‘The very term mensuration sounds engineer-like’: measurement and engineering authority in nineteenth-century river management (2024)
Rachel Dishington (Author)
British Journal for the History of Science
Volume: 57
Issue: 1
Pages: 21-41
Measurement was vital to nineteenth-century engineering. Focusing on the work of the Stevenson engineering firm in Scotland, this paper explores the processes by which engineers made their measurements credible and explains how measurement, as both a product and a practice, informed engineering decisions and supported claims to engineering authority. By examining attempts made to quantify, measure and map dynamic river spaces, the paper analyses the relationship between engineering experience and judgement and the generation of data that engineers considered to be ‘tolerably correct’. While measurement created an abstract and simplified version of the river that accommodated prediction, this abstraction had to be connected to and made meaningful in real river space despite acknowledged limitations to measuring practice. In response, engineers drew on experience gained through the measuring process to support claims to authoritative knowledge. This combination of quantification and experience was then used to support interventions in debates over the proper use and management of rivers. This paper argues that measurement in nineteenth-century engineering served a dual function, producing both data and expertise, which were both significant in underpinning engineering authority and facilitating engineers’ intervention in decision making for river management.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Clarke, D.;
Kinns, R.;
(2012)
Some New Insights into the History of the Glasgow Time Ball and Time Guns
(/isis/citation/CBB001221504/)
Article
Luminita Gatejel;
(October 2018)
Building a Better Passage to the Sea: Engineering and River Management at the Mouth of the Danube, 1829–61
(/isis/citation/CBB779229466/)
Book
Vito Rovigo;
(2016)
Il fiume, le terre, l’immaginario. L’Adige come fenomeno storiografico complesso
(/isis/citation/CBB661048611/)
Article
Maarten G. Kleinhans;
(2023)
Measuring and Manipulating the Rhine River Branches: Interactions of Theory and Embodied Understanding in Eighteenth Century River Hydraulics
(/isis/citation/CBB571178798/)
Article
Klaus Staubermann;
Geoffrey N. Swinney;
(2016)
Making Space for Models: (Re)presenting Engineering in Scotland’s National Museum, 1854–Present
(/isis/citation/CBB628182365/)
Book
Russell, Ben;
(2014)
James Watt: Making the World Anew
(/isis/citation/CBB001510127/)
Book
John Moore;
(2017)
The Clyde: Mapping the River
(/isis/citation/CBB114394939/)
Book
Connor, Robert Dickson;
Simpson, Allen David Cumming;
Morrison-Low, A. D.;
(2004)
Weights and Measures in Scotland: A European Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB000750862/)
Chapter
Francesco Salvestrini;
(2010)
Navigazione e trasporti sulle acque interne della toscana medievale e protomoderna (secoli XIII-XVI)
(/isis/citation/CBB049500742/)
Chapter
Veronica Ghizzi;
(2010)
Si durabit tregua intra aquam et nos: fiumi e castelli mantovani nel trecento
(/isis/citation/CBB180053135/)
Book
Stagg, Ronald John;
(2010)
The Golden Dream: A History of the St. Lawrence Seaway
(/isis/citation/CBB001421492/)
Chapter
Massimo Mussini;
(2010)
Governo delle acque nel territorio reggiano fra medioevo e rinascimento
(/isis/citation/CBB348854805/)
Book
Adam Mandelman;
(2020)
The Place with No Edge: An Intimate History of People, Technology, and the Mississippi River Delta
(/isis/citation/CBB918000641/)
Article
Maffioli, Cesare S;
(2008)
Galileo, Guiducci and the Engineer Bartolotti on the Bisenzio River
(/isis/citation/CBB000931293/)
Article
Shinichiro Nakamura;
Taikan Oki;
Shinjiro Kanae;
(April 2022)
Lost Rivers: Tokyo's Sewage Problem in the High-Growth Period, 1953–73
(/isis/citation/CBB066505806/)
Article
Daniel Macfarlane;
(January 2020)
Nature Empowered: Hydraulic Models and the Engineering of Niagara Falls
(/isis/citation/CBB743954854/)
Chapter
Pietro C. Marani;
(2010)
Leonardo e le acque in Lombardia. Dal "Primo Libro delle Acque" ai "Diluvi"
(/isis/citation/CBB801952762/)
Article
Baird, Davis;
(2010)
Engineering Realities
(/isis/citation/CBB001023794/)
Article
Yousef Yassi;
Reza Yassi;
(2020)
Al-Khazini’s Balance of Wisdom: A Masterpiece of Medieval Engineering
(/isis/citation/CBB809682343/)
Article
David Banks;
(2015)
Dr T. G. N. ‘Graeme’ Haldane — Scottish Heat Pump Pioneer
(/isis/citation/CBB043414912/)
Be the first to comment!