Making and managing medical anomalies: Exploring the classification of ‘medically unexplained symptoms’ (December 2020)
This article explores the making and management of anomaly in scientific work, taking ‘medically unexplained symptoms’ (MUS) as its case. MUS is a category used to characterize health conditions that are widely held to be ambiguous, in terms of their nature, causes and treatment. It has been suggested that MUS is a ‘wastebasket diagnosis’. However, although a powerful metaphor, it does neither the category nor the profession justice: Unlike waste in a wastebasket, unexplained symptoms are not discarded but contained, not ejected but managed. Rather than a ‘wastebasket’, I propose that we instead think about it as a ‘junk drawer’. A junk drawer is an ordering device whose function is the containment of things we want to keep but have nowhere else to put. Based on a critical document analysis of the research literature on MUS (107 research articles from 10 medical journals, published 2001–2016), the article explores how the MUS category is constituted and managed as a junk drawer in medical science.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Alice Street;
(December 2011)
Artefacts of not-knowing: The medical record, the diagnosis and the production of uncertainty in Papua New Guinean biomedicine
(/isis/citation/CBB480850883/)
Article
Annemarie Jutel;
(2021)
Uncertainty and the inconvenient facts of diagnosis
(/isis/citation/CBB249581784/)
Article
Martyn Pickersgill;
(2019)
Psychiatry and the Sociology of Novelty: Negotiating the US National Institute of Mental Health “Research Domain Criteria” (RDoC)
(/isis/citation/CBB630004689/)
Article
Knaapen. Loes;
(October 2013)
Being ‘evidence-based’ in the absence of evidence: The management of non-evidence in guideline development
(/isis/citation/CBB444983980/)
Article
Aragona, Massimiliano;
(2013)
Neopositivism and the DSM Psychiatric Classification. An Epistemological History. Part 1: Theoretical Comparison
(/isis/citation/CBB001320328/)
Article
Rachel Cooper;
(2018)
Understanding the DSM-5: Stasis and Change
(/isis/citation/CBB641094844/)
Article
Koichi Kameda;
Ann H Kelly;
Javier Lezaun;
Ilana Löwy;
(October 2021)
Imperfect diagnosis: The truncated legacies of Zika testing
(/isis/citation/CBB603527462/)
Article
Julia Swallow;
Alexandra Hillman;
(April 2019)
Fear and anxiety: Affects, emotions and care practices in the memory clinic
(/isis/citation/CBB055124638/)
Article
Alexandra Hillman;
Joanna Latimer;
(April 2019)
Somaticization, the making and unmaking of minded persons and the fabrication of dementia
(/isis/citation/CBB034246323/)
Article
Anne Kerr;
Tineke Broer;
Emily Ross;
Sarah Cunningham Burley;
(August 2019)
Polygenic risk-stratified screening for cancer: Responsibilization in public health genomics
(/isis/citation/CBB774833590/)
Article
Madeleine Mant;
(2020)
‘A Little Time Woud Compleat the Cure’: Broken Bones and Fracture Experiences of the Working Poor in London’s General Hospitals During the Long Eighteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB726530504/)
Article
Lisa Sigl;
(May 2016)
On the Tacit Governance of Research by Uncertainty: How Early Stage Researchers Contribute to the Governance of Life Science Research
(/isis/citation/CBB119230475/)
Article
Jorge Castillo-Sepúlveda;
Francisco Tirado;
Ana Gálvez;
(2023)
Biopolitics and speculative objects in Chilean health projects
(/isis/citation/CBB679456149/)
Article
Jialin Li;
(January 2021)
Cloaking the Pregnancy: Scientific Uncertainty and Gendered Burden among Middle-class Mothers in Urban China
(/isis/citation/CBB427082772/)
Article
Kruse, Corinna;
(October 2013)
The Bayesian approach to forensic evidence: Evaluating, communicating, and distributing responsibility
(/isis/citation/CBB366782410/)
Article
Steven Tresker;
(2020)
A typology of clinical conditions
(/isis/citation/CBB690319995/)
Article
Hane Htut Maung;
(2016)
Diagnosis and causal explanation in psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB953313116/)
Article
Brian, Kathleen M.;
(2012)
“Occasionally heard to be answering voices”: Aural Culture and the Ritual of Psychiatric Audition, 1877--1911
(/isis/citation/CBB001251914/)
Article
Régis Olry;
Duane E. Haines;
(2017)
The Devil Always Experienced Malicious Pleasure in Imposing Himself in Neuropsychiatric Nosology
(/isis/citation/CBB588658266/)
Article
Mauricio V Daker;
(2019)
The theory of symptom complexes, mind and madness
(/isis/citation/CBB264539507/)
Be the first to comment!