IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB088934725

The “Indifferent Hypothesis” Redux: The Dilemmas of Pierre Duhem (2017)

Rocke, Alan J. (Author)

Historical Studies in the Natural Sciences
Volume: 47
Issue: 3
Pages: 268-292

DOI: 10.1525/hsns.2017.47.3.268

URI: http://hsns.ucpress.edu/content/47/3/268

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

In 1892, the young but already eminent physical chemist Pierre Duhem published a 64-page monograph on chemical theory. The essay comprised his first extended statement on atomic-molecular ideas in chemistry, and contained a frontal attack on the chemical atomic theory of his day. Little attention to date has been devoted to Duhem’s attitude toward the kind of chemical-atomist/structuralist “wet” chemistry that characterized most of the work of most European academic chemists during the second half of the nineteenth century. An analysis of the 1892 essay thus provides opportunity for a fresh perspective on an understanding of Duhem’s philosophy of science. We show, inter alia, that he closely followed the work and ideas of the principal champion of atomist-structural chemistry in France, Adolphe Wurtz, while also strongly condemning the work of the leader of the anti-atomist camp in France, Marcellin Berthelot; both circumstances carry powerful ironies considering Duhem’s standpoint. We seek an understanding of these ironies and dilemmas not just in scientific and philosophical but also in biographical considerations—particularly the role of religion in Duhem’s thought. This essay is part of a special issue entitled THE BONDS OF HISTORY edited by Anita Guerrini.

...More

Associated with

Article Anita Guerrini (2017) Introduction to Special Issue: The Bonds of History. Historical Studies in the Natural Sciences (pp. 263-267). unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB088934725/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Brakel, Jaap van; (2013)
František Wald's Empiricism (/isis/citation/CBB001320765/)

Book Duhem, Pierre; (2002)
Mixture and Chemical Combination: And Related Essays (/isis/citation/CBB000201354/)

Thesis Paul Timothy Greenham; (2015)
A Concord of Alchemy with Theology: Isaac Newton's Hermeneutics of the Symbolic Texts of Chymistry and Biblical Prophecy (/isis/citation/CBB546362110/)

Article Bordoni, Stafano; (2013)
Routes Towards an Abstract Thermodynamics in the Late Nineteenth Century (/isis/citation/CBB001320791/)

Article Needham, Paul; (2004)
Mixture and Chemical Combination and Related Essays: A Response to Robert Deltete and Anastasios Brenner (/isis/citation/CBB000502836/)

Article Kenichi Natsume; (2022)
Abstractive and Hypothetical Methodologies of Energetics: Physical Sciences between Mechanics and Chemistry in Victorian Britain (/isis/citation/CBB843016617/)

Article Sonia Maria Dion; (2018)
Natural Classification and Pierre Duhem's Historical Work: Which Relationships? (/isis/citation/CBB874044967/)

Book Pierre Duhem; Mirella Fortino; Jean-François Stoffel; (2022)
Realtà e rappresentazione : alle origini della "Théorie physique" (scritti 1892-1896) (/isis/citation/CBB823313741/)

Chapter Simon Mazauric; (2017)
Le continuisme de Duhem en questions (/isis/citation/CBB238568481/)

Chapter Pierre–Michel Vauthelin; (2017)
Duhem et la thermodynamique française de la fin du XIXe siècle (/isis/citation/CBB074154000/)

Chapter Carlo Vinti; (2017)
Duhem–Bachelard: per un confronto (/isis/citation/CBB098147354/)

Article Stump, David J.; (2007)
Pierre Duhem's Virtue Epistemology (/isis/citation/CBB000771905/)

Article Weber, Marcel; (2009)
The Crux of Crucial Experiments: Duhem's Problems and Inference to the Best Explanation (/isis/citation/CBB001230044/)

Chapter Mirella Fortino; (2017)
La tensione essenziale fra finzionalismo e realismo nell’epistemologia di Pierre Duhem (/isis/citation/CBB724992694/)

Book Mirella Fortino; (2017)
Pierre Duhem: Verità, ragione e metodo (/isis/citation/CBB718409602/)

Chapter Ariew, Roger; (2007)
Pierre Duhem et “l'esprit allemand” (/isis/citation/CBB001022511/)

Article Brenner, Anastasios; Needham, Paul; Stump, David J.; Deltete, Robert; (2011)
New Perspectives on Pierre Duhem's The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory (/isis/citation/CBB001032933/)

Article Zwier, Karen R.; (2011)
Dalton's Chemical Atoms versus Duhem's Chemical Equivalents (/isis/citation/CBB001230050/)

Chapter Jean-François Stoffel; (2017)
L’interprétation de l’«affaire Galilée» élaborée par Paul Mansion a–t–elle influencé Pierre Duhem? (/isis/citation/CBB304403940/)

Article Achinstein, Peter; (2007)
Atom's Empirical Eve: Methodological Disputes and How to Evaluate Them (/isis/citation/CBB000830786/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}