The tragedy of the canon; or, path dependence in the history and philosophy of science (2021)
Agnes Bolinska (Author)
Martin, Joseph D. (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 89
Pages: 63-73
We have previously argued that historical cases must be rendered canonical before they can plausibly serve as evidence for philosophical claims, where canonicity is established through a process of negotiation among historians and philosophers of science (Bolinska and Martin, 2020). Here, we extend this proposal by exploring how that negotiation might take place in practice. The working stock of historical examples that philosophers tend to employ has long been established informally, and, as a result, somewhat haphazardly. The composition of the historical canon of philosophy of science is therefore path dependent, and cases often become stock examples for reasons tangential to their appropriateness for the purposes at hand. We show how the lack of rigor around the canonization of case studies has muddied the waters in selected philosophical debates. This, in turn, lays the groundwork for proposing ways in which they can be improved.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Ana Simões;
(2019)
Looking Back, Stepping Forward: Reflections on the Sciences in Europe
Book
Michael Billig;
(2019)
More Examples, Less Theory: Historical Studies of Writing Psychology
Chapter
Chang, Hasok;
(2012)
Beyond Case-Studies: History as Philosophy
Article
Alan J. Rocke;
(2022)
Reflections on the Last and the Next Hundred Years
Article
Robert Bud;
(2016)
Representing scale: What should be special about the heritage of mass science?
Article
William H. Brock;
(2022)
The Long and Short of It: The Future Writing of History of Chemistry
Article
Stephen J. Weininger;
(2022)
“The Poor Sister:” Coming to Grips with Recent and Contemporary Chemistry
Article
Peter J. T. Morris;
Jeffrey I. Seeman;
(2022)
The Importance of Plurality and Mutual Respect in the Practice of the History of Chemistry
Article
Ana Barahona;
(2023)
Erasing borders: a new look at the historiography of science
Article
Subrata Dasgupta;
(2021)
Whiggism, creativity and the historiography of technoscience
Article
Sven Dupré;
Geert Somsen;
(2019)
The History of Knowledge and the Future of Knowledge Societies
Article
Carla Nappi;
(2017)
Paying Attention: Early Modern Science Beyond Genealogy
Article
Joachim L. Dagg;
(2017)
How counterfactuals of Red-Queen theory shed light on science and its historiography
Article
J. C. Pinto de Oliveira;
(2020)
Kuhn, Condorcet, and Comte: On the Justification of the "Old" Historiography of Science
Article
David Larsson Heidenblad;
(2018)
Mapping a New History of the Ecological Turn: The Circulation of Environmental Knowledge in Sweden 1967
Book
Anke te Heesen;
(2022)
Revolutionäre im Interview: Thomas Kuhn, Quantenphysik und Oral History
Article
Thomas Teo;
Gordana Jovanović;
Martin Dege;
(2021)
Motivated historiography: Comments on Wolfgang Schönpflug’s reappraisal of German critical psychology
Article
Reinhardt, Carsten;
(2010)
Historische Wissenschaftsforschung, heute. Überlegungen zu einer Geschichte der Wissensgesellschaft
Article
Paola Radici Colace;
(2013)
Il 'mestiere' di storico. La scrittura della storia dall'opinione alla ricostruzione scientifica
Article
Smith, Pamela H.;
(2009)
Science on the Move: Recent Trends in the History of Early Modern Science
Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Almagest
Centaurus: International Magazine of the History of Mathematics, Science, and Technology
Environment and History
Be the first to comment!