Article ID: CBB074913080

Darwin’s Two Theories, 1844 and 1859 (2018)

unapi

Darwin’s first two, relatively complete, explicit articulations of his theorizing on evolution were his Essay of 1844 and On the Origin of Species published in 1859. A comparative analysis concludes that they espoused radically different theories despite exhibiting a continuity of strategy, much common structure and the same key idea. Both were theories of evolution by means of natural selection. In 1844, organic adaptation was confined to occasional intervals initiated and controlled by de-stabilization events. The modified descendants rebalanced the particular “plant and animal forms … unsettled by some alteration in their circumstances.” But by 1859, organic adaptation occurred continuously, potentially modifying the descendants of all organisms. Even natural selection, the persistent core of Darwin’s theorizing, does not prove to be a significant basis for theory similarity. Consequently, Darwin’s Origin theory cannot reasonably be considered as a mature version of the Essay. It is not a modification based on adjustments, further justifications and the integration of a Principle of Divergence. The Origin announced a new “scientific paradigm” while the Essay did little more than seemingly misconfigure the operation of a novel mechanism to extend varieties beyond their accepted bounds, and into the realm of possible new species. Two other collections of Darwin’s theorizing are briefly considered: his extensive notes of the late 1830s and his contributions to the famous meeting of 1 July 1858. For very different reasons, neither constitutes a challenge to the basis for this comparative study. It is concluded that, in addition to the much-debated social pressures, an unacknowledged further reason why Darwin did not publish his theorizing until 1859, could have been down to his perceptive technical judgement: wisely, he held back from rushing to publish demonstrably flawed theorizing.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB074913080/

Similar Citations

Article James G. Lennox; (2021)
Accentuate the negative: Locating possibility in Darwin’s ‘long argument’ (/isis/citation/CBB202149987/)

Article Holterhoff, Kate; (2014)
The History and Reception of Charles Darwin's Hypothesis of Pangenesis (/isis/citation/CBB001422092/)

Article Bellon, Richard; (2003)
“The Great Question in Agitation”: George Bentham and the Origin of Species (/isis/citation/CBB000501819/)

Thesis Michael Dee; (2016)
Roots of Charles Darwin's Creativity (/isis/citation/CBB344704069/)

Article Chancellor, Gordon; (2015)
Levels of Selection in Darwin's Origin of Species (/isis/citation/CBB001510219/)

Book Levine, George Lewis; (2006)
Darwin Loves You: Natural Selection and the Re-enchantment of the World (/isis/citation/CBB000772748/)

Article Bowler, Peter J.; (2008)
What Darwin Disturbed: The Biology That Might Have Been (/isis/citation/CBB000850417/)

Book Donohue, Kathleen; (2011)
Darwin's Finches: Readings in the Evolution of a Scientific Paradigm (/isis/citation/CBB001033158/)

Article Beer, Gillian; (2009)
Darwin and the Uses of Extinction (/isis/citation/CBB001030096/)

Chapter Sloan, Phillip R.; (2001)
“The Sense of Sublimity”: Darwin on Nature and Divinity (/isis/citation/CBB000101144/)

Article Theunissen, Bert; (2012)
Darwin and His Pigeons. The Analogy Between Artificial and Natural Selection Revisited (/isis/citation/CBB001221001/)

Article Lawson, Anton E.; (2009)
On the Hypothetico-Deductive Nature of Science---Darwin's Finches (/isis/citation/CBB001032859/)

Article Gildenhuys, Peter; (2004)
Darwin, Herschel, and the Role of Analogy in Darwin's Origin (/isis/citation/CBB000501625/)

Article Burnett, D. Graham; (2009)
Savage Selection: Analogy and Elision in On the Origin of Species (/isis/citation/CBB000932659/)

Article Richards, Robert J.; (2012)
Darwin's Principles of Divergence and Natural Selection: Why Fodor Was Almost Right (/isis/citation/CBB001221609/)

Article Deichmann, Ute; (2010)
Gemmules and Elements: On Darwin's and Mendel's Concepts and Methods in Heredity (/isis/citation/CBB001230066/)

Article Thierry Hoquet; (2021)
Pluralizing Darwin: Making Counter-Factual History of Science Significant (/isis/citation/CBB581465929/)

Article Ian Hesketh; (2021)
Narratives of Charles Darwin Down Under (/isis/citation/CBB437714128/)

Authors & Contributors
Robert Ready
Michael Dee
Wilmer, Clive
Holterhoff, Kate
van Wyhe, John
Theunissen, Bert
Concepts
Evolution
Natural selection
Darwinism
Biology
Metaphors; analogies
Species concept (biology)
Time Periods
19th century
20th century
21st century
Places
Great Britain
Blue Mountains (New South Wales)
Tasmania (Australia)
New South Wales (Australia)
England
Malay; Malaysia
Institutions
Linnean Society of London
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment