In this commentary, Kristin Asdal reflects on pragmatism as one of the methodological touchstones of Science, technology and society (STS). In its focus on practices, pragmatist STS can be prone to falling into a problematic presentism, obscuring the historicity of the practices being studied, and to falling into problematic material/semiotic binaries. But what does it take, in practice, to be pragmatic? In her commentary, Asdal points to how this ought to imply being open when it comes to our choice of methods, thus finding creative ways of maintaining a crucial recognition of history as well as relations between the textual and the material. This in turn might instantiate new, distinctive, and inspiring modes of pragmatist methodological insight—such as precisely in these special issue papers devoted to animal care. These papers are also inspiringly pragmatic, in the meaning of careful—in order not to be overtly programmatic, i.e. deciding beforehand your position or standpoint on a given topic, such as human–animal relations. Following on from this she puts forward the notion “interested methods.”
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Brian Balmer;
(March 2017)
Shadow Values and the Politics of Extrapolation (Special Issue Commentary)
(/isis/citation/CBB819964335/)
Article
Raf De Bont;
(2021)
Hamster numbers: Biopolitics and animal agency in the Dutch fields, circa 1870-present
(/isis/citation/CBB084153011/)
Article
Carlo Caduff;
(March 2017)
Targets in the Cloud: On Transparency and Other Shadows (Special Issue Commentary)
(/isis/citation/CBB356484671/)
Review
Marlene Gómez Becerra;
(2022)
Review of "Seeds of power: Environmental injustice and genetically modified soybeans in Argentina"
(/isis/citation/CBB567797128/)
Article
Jorge Castillo-Sepúlveda;
Francisco Tirado;
Ana Gálvez;
(2023)
Biopolitics and speculative objects in Chilean health projects
(/isis/citation/CBB679456149/)
Article
Abril Saldaña-Tejeda;
Xyoli Pérez-Campos;
Elizabeth Reddy;
(2022)
Seismic noise to public health signal: Investigating the effects of pandemic guidance in Mexico
(/isis/citation/CBB608117334/)
Article
Andreas Folkers;
Sven Opitz;
(June 2022)
Low-carbon cows: From microbial metabolism to the symbiotic planet
(/isis/citation/CBB874316885/)
Article
Stéphanie Ponsavady;
(December 2018)
Moving the Goalposts: Postcolonial Intersections and Mobilities
(/isis/citation/CBB556191692/)
Article
Sally Wyatt;
(March 2017)
Making Policies for Open Data: Experiencing the Technological Imperative in the Policy World (Special Issue Commentary)
(/isis/citation/CBB070435927/)
Article
Heather Anne Swanson;
(December 2020)
Why Railroads Now?: Anthropology of Infrastructure and Debates around “Green” Transit
(/isis/citation/CBB388531770/)
Article
Gregory Clancey;
(2021)
Commentary on “Sources of Disaster: A Roundtable Discussion on New Epistemic Perspectives in Post-3.11 Japan”
(/isis/citation/CBB984146673/)
Article
Neelke Doorn;
Behnam Taebi;
(May 2018)
Rawls’s Wide Reflective Equilibrium as a Method for Engaged Interdisciplinary Collaboration: Potentials and Limitations for the Context of Technological Risks
(/isis/citation/CBB722391619/)
Article
Daniel Neyland;
(January 2016)
Bearing Account-able Witness to the Ethical Algorithmic System
(/isis/citation/CBB408589504/)
Article
Mzamose Gondwe;
Nancy Longnecker;
(September 2015)
Objects as Stimuli for Exploring Young People’s Views about Cultural and Scientific Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB661432570/)
Article
Wen-Ling Tu;
(2021)
Commentary on Four Tapuya Papers on Environmentalism in Latin America: The EASTS Perspective (Essay)
(/isis/citation/CBB438431524/)
Article
Natasha D. Schüll;
(March 2022)
Afterword: Shifting the Terms of the Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB889022961/)
Article
Miao Lu;
Jack Linchuan Qiu;
(2023)
Transfer or Translation? Rethinking Traveling Technologies from the Global South
(/isis/citation/CBB075981875/)
Article
Malte Ziewitz;
(January 2016)
Governing Algorithms: Myth, Mess, and Methods
(/isis/citation/CBB061486372/)
Article
Logan D. A. Williams;
(March 2018)
Mapping Superpositionality in Global Ethnography
(/isis/citation/CBB873960993/)
Article
David Moats;
Liz McFall;
(2019)
In Search of a Problem: Mapping Controversies over NHS (England) Patient Data with Digital Tools
(/isis/citation/CBB339833803/)
Be the first to comment!