David’s Weapon of Mass Destruction: The Reception of Thor Heyerdahl’s ‘Kon-Tiki Theory’ (2019)
From the late 1930s to his death in 2002, Norwegian adventurer and amateur ethnologist Thor Heyerdahl struggled to find academic acceptance for his Pacific Islands settlement theory. He even went as far as using the biblical story of David and Goliath as a metaphor for his struggle against academia. However, there are numerous reasons to question the accuracy of Heyerdahl’s description of his relationship to the scientific community. This paper discusses the reception of Heyerdahl’s ‘Kon-Tiki theory’ among Pacific scholars in the late 1940s and early 1950s. By analysing contemporary reviews of Heyerdahl’s 1952 book American Indians in the Pacific and comments on early drafts of the theory, this paper demonstrates that the material substantially differs from Heyerdahl’s own claims. He was not excluded by the Pacific scientific community, but welcomed and encouraged. Above all, reviewers of Heyerdahl’s theory praised the importance of the challenge he had posed to the established research narrative. However, Heyerdahl’s academic amateurism failed to convince the scientific community of the accuracy of his theory.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Matthew Spriggs;
(2020)
Everything You’ve Been Told About the History of Australian Archaeology is Wrong!
(/isis/citation/CBB069456008/)
Thesis
Pastore, Christopher L.;
(2011)
From Sweetwater to Seawater: An Environmental History of Narragansett Bay, 1636--1849
(/isis/citation/CBB001567330/)
Article
Mattes, Johannes;
(2021)
“Central nodes” and “neutral grounds:” boundary-work between scholarship, scientific amateurism and the public in Vienna (1860-1890)
(/isis/citation/CBB267101748/)
Book
Susan M. Alt;
(2018)
Cahokia's Complexities: Ceremonies and Politics of the First Mississippian Farmers
(/isis/citation/CBB140638779/)
Article
Tikkanen, Karin Westin;
(2012)
The Consequences of Truth
(/isis/citation/CBB001210570/)
Chapter
Kouki, Paula;
(2013)
Problems of Relating Environmental History and Human Settlement in the Classical and Late-Classical Periods: The Example of Southern Jordan
(/isis/citation/CBB001422314/)
Book
Porter, Anne;
(2012)
Mobile Pastoralism and the Formation of near Eastern Civilizations: Weaving Together Society
(/isis/citation/CBB001422626/)
Book
Xosé-Lois Armada;
Mercedes Murillo-Barroso;
Mike Charlton;
(2018)
Metals, Minds and Mobility: Integrating Scientific Data with Archaeological Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB820098544/)
Book
Jim Leary;
(2014)
Past mobilities: archaeological approaches to movement and mobility
(/isis/citation/CBB151824607/)
Book
Whittle, Alasdair W. R.;
Bickle, Penny;
(2014)
Early Farmers: The View from Archaeology and Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001422642/)
Chapter
Thomas, Kenneth D.;
(2003)
Minimizing Risk? Approaches to Pre-Harappan Human Ecology on the North-West Margin of the Greater Indus System
(/isis/citation/CBB001422471/)
Article
Tarquin Holmes;
Carrie Friese;
(2020)
Making the Anaesthetised Animal into a Boundary Object: An Analysis of the 1875 Royal Commission on Vivisection
(/isis/citation/CBB174441189/)
Article
Skelly, Robert;
David, Bruno;
Petchey, Fiona;
Leavesley, Matthew;
(2014)
Tracking Ancient Beach-Lines Inland: 2600-Year-Old Dentate-Stamped Ceramics at Hopo, Vailala River Region, Papua New Guinea
(/isis/citation/CBB001422017/)
Article
Federico Brandmayr;
(2021)
When Boundary Organisations Fail: Identifying Scientists and Civil Servants in L’Aquila Earthquake Trial
(/isis/citation/CBB058662495/)
Book
John H. Evans;
(2020)
The Human Gene Editing Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB424000521/)
Article
Hodges, Matt;
(2013)
Illuminating Vestige: Amateur Archaeology and the Emergence of Historical Consciousness in Rural France
(/isis/citation/CBB001213117/)
Article
Freeman, P.W.M.;
(2014)
Mommsen, Hübner, Haverfield, Watkin and Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum vol. VII
(/isis/citation/CBB001421849/)
Book
Peter Hempenstall;
(2017)
Truth's Fool: Derek Freeman and the War over Cultural Anthropology
(/isis/citation/CBB504459071/)
Article
Catherine D Tan;
(April 2021)
Defending ‘snake oil’: The preservation of contentious knowledge and practices
(/isis/citation/CBB517095153/)
Thesis
Coopersmith, Jared Scott;
(2012)
Scientific Controversies and Boundary Disputes: The Intelligent Design Movement Network
(/isis/citation/CBB001561017/)
Be the first to comment!