Theorizing Subdisciplinary Exchange: Historical Sociology, Ethnography, and the Case of SSHA (2024)
Damon Mayrl (Author)
Nicholas Hoover Wilson (Author)
Matthew Mahler (Author)
Josh Pacewicz (Author)
Social Science History
Volume: 48
Issue: 2
Pages: 259-284
What happens at the point of interchange between scholarly communities? We examine this question by investigating the case of growing ties between historical sociology and ethnography, two social scientific methods that once seemed to have little in common. Drawing on methodological writings by ethnographers and original interviews with practicing historical sociologists, we argue that these ties have been shaped by structural and methodological homologies between the two disciplines. Structurally, ethnography and historical sociology are similarly positioned in sociology more broadly, as enterprises with sometimes-tense relationships with dominant assumptions of the social sciences. Methodologically, both ethnographers and historical sociologists face the challenges of bounding the research process, navigating access to data, analyzing and retaining data while “in the field,” and overcoming cultural distance between themselves and the worlds they are studying. Taken together, these findings extend work in the sociology of science and knowledge and suggest some key conditions for intellectual efflorescence.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Cornelius Schubert;
Andreas Kolb;
(May 2021)
Designing Technology, Developing Theory: Toward a Symmetrical Approach
Article
Reichmann, Werner;
(December 2013)
Epistemic participation: How to produce knowledge about the economic future
Book
Peter Cox;
(2019)
Cycling: A Sociology of Vélomobility
Article
Angela Fritz;
(2018)
‘I was a Sociological Stranger’: Ethnographic Fieldwork and Undercover Performance in the Publication of The Taxi-Dance Hall, 1925–1932
Article
Joeri Bruyninckx;
(September 2017)
Synchronicity: Time, Technicians, Instruments, and Invisible Repair
Book
Staum, Martin S.;
(2011)
Nature and Nurture in French Social Sciences, 1859--1914 and Beyond
Article
Gunlög Fur;
(2019)
Different Ways of Seeing ‘Savagery’: Two Nordic Travellers in 18th-Century North America
Book
Lois Benjamin;
(2024)
Ascension: The Sociology of an African American Family's Generational Journey
Article
Luís Tirapicos;
(2019)
Bibliographical Evolutions: From Archaeoastronomy to Astronomy in Culture
Article
Centellas, Kate M.;
Smardon, Regina E.;
Fifield, Steve;
(2014)
Calibrating Translational Cancer Research: Collaboration without Consensus in Interdisciplinary Laboratory Meetings
Book
Enrique Perdiguero Gil;
Josep M. Comelles;
(2015)
Medicina y etnografía en Cataluña
Article
Pierre Schneider;
(2012)
Les «climats» de Pline l’Ancien (N.H. 6, 212-220): essais de transcriptions graphiques
Article
Kruse, Corinna;
(October 2013)
The Bayesian approach to forensic evidence: Evaluating, communicating, and distributing responsibility
Chapter
Silvana Rocca;
(2015)
"Parcere parto": una "iunctura" virgiliana tra primitivismo e aspetti culturali
Book
Willard McCarty;
Geoffrey E. R. Lloyd;
Aparecida Vilaça;
(2022)
Science in the Forest, Science in the Past: Further Interdisciplinary Explorations
Article
Rafael A. Gonzalez Rivera;
Laura Cortes-Rico;
Tanya Perez-Bustos;
Manuel Franco-Avellaneda;
(2016)
Embroidering Engineering: A Case of Embodied Learning and Design of a Tangible User Interface
Article
Marko Monteiro;
(2018)
Ethnography and interdisciplinary work: Experiences from the US and Brazil
Book
Phillip Vannini;
April Vannini;
(2021)
Inhabited: Wildness and the Vitality of the Land
Book
Amber Benezra;
(2023)
Gut Anthro: An Experiment in Thinking with Microbes
Book
Arpita Roy;
(2024)
Unfinished Nature: Particle Physics at CERN
Be the first to comment!