‘Revolutions, Philosophical as Well as Civil’: French Chemistry and American Science in Samuel Latham Mitchill’s Medical Repository (2020)
Apel, Thomas (Author)
Annals of Science: The History of Science and Technology
Volume: 77
Issue: 2
Pages: 189-214
From 1797 to 1801 a controversy played out on the pages of the Medical Repository, the first scientific journal published in the United States. At its centre was the well-known feud between the followers of Antoine Lavoisier and Joseph Priestley, the lone supporter of the phlogiston model. The American debate, however, had more than two sides. The Americans chemists, Samuel Latham Mitchill and Benjamin Woodhouse, who rushed to support Priestley did not defend his scientific views. Rather, as citizens of a republic, they defended his right to have them. They also castigated the assertions of the “French chemists,” whose claims that the new chemistry obviated debate seemed unsettlingly similar to the dictatorial ambitions of the French state. Using the Medical Repository, Mitchill and Woodhouse sought a compromise that validated the new chemistry, but united it with a more egalitarian form of discourse. The desired balance eluded them. Priestley proved too stubborn, and as the French Revolution descended into dictatorship and war, Mitchill and Woodhouse came more to realize that truly prising French chemistry from the culture of the revolutionary era. The episode left Mitchill and Woodhouse disillusioned with chemistry and hoping to redirect scientific enthusiasm to more pious ends.
...MoreArticle John R. R. Christie (2020) Atlantic Chemistries, 1600–1820. Annals of Science: The History of Science and Technology (pp. 135-138).
Similar Citations
Article
J. Marc Macdonald;
(2020)
Failed Utopias and Practical Chemistry: The Priestleys, the Du Ponts, and the Transmission of Transatlantic Science, 1770–1820
(/isis/citation/CBB179199218/)
Book
Marco Beretta;
Paolo Brenni;
(2022)
The Arsenal of Eighteenth-Century Chemistry: The Laboratories of Antoine Laurent Lavoisier (1743-1794)
(/isis/citation/CBB674187148/)
Book
Bensaude-Vincent, Bernadette;
Blondel, Christine;
(2008)
Science and Spectacle in the European Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB000850395/)
Article
Kevin de Berg;
(2014)
Teaching Chemistry for All Its Worth: The Interaction Between Facts, Ideas, and Language in Lavoisier’s and Priestley’s Chemistry Practice: The Case of the Study of the Composition of Air
(/isis/citation/CBB545912602/)
Thesis
Basu, Prajit K.;
(1992)
Scientific explanation in the history of chemistry: The Priestley-Lavoisier debate
(/isis/citation/CBB001564400/)
Article
Bret, Patrice;
(2012)
Lavoisier, Guyton de Morveau e Berthollet, químicos e correspondentes (1772--1822): formas e usos da correspondéncia científica em torno da Revolução
(/isis/citation/CBB001212603/)
Book
Jackson, Joe;
(2005)
A World on Fire: A Heretic, an Aristocrat, and the Race to Discover Oxygen
(/isis/citation/CBB000600699/)
Book
Djerassi, Carl;
Hoffmann, Roald;
(2001)
Oxygen: A Play in Two Acts
(/isis/citation/CBB000430084/)
Article
Basu, Prajit K.;
(2003)
Theory-Ladenness of Evidence: A Case Study from History of Chemistry
(/isis/citation/CBB000340883/)
Article
Crosland, Maurice;
(2003)
Research Schools of Chemistry from Lavoisier to Wurtz
(/isis/citation/CBB000340618/)
Article
Ricci, Patricia Likos;
(2012)
Joseph Priestley House
(/isis/citation/CBB001200548/)
Article
Beretta, Marco;
(1993)
Chemists in the storm: Lavoisier, Priestley and the French Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000044966/)
Article
Sánchez, José Ramón Bertomeu;
García Belmar, Antonio;
(2000)
Mateu Orfila's Elémens de Chimie Médicale and the Debate about Medical Applications of Chemistry in Early Nineteenth-Century France
(/isis/citation/CBB000111703/)
Book
Johnson, Steven;
(2008)
The Invention of Air: A Story of Science, Faith, Revolution, and the Birth of America
(/isis/citation/CBB000954683/)
Article
Levere, Trevor H.;
(2009)
Dr. Thomas Beddoes: Chemistry, Medicine, and the Perils of Democracy
(/isis/citation/CBB000932256/)
Article
Beretta, Marco;
(2011)
Rinman, Diderot, and Lavoisier: New Evidence regarding Guillaume-François Rouelle's Private Laboratory and Chemistry Course
(/isis/citation/CBB001024836/)
Article
Francesca Antonelli;
(2022)
Becoming Visible: Marie-Anne Paulze-Lavoisier and the Campaign for the “New Chemistry” (1770s-1790s)
(/isis/citation/CBB123830478/)
Book
Francesca Antonelli;
(2022)
Scrivere e sperimentare. Marie-Anne Paulze-Lavoisier, segretaria della “nuova chimica” (1771-1836)
(/isis/citation/CBB411296016/)
Book
Fauque, Danielle;
(2003)
Lavoisier et la Naissance de la Chimie Moderne
(/isis/citation/CBB000650469/)
Article
Matthews, Michael R.;
(2009)
Science and Worldviews in the Classroom: Joseph Priestley and Photosynthesis
(/isis/citation/CBB001032844/)
Be the first to comment!