The “Greenberg Controversy” and the Interdisciplinary Study of Global Linguistic Relationships (2023)
Kaplan, Judith R. H. (Author)
Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte
Volume: 46
Issue: 1
Pages: 114-132
This paper examines the controversy that followed the 1987 publication of Joseph Greenberg's book, Language in the Americas, attending to the role of language and linguistic research within overlapping disciplinary traditions. With this text, Greenberg presented a macro-level tripartite classification that opposed then dominant fine-grained analyses recognizing anywhere from 150 to 200 distinct language families. His proposal was the subject of a landmark conference, examining strengths and weaknesses, the unpublished proceedings of which are presented here for the first time. For specialists in the anthropological and comparative-historical study of Indigenous American languages, Greenberg's intervention highlighted the tension between language, conceived as an abstract object of study, and languages, understood to be carriers of specific cultural knowledge. For physical anthropologists and archaeologists, his theory was initially fortuitous on programmatic, substantive, and methodological grounds. The essay will show how interdisciplinary appeals were figured by supporters as a virtue, and by critics as a vice. The essay further highlights ethical reasons for integrating historical narratives of science and the humanities.
...MoreArticle Floris Solleveld (2023) Language in the Global History of Knowledge. Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte (pp. 7-17).
Similar Citations
Article
Surekha Davies;
(2014)
Science, New Worlds, and the Classical Tradition: An Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB682086951/)
Article
Charbel N. El-Hani;
Luana Poliseli;
David Ludwig;
(2022)
Beyond the divide between indigenous and academic knowledge: Causal and mechanistic explanations in a Brazilian fishing community
(/isis/citation/CBB483111553/)
Book
Householder, Michael;
(2011)
Inventing Americans in the Age of Discovery: Narratives of Encounter
(/isis/citation/CBB001201653/)
Book
Heaton, Matthew M.;
(2013)
Black Skin, White Coats: Nigerian Psychiatrists, Decolonization, and the Globalization of Psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB001202372/)
Article
Rebeca Fernández Rodríguez;
(2023)
Language, Science and Globalization in the Eighteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB980504645/)
Book
Camps, Joaquim;
Wiltshire, Caroline R;
Andersen, Henning;
(2001)
Linguistic Symposium on Romance Languages (30th: 2000: Gainesville, Florida). Romance syntax, semantics and L2 acquisition: Selected papers from the 30th Linguistic Symposium on Romance Languages, Gainesville, Florida, February 2000
(/isis/citation/CBB000100070/)
Article
Tuite, Kevin;
(2008)
The Rise and Fall and Revival of the Ibero-Caucasian Hypothesis
(/isis/citation/CBB001211637/)
Article
Swiggers, Pierre;
(2009)
David Zeisberger's Description of Delaware Morphology (1827)
(/isis/citation/CBB001211626/)
Book
Barriga Villanueva, Rebeca;
Martín Butragueño, Pedro;
(2010)
Historia sociolingüística de México
(/isis/citation/CBB001211997/)
Article
Meghan Odsliv Bratkovich;
(2018)
Shining Light on Language for, in, and as Science Content
(/isis/citation/CBB890247101/)
Article
Klein, Franz-Josef;
(2009)
Pinturas, figuras, letras: Zur Darstellung logographischer und phonographischer Schriftsysteme bei José de Acosta und Gregorio García
(/isis/citation/CBB001211629/)
Book
Krystal De Napoli;
Margo Neale;
(2022)
First Knowledges Astronomy: Sky Country
(/isis/citation/CBB626941058/)
Book
Fred Cahir;
Ian D. Clark;
Philip A. Clarke;
(2018)
Aboriginal Biocultural Knowledge in South-eastern Australia: Perspectives of Early Colonists
(/isis/citation/CBB230427791/)
Thesis
Calandra McCool;
(2016)
Native American Stories as Scientific Investigations of Nature: Indigenous Science and Methodologies
(/isis/citation/CBB631274656/)
Article
Hein van den Berg;
(2022)
Animal languages in eighteenth-century German philosophy and science
(/isis/citation/CBB285555955/)
Book
Cook, Harold John;
Dupré, Sven;
(2012)
Translating Knowledge in the Early Modern Low Countries
(/isis/citation/CBB001420402/)
Article
Métraux, Alexandre;
(2007)
Opening Remarks on the History of Science in Yiddish
(/isis/citation/CBB000720229/)
Book
Nathan Vedal;
(2022)
The Culture of Language in Ming China: Sound, Script, and the Redefinition of Boundaries of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB226349178/)
Article
Valle, Ivonne del;
(2013)
From José de Acosta to the Enlightenment: Barbarians, Climate Change, and (Colonial) Technology as the End of History
(/isis/citation/CBB001201895/)
Article
Jorge Cañizares-Esguerra;
(2018)
Bartolomé Inga’s Mining Technologies: Indians, Science, Cyphered Secrecy, and Modernity in the New World
(/isis/citation/CBB962234774/)
Be the first to comment!