Cooperative Division of Cognitive Labour: The Social Epistemology of Photosynthesis Research (2022)
Nickelsen, Kärin (Author)
Journal for General Philosophy of Science
Volume: 53
Issue: 1
Pages: 23-40
How do scientists generate knowledge in groups, and how have they done so in the past? How do epistemically motivated social interactions influence or even drive this process? These questions speak to core interests of both history and philosophy of science. Idealised models and formal arguments have been suggested to illuminate the social epistemology of science, but their conclusions are not directly applicable to scientific practice. This paper uses one of these models as a lens and historiographical tool in the examination of actual scientific collectives. It centres on the analysis of two episodes from the history of photosynthesis research of the late nineteenth- to mid-twentieth centuries, which display a wide and coordinated intellectual diversity similar to Kitcher’s “division of cognitive labour” (1990). The concept, I argue, captures important aspects of the photosynthesis research communities, but the underlying process unfolded in ways that differ from the model’s assumption in interesting ways. The paper unravels how the self-organised interplay of cooperation and competition, and the dynamics of individual and collective goals within scientific communities were influential factors in the generation of knowledge. From there, some thoughts are developed on how historical and philosophical approaches in the analysis of science can productively interact.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Krist Vaesen;
(2021)
French Neopositivism and the Logic, Psychology, and Sociology of Scientific Discovery
(/isis/citation/CBB634106059/)
Article
Kistner, Kelly;
(2013)
“A Word Factory Was Wanted”: Organizational Objectivity in the Making of the Oxford English Dictionary
(/isis/citation/CBB001320556/)
Article
Scranton, Philip;
(2012)
Thinking about Work, Knowledge, Law and Property
(/isis/citation/CBB001210230/)
Article
Nickelsen, Kärin;
Graßhoff, Gerd;
(2011)
In Pursuit of Formaldehyde: Causally Explanatory Models and Falsification
(/isis/citation/CBB001024015/)
Article
Guillaume Lancereau;
(2024)
Entre espace public et mondes privés: Les masculinités savantes aux origines de la discipline historique en France, 1870–1914
(/isis/citation/CBB696598575/)
Article
Withers, Charles W. J.;
Finnegan, Diarmid;
Higgitt, Rebekah;
(2006)
Geography's Other Histories? Geography and Science in the British Association for the Advancement of Science, 1831--c. 1933
(/isis/citation/CBB001320702/)
Article
Popowski, H.;
(2007)
Historiographic Conceptions of Witold Rubczynski
(/isis/citation/CBB000931651/)
Article
Masters, B. R.;
(2014)
Paths to Förster's Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB001421695/)
Article
Nickelsen, Kärin;
(2009)
The Construction of a Scientific Model: Otto Warburg and the Building Block Strategy
(/isis/citation/CBB000954213/)
Article
Hazel Morrison;
(2017)
Henderson and Meyer in correspondence: a transatlantic history of dynamic psychiatry, 1908–29
(/isis/citation/CBB141998062/)
Article
Stöltzner, Michael;
(2009)
Gangarten des Rationalen. Zu den Zeitstrukturen der Quantenrevolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000932098/)
Chapter
Bruno Belhoste;
(2017)
From Quarry to Paper: Cuvier's Three Epistemological Cultures
(/isis/citation/CBB588948570/)
Article
Vicente, Filipa Lowndes;
(2012)
A Photograph of Four Orientalists (Bombay, 1885): Knowledge Production, Religious Identities, and the Negotiation of Invisible Conflicts
(/isis/citation/CBB001500544/)
Article
Andre M. Hahn;
(2016)
Can a History of Photosynthesis be Grand?
(/isis/citation/CBB895847729/)
Article
Kärin Nickelsen;
(2007)
From Leaves to Molecules: Botany and the Development of Photosynthesis Research
(/isis/citation/CBB367215688/)
Book
Kärin Nickelsen;
(2015)
Explaining Photosynthesis: Models of Biochemical Mechanisms, 1840-1960
(/isis/citation/CBB217214385/)
Article
Matthews, Michael R.;
(2009)
Science and Worldviews in the Classroom: Joseph Priestley and Photosynthesis
(/isis/citation/CBB001032844/)
Article
Sven Dupré;
Geert Somsen;
(2019)
The History of Knowledge and the Future of Knowledge Societies
(/isis/citation/CBB931053546/)
Book
Hannah Star Rogers;
(2022)
Art, Science, and the Politics of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB734293422/)
Article
Duarte, Regina Horta;
(2009)
História e biologia: diálogos possíveis, distâncias necessárias
(/isis/citation/CBB000932981/)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Annals of the History and Philosophy of Biology
European Physical Journal H
French Historical Studies
História, Ciências, Saúde---Manguinhos
Be the first to comment!