Discussing Patients in Private and in Print: The Records of an Eighteenth-Century Dispensary (2023)
This essay studies the variation between the ways in which physicians wrote about their patients in private and their presentation of these case histories to the wider world in print. Focusing particularly on the case of Andrew Duncan, who founded the Edinburgh Public Dispensary in 1776, this paper will investigate the differences detailed in Duncan's handwritten case notes with the ways in which he chose to portray these patient cases in his published works. This paper will argue that not only does Duncan demonstrate a tendency to exaggerate the positive outcomes from his treatments but also his published works simplify the diagnoses performed on dispensary patients. The self-editing which is apparent in his medical publishing includes the omission of details of the range of complaints individual patients suffer from and exclusion of certain disease categories, including hysteria, from the printed record. This paper will argue that a historiographical focus on printed material such as disease studies and annual reports can result in the distortion of information regarding diagnosis, medical outcomes, and the relationship between patient and practitioner during the eighteenth century.
...MoreArticle Ashleigh Blackwood; Helen Williams (2023) Writing Doctors and Writing Health in the Long Eighteenth Century. Journal for Eighteenth-Century Studies (pp. 3-20).
Similar Citations
Book
Chalmers, John;
(2010)
Andrew Duncan Senior: Physician of the Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB001230283/)
Article
Riaza Morales, José M.;
(1987)
En el centenario del experimento de Michelson-Morley: Antecedentes de la relatividad especial
(/isis/citation/CBB000056055/)
Chapter
Catherine Jones;
(2014)
Benjamin Rush, Edinburgh Medicine and the Rise of Physician Autobiography
(/isis/citation/CBB761857808/)
Book
Allen, David Elliston;
(2001)
Naturalists and Society: The Culture of Natural History in Britain, 1700-1900
(/isis/citation/CBB000100994/)
Article
Eddy, Matthew Daniel;
(2014)
How to See a Diagram: A Visual Anthropology of Chemical Affinity
(/isis/citation/CBB001550415/)
Book
Emerson, Roger L.;
(2008)
Academic Patronage in the Scottish Enlightenment: Glasgow, Edinburgh, and St. Andrews Universities
(/isis/citation/CBB000953275/)
Article
Stephen C. Craig;
(2017)
“Enquire into All the Circumstances of the Patient Narrowly”: John Rutherford’s Clinical Lectures in Edinburgh, 1749–53
(/isis/citation/CBB791097194/)
Book
McCrae, Morrice;
(2007)
Physicians and Society: A History of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh
(/isis/citation/CBB000930551/)
Article
Nenadic, Stana;
(2012)
Architect-Builders in London and Edinburgh, c. 1750--1800, and the Market for Expertise
(/isis/citation/CBB001212670/)
Article
Bill Jenkins;
(2020)
Race Before Darwin: Variation, Adaptation and the Natural History of Man in Post-Enlightenment Edinburgh, 1790–1835
(/isis/citation/CBB902634281/)
Book
Eddy, Matthew D.;
(2008)
The Language of Mineralogy: John Walker, Chemistry and the Edinburgh Medical School, 1750--1800
(/isis/citation/CBB000951069/)
Book
Hanna Hodacs;
Stéphane Van Damme;
Kenneth Nyberg;
(2018)
Linnaeus, Natural History and the Circulation of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB833759855/)
Article
Bow, Charles Bradford;
(2013)
The Science of Applied Ethics at Edinburgh University: Dugald Stewart on Moral Education and the Auxiliary Principles of the Moral Faculty
(/isis/citation/CBB001451711/)
Article
Dingwall, H. M.;
(2000)
“To be insert in the Mercury”: Medical practitioners and the press in eighteenth-century Edinburgh
(/isis/citation/CBB000110299/)
Essay Review
Oldroyd, David;
(2011)
Mineralogy, Chemistry, Botany, Medicine, Geology, Agriculture, Meteorology, Classification,…: The Life and Times of John Walker (1730--1803), Professor of Natural History at Edinburgh University
(/isis/citation/CBB001566752/)
Article
Atiyah, Michael;
(2006)
Benjamin Franklin and the Edinburgh Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB001232056/)
Article
Eddy, Matthew D.;
(2006)
The Fabric of the Globe: Chemistry and Geology in Enlightenment Edinburgh
(/isis/citation/CBB000741383/)
Article
Emerson, Roger L.;
(2004)
The Founding of the Edinburgh Medical School
(/isis/citation/CBB000774437/)
Thesis
Casteel, Eric Grier;
(2007)
Entrepot and Backwater: A Cultural History of the Transfer of Medical Knowledge from Leiden to Edinburgh, 1690--1740
(/isis/citation/CBB001561400/)
Article
Paraskevas Vezyridis;
Stephen Timmons;
(August 2021)
E-Infrastructures and the divergent assetization of public health data: Expectations, uncertainties, and asymmetries
(/isis/citation/CBB744787120/)
Be the first to comment!