In modern mathematics, whose origins date back to the seventeenth century, method takes priority over the object, as the generality of method (which relies on a set of axioms and the laws of formal logic, applicable to any kind of objects whatsoever) implies the generality of the studied object. This epistemological attitude was alien to Greek mathematics, in which the generality of method did not necessarily mean the general character of its object. This is manifest, e.g., in Euclid’s Elements, where the axiomatic-deductive method does not eradicate the particularity of the studied objects: numbers, lengths, plane figures, and solids. The aim of this paper consists in showing that in the early stages of Greek mathematics, when axiomatic-deductive way of argumentation was still unknown, object took priority over method in the sense that an investigation was not accomplished according to a definite method, fixed in advance, but rather relied upon methods that were suggested, in each particular case, by the structure of the appropriate objects. I will examine such a state of affairs by proposing reconstructions of archaic demonstrations of theorems taken from early geometry, arithmetic, and the theory of ratios and proportions.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Essay Review
Unguru, Sabetai;
(2002)
Amicus Plato sed…: Fowler's New Mathematical Reconstruction of the Mathematics of Plato's Academy
(/isis/citation/CBB000200186/)
Article
Saito, Ken;
(2003)
Phantom Theories of Pre-Eudoxean Proportion
(/isis/citation/CBB000740735/)
Article
Hernán, Pilar;
(2006)
Proporción y armonía en el Ayante de Sófocles y el Partenón:matemáticas y creación artística a mediados del s. V
(/isis/citation/CBB001023869/)
Article
Krol, Z.;
(2007)
Introduction to Ancient Theories of Proportion
(/isis/citation/CBB000931652/)
Article
Marcella Giulia Lorenzi;
Mauro Francaviglia;
(2010)
Dal cosmo al numero e alla geometria euclidea
(/isis/citation/CBB384645759/)
Article
Daniele Pasquazi;
Benedetto Scoppola;
(2021)
Aritmetica euclidea e filosofia stoica
(/isis/citation/CBB278285265/)
Chapter
Matthew Landrus;
()
4. Mathematical and Proportion Theories in the Work of Leonardo da Vinci and Contemporary Artist/Engineers at the Turn of the Sixteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB335847578/)
Chapter
Reviel Netz;
(2016)
Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB996690754/)
Article
Berggren, J. L.;
Brummelen, Glen Van;
(2000)
Abu Sahl al-Kuhi's “On the Ratio of the Segments of a Single Line that Falls on Three Lines”
(/isis/citation/CBB000931681/)
Chapter
Renzo Baldasso;
John Logan;
()
8. Between the Golden Ratio and a Semiperfect Solid: Fra Luca Pacioli and the Portrayal of Mathematical Humanism
(/isis/citation/CBB978992186/)
Article
Palmieri, Paolo;
(2001)
The Obscurity of the Equimultiples: Clavius' and Galileo's Foundational Studies of Euclid's Theory of Proportions
(/isis/citation/CBB000101288/)
Article
De Pierris, Graciela;
(2012)
Hume on Space, Geometry, and Diagrammatic Reasoning
(/isis/citation/CBB001211479/)
Article
Dunlop, Katherine;
(2012)
The Mathematical Form of Measurement and the Argument for Proposition I in Newton's Principia
(/isis/citation/CBB001211480/)
Article
Maanen, Jan van;
(2006)
Diagrams and Mathematical Reasoning: Some Points, Lines, and Figures
(/isis/citation/CBB000850085/)
Article
Mendell, Henry;
(2007)
Two Traces of Two-Step Eudoxan Proportion Theory in Aristotle: A Tale of Definitions in Aristotle, with a Moral
(/isis/citation/CBB000740261/)
Book
Kim Williams;
Michael J. Ostwald;
(2015)
Architecture and Mathematics from Antiquity to the Future: Volume I: Antiquity to the 1500s
(/isis/citation/CBB061663908/)
Article
Notargiacomo, Simone;
(2008)
Il concetto matematico di μεσóτηζ
(/isis/citation/CBB001024082/)
Article
Petrocchi, Alessandra;
(2015)
A New Theoretical Approach to Sample Problems and Deductive Reasoning in Sanskrit Mathematical Texts
(/isis/citation/CBB001550650/)
Article
Marie-Noëlle Ribas;
(2018)
Aristote, père de l’astrophysique scientifique
(/isis/citation/CBB311581277/)
Chapter
Stevens, Wesley M.;
(2002)
Fields and Streams: Language and Practice of Arithmetic and Geometry in Early Medieval Schools
(/isis/citation/CBB000350350/)
Be the first to comment!