Article ID: CBB125423159

“An Official Conscience and Warranting Agency”: Institutional Isomorphism and the Rise of Dutch Ethics Review in the 1970s and 1980s (2021)

unapi

Abstract Why did medical research involving human subjects, a practice that is arguably as old as medicine itself, come to be regulated by research ethics committees in the late twentieth century? In this essay, I answer this question for the Netherlands, by querying the rise of ethics review in the 1970s and 1980s through the lens of “institutional isomorphism”. Drawing on the classic work of Paul Dimaggio and Walter Powell, I argue that extra-national changes to funding and publishing requirements in this period were identifiably more important for the emergence of ethics review in the Netherlands than were ethical concerns for research misconduct – a process that was marked by definitive elements of internationally coercive, and perhaps also of mimetic isomorphism. In addition, I detail how, as a consequence of these developments, those involved in Dutch ethics review came to consider “variation and inconsistency” as one of the system’s biggest problems in the late 1980s. To remedy this, numerous normative isomorphic attempts were undertaken in the late twentieth century to make all Dutch research ethics committees act in the same way. This emphasis on institutional homogeneity has been borne out in the Netherlands, even though it has repeatedly been criticized for hampering democratic and ethical decision-making.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB125423159/

Similar Citations

Article Sarah Babb; (2021)
The Privatization of Human Research Ethics: An American Story (/isis/citation/CBB733380502/)

Article Helena Tinnerholm Ljungberg; (2021)
Regulating Research: The Origins and Institutionalization of Research Ethics Committees in Sweden (/isis/citation/CBB714565276/)

Article Magaly Tornay; (2021)
The Missing Committees: Research Ethics in the Making in Switzerland (/isis/citation/CBB288164362/)

Article Noortje Jacobs; Helena Tinnerholm Ljungberg; (2021)
How Ethics Travels: The International Development of Research Ethics Committees in the Late Twentieth Century (/isis/citation/CBB244060560/)

Article Pavel Vasilyev; Alexander Petrenko; Veronika Tayukina; (2021)
Dealing with Ethical Issues in Clinical Trials: The USSR in the Global Context (/isis/citation/CBB335369410/)

Article Strasser, Bruno J.; (2011)
The Experimenter's Museum: GenBank, Natural History, and the Moral Economies of Biomedicine (/isis/citation/CBB001022861/)

Thesis Atwood-Gailey, Elizabeth Mary; (1999)
Constructing a “Good Death”: News Media Framing of the Euthanasia Debate from 1975 to 1997 (/isis/citation/CBB001562712/)

Article Parry, Bronwyn; (2013)
The Afterlife of the Slide: Exploring Emotional Attachment to Artefactualised Bodily Traces (/isis/citation/CBB001420756/)

Article Michael, Mike; Wainwright, Steven P.; Williams, Clare; (2005)
Temporality and Prudence: On Stem Cells as “Phronesic Things” (/isis/citation/CBB000850148/)

Article Rosagemma Ciliberti; Nicola Bragazzi; Anna Siri; Paolo Petralia; Alessandro Bonsignore; (2021)
The Italian legislator’s silence on physician-assisted suicide: Legal and bioethical implications (/isis/citation/CBB580737740/)

Article Lieburg, Mart J. van; (2013)
Gerrit A. Lindeboom (1905--1986) en de medische geschiedenis (/isis/citation/CBB001321102/)

Article Kater, Loes; Houtepen, Rob; Vries, Raymond De; Widdershoven, Guy; (2003)
Health Care Ethics and Health Law in the Dutch Discussion on End-of-Life Decisions: A Historical Analysis of the Dynamics and Development of Both Disciplines (/isis/citation/CBB000340830/)

Authors & Contributors
Tinnerholm Ljungberg, Helena
Jacobs, Noortje
Bragazzi, Nicola Luigi
Petrenko, Alexander
Tayukina, Veronika
Vasilyev, Pavel
Concepts
Biology and ethics; bioethics
Medicine and ethics
Research methods
Medicine and law
Human experimentation
Regulation
Time Periods
20th century, late
21st century
20th century
20th century, early
Places
United States
Netherlands
Great Britain
South Korea
Amsterdam (Netherlands)
West Germany
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment