A controversial question concerning ancient geography is the location of the prime meridian which underlies the position data in Ptolemy's Geography and runs through the Fortunate Islands. An answer to this question is derived by means of a localisation of the places given by Ptolemy at the African western coast, i.e. in Mauritania Tingitana and Libya Interior, whose modern identifications are often uncertain or unknown. The origination of Ptolemy's positions from the distance data of seafarings is considered. A comparison of his data with distances reported by Pliny yields a satisfactory agreement. The localisation of Ptolemy's places is based on distances derived from Ptolemy's coordinates and partly on further information by ancient authors. Through it previous identifications are confirmed and new identifications are found. It shows that the Fortunate Islands correspond to several eastern islands of the Canary Islands. Explanations are given for the errors of Ptolemy's position data. A likely error by Ptolemy barely considered is his repetition of a part of Mauritania Tingitana in his description of Libya Interior. The existence of this repetition is confirmed by an adjustment of a transformation between the positions of the duplicated places and a statistical test of the arranged model. A comparison of longitudinal distances in different ancient sources reveals that the position of Ptolemy's prime meridian is based on distances given by Marinos and Eratosthenes.
...More
Book
McConnell, Anita;
Martin, Jean-Pierre;
Débarbat, Suzanne;
(2013)
Méridien, méridienne: textes, enjeux, débats et passions autour des méridiens de Paris et de Greenwich (1783--2000)
(/isis/citation/CBB001214469/)
Article
Dmitry A. Shcheglov;
(2017)
Eratosthenes’ Contribution to Ptolemy’s Map of the World
(/isis/citation/CBB350685006/)
Article
Francesco Prontera;
(2010)
Carta e testo nella geografia antica
(/isis/citation/CBB295904750/)
Article
Philippe Seubert;
(2017)
Délimitation et divisions de l’Arabie, d’Eratosthène à Ptolémée
(/isis/citation/CBB139661885/)
Article
Pascal Arnaud;
(2017)
Le traitement cartographique de l’information périplographique et diaplographique par Ptolémée: quelques exemples
(/isis/citation/CBB598591299/)
Article
Amson, John Ceres;
(2008)
Gregory's Meridian Line of 1673--74: A St. Andrews Detective Story
(/isis/citation/CBB000931917/)
Article
Ortiz, Eduardo L.;
(2005)
La Comisión del Arco de Meridiano. Astronomía, Geodesia, Oceanografía y Geofísica en la Argentina de 1935-1945
(/isis/citation/CBB000933601/)
Article
James Lequeux;
(2020)
Geodetic arcs, pendulums and the shape of the Earth
(/isis/citation/CBB886876626/)
Article
Gregory McIntosh;
(2020)
Conventional Wisdom and the Date of the Kunstmann I Chart
(/isis/citation/CBB373629190/)
Article
Dmitry A. Shcheglov;
(2016)
The Accuracy of Ancient Cartography Reassessed: The Longitude Error in Ptolemy’s Map
(/isis/citation/CBB832686811/)
Article
Higgitt, Rebekah;
Dolan, Graham;
(2010)
Greenwich, Time and “the Line”
(/isis/citation/CBB000932674/)
Article
Cameron McPhail;
Robert Hannah;
(2012)
The Cartographers of the Taurus Line: the Bematists, Dicaearchus and Eratosthenes
(/isis/citation/CBB414082075/)
Article
Silvia Panichi;
(2018)
Come si aggiorna la geografia antica: il Sud dell’ecumene tra Eratostene e Strabone
(/isis/citation/CBB248659311/)
Article
Pietro Janni;
(2017)
Tolomeo, uno «sconfitto della storia»?
(/isis/citation/CBB034147992/)
Chapter
Aujac, Germaine;
(1998)
Eratosthène et la géographie physique
(/isis/citation/CBB000080787/)
Article
Chet Van Duzer;
Bárbara Polo Martín;
(2018)
A Newly Discovered Fragment of Ptolemy’s Geography from the Workshop of Piero del Massaio
(/isis/citation/CBB299604051/)
Article
Didier Marcotte;
(2017)
Ptolémée ethnographe. Questions de tradition
(/isis/citation/CBB957748695/)
Article
Didier Marcotte;
(2021)
Ptolémée ethnographe II. Nature et fonction des notices ethnographiques dans la Géographie
(/isis/citation/CBB311549590/)
Article
Francesco Prontera;
(2017)
Da Strabone a Tolemeo: cartografia generale e regionale
(/isis/citation/CBB755353886/)
Article
Silvia Panichi;
(2017)
L’istmo della penisola anatolica
(/isis/citation/CBB011132737/)
Be the first to comment!