Bone" Fever in Philadelphia, 1780: Reflections on the History of Disease
(/isis/citation/CBB067436366/)
Thesis
Horan, Joseph;
(2013)
Fibers of Empire: Cotton Cultivation in France and Italy during the Age of Napoleon
(/isis/citation/CBB001567521/)
Book
Bulmus, Birsen;
(2012)
Plague, Quarantines, and Geopolitics in the Ottoman Empire
(/isis/citation/CBB001251697/)
Book
Hackett, Frederick John Paul;
(2002)
“A Very Remarkable Sickness”: Epidemics in the Petit Nord, 1670-1846
(/isis/citation/CBB000471053/)
Book
Dickerson, James L.;
(2006)
Yellow Fever: A Deadly Disease Poised to Kill Again
(/isis/citation/CBB000800195/)
Thesis
Apel, Thomas;
(2012)
Feverish Bodies, Enlightened Minds: Yellow Fever and Common-Sense Natural Philosophy in the Early American Republic, 1793--1805
(/isis/citation/CBB001561011/)
Book
David S. Barnes;
(2023)
Lazaretto: How Philadelphia Used an Unpopular Quarantine Based on Disputed Science to Accommodate Immigrants and Prevent Epidemics
(/isis/citation/CBB031880933/)
Article
Lorcin, Patricia M. E.;
(1999)
Imperialism, Colonial Identity, and Race in Algeria, 1830-1876: The Role of the French Medical Corps
(/isis/citation/CBB000111788/)
Chapter
Madonna Grehan;
(2015)
Typhoid Fever Epidemic, 1885-1887, Tasmania, Australia
(/isis/citation/CBB543472731/)
Article
Fantini, Bernardino;
(2012)
Polio in Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB001211097/)
Article
Rhoades, Michelle K.;
(2006)
Renegotiating French Masculinity: Medicine and Venereal Disease during the Great War
(/isis/citation/CBB000660034/)
Article
Rasmussen, Anne;
(2013)
Civilian Populations Versus Soldiers? Public Health and Infectious Diseases in France, 1914--1918
(/isis/citation/CBB001421906/)
Article
Helen Esfandiary;
(2022)
‘A thankless enterprise’: Lady Mary Wortley Montagu's campaign to establish medical unorthodoxy amongst her female network
(/isis/citation/CBB759886087/)
Book
Hudson, Geoffrey L.;
(2007)
British Military and Naval Medicine, 1600--1830
(/isis/citation/CBB000951553/)
Book
Andrew M. Wehrman;
(2022)
The Contagion of Liberty: The Politics of Smallpox in the American Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB236021862/)
Centaurus: International Magazine of the History of Mathematics, Science, and Technology
Dynamis: Acta Hispanica ad Medicinae Scientiarumque Historiam Illustrandam
French Historical Studies
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Medical History
Be the first to comment!