Hysteria, head injuries and heredity: ‘Shell-shocked’ soldiers of the Royal Edinburgh Asylum, Edinburgh (1914–24) (2022)
Joanna Park (Author)
Louise Neilson (Author)
Demetriades, Andreas K. (Author)
Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science
Volume: 77
Issue: 3
Pages: 443-470
This project illustrates as-yet-uncharted psychiatric patients from the Royal Edinburgh Asylum (REA) around the time of World War I, predominantly ‘shell-shocked’ soldiers. Primary patient notes help to elucidate definitions, symptoms and perceptions of ‘shell-shock’, in addition to its links with other psychiatric conditions. This includes general paralysis of the insane (GPI), alcohol excess, mania and melancholia. Whereas the majority of these patients were suffering from shell-shock, it is not once explicitly listed as a diagnosis; it was a term whose use was discouraged by the War Office and key medical experts from 1916 onwards. As such, this paper demonstrates effects that canonical views held by the War Office and military psychiatrists on shell-shock aetiology had on language used in psychiatric patient notes. The results corroborate wartime views that mental distress due to a physical head injury was preferable to shell-shock without obvious cause; that neurasthenia was a more desirable diagnostic label than hysteria; and that mental illness was predominantly due to an inherited flaw in someone's character. Language used by psychiatrists to describe their patients was influenced by contemporary perspectives on gender, class and mental illness. More broadly, this paper adds to discussions about definitions and symptomatology of shell-shock that are being uncovered in historical patient notes from this period.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Linden, Stefanie Caroline;
Jones, Edgar;
(2014)
“Shell Shock” Revisited: An Examination of the Case Records of the National Hospital in London
Book
Rebecca Ayako Bennette;
(2020)
Diagnosing Dissent: Hysterics, Deserters, and Conscientious Objectors in Germany During World War One
Article
AD (Sandy) Macleod;
(2018)
Abrupt treatments of hysteria during World War I, 1914–18
Book
Mark Osborne Humphries;
(2018)
A Weary Road: Shell Shock in the Canadian Expeditionary Force, 1914-1918
Book
Tracey Loughran;
(2017)
Shell-Shock and Medical Culture in First World War Britain
Book
Michael Robinson;
(2020)
Shell-shocked British Army veterans in Ireland, 1918-39: A difficult homecoming
Book
Andrea Gräfin von Hohenthal;
(2023)
Griff nach der Psyche?: Psychologie im Ersten Weltkrieg in Großbritannien und Deutschland
Thesis
Arnaud, Sabine M.;
(2007)
Narratives and Politics of a Diagnosis: The Construction and Circulation ofHysteria as a Medical Category, 1730--1820
Article
Loughran, Tracey;
(2008)
Hysteria and Neurasthenia in Pre-1914 British Medical Discourse and in Histories of Shell-Shock
Article
Bernabeu-Mestre, J.;
Cid Santos, A. P.;
Esplugues Pellicer, J. X.;
Galiana-Sánchez, M. E.;
(2008)
Categorías diagnósticas y género: los ejemplos de la clorosis y la neurastenia en la medicina española contemporánea (1877--1936)
Article
Jones, Edgar;
Wessely, Simon;
(2005)
War Syndromes: The Impact of Culture on Medically Unexplained Symptoms
Article
Donato Bragatto;
Adello Vanni;
(2022)
Le nevrosi di guerra, l’anafilassi psichica e la sedizione criminaloide a Villa del Seminario (1916-1917)
Book
Mark C. Wilkins;
(2019)
Aero-Neurosis: Pilots of the First World War and the Psychological Legacies of Combat
Article
Meyer, Jessica;
(2009)
Separating the Men from the Boys: Masculinity and Maturity in Understandings of Shell Shock in Britain
Article
Lestrade, Cécile;
Gayral, Louis-François;
(2000)
Les psychoses de guerre pendant le conflit 1914-1918: L'apport du Dr Paul Voivenel: le concept de “peur morbide acquise”
Article
Jones, Edgar;
(2010)
Shell Shock at Maghull and the Maudsley: Models of Psychological Medicine in the UK
Article
Ayres, P. G.;
(2015)
Isaac Bayley Balfour, Sphagnum Moss, and the Great War (1914--1918)
Book
Tyquin, Michael;
(2006)
Madness and the Military: Australia's Experience of the Great War
Article
Stefanie Caroline Linden;
(2021)
When war came home: air-raid shock in World War I
Article
Larsson, Marina;
(2009)
Families and Institutions for Shell-Shocked Soldiers in Australia after the First World War
Be the first to comment!