Article ID: CBB085486459

On two Seventeenth century Persian paintings depicting comets or fireballs: a correction (2020)

unapi

In a recent issue of the Journal of Astronomical History and Heritage I looked into two seventeenth century Persian paintings depicting tailed objects (comets or possibly fireballs) in the sky (Kapoor, 2019). One of these, the painting by Muhammad Zaman, has a date inscribed at the lower left as 'sana 7'. Elsewhere, the date has been interpreted as the seventh year of the reign of the Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb (r. 1658‒1707) CE). Two bright comets, one in December 1664 (C/1664 W1) and another in April 1665 (C/1665 F1) had appeared during the Emperor's seveth regnal year and it was suggested by others that the comet of December 1664 could be the one portrayed by Zaman. In my work, I had inadvertently considered that the seventh regnal year ended on 24 July 1664, which therefore ruled out either of the comets, but since the recorded date of the coronation was 1 Dhu l-Qa'da 1068 AH (31 July 1658 CE Greg), Aurangzeb's seventh regnal year should be 1 Dhu l-Qa'da 1074‒ 29 Shawwal 1075 A.H. (≡26 May 1664–15 May 1665), which revives the suggestion that the comet of December 1664 or of April 1665 was the one portrayed by Zaman. The December 1664 comet rose in the morning in the S-E during its best-view dates, while the April 1665 comet remained a morning object through its visible phase. I have computed ephemerides of the comets and compared their positions in the sky with respect to some bright stars that also were observed on the best-view dates. A late night or early morning sky-watcher in Isfahan would have seen the comets rise in the S-E, or, in the N-E, but their respective orientations in the sky would have been the opposite to that portrayed in Zaman's painting where the tailed form is shown headed S-W, suggestive of an evening apparition. While the period of Aurangzeb's seventh regnal year stands corrected, this does not affect the inferences and the conclusions drawn in Kapoor (2019).

...More
Associated with

Article R. C. Kapoor (2019) On two seventeenth century Persian paintings depicting comets or fireballs. Journal of Astronomical History and Heritage (pp. 273-293). unapi

Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB085486459/

Similar Citations

Article R. C. Kapoor; (2019)
On two seventeenth century Persian paintings depicting comets or fireballs (/isis/citation/CBB992961978/)

Article Gábor Almási; (2022)
Astrology in the crossfire: the stormy debate after the comet of 1577 (/isis/citation/CBB786602400/)

Article Luca Nardi; (2023)
A Review of Two Italian 'Killer Meteorites’: Crema 1511 and Milan 1633–1664 (/isis/citation/CBB085680564/)

Book Patrick J. Boner; (2020)
Kepler’s New Star (1604): Context and Controversy (/isis/citation/CBB360331519/)

Chapter Beltrán Marí, Antonio; (2012)
Galileo, Grassi y el gran cometa de 1618. Las polémicas latentes (/isis/citation/CBB001260652/)

Article Ansari, S. M. Razaullah; (2002)
Practical Astronomy in Indo-Persian Sources (/isis/citation/CBB000340417/)

Article Christiaan Sterken; (2018)
The Great Comet of 1858: A Road Sign to the Stars (/isis/citation/CBB302198513/)

Chapter Catherine Abou-Nemeh; (2017)
Controversies over Comets: Isaac Newton, Nicolas Hartsoeker, and Early Modern World-making (/isis/citation/CBB982337013/)

Article Ting Chen; Lingfeng Lü; (2022)
Astronomical or political: Interpretation of comets in times of crisis in Qing China (/isis/citation/CBB395595446/)

Article Bari, Abdul; (2001)
Graeco-Arab Medicine in Iran during Safwi Period (/isis/citation/CBB000742018/)

Article Bari, Abdul; (2003)
Dastūr al-Hunūd: A Persian Ṭibbī Manuscript (/isis/citation/CBB000741860/)

Article Ben-Zaken, Avner; (2009)
From Naples to Goa and Back: A Secretive Galilean Messenger and a Radical Hermeneutist (/isis/citation/CBB000931550/)

Article Matthew Melvin-Koushki; (2017)
Powers of One: The Mathematicalization of the Occult Sciences in the High Persianate Tradition (/isis/citation/CBB814580335/)

Article Barker, Peter; (2017)
The Social Structure of Islamicate Science (/isis/citation/CBB589668279/)

Article Michiel Leezenberg; (2023)
From Cosmopolitan to Vernacular in the Language Sciences: A Global History Perspective (/isis/citation/CBB848075999/)

Article Volkmar Schüller; Sonja Brentjes; (2006)
Pietro Della Valle's Latin Geography of Safavid Iran (1624-1628): Introduction (/isis/citation/CBB438960455/)

Authors & Contributors
Bari, Abdul
Michiel Leezenberg
Ting Chen
Melvin-Koushki, Matthew
Lingfeng Lü
Luca Nardi
Concepts
Comets; meteors; meteorites
Controversies and disputes
Astronomy
Arab/Islamic world, civilization and culture
Cosmology
Medicine
Time Periods
17th century
16th century
18th century
Early modern
Medieval
Safavid dynasty
Places
Persia (Iran)
Portugal
Ottoman Empire
India
Velha Goa (India)
New York City (New York, U.S.)
Institutions
Jesuits (Society of Jesus)
Metropolitan Museum of Art
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment